March 21, 2023 Breaking News, Latest News, and Videos

Dylan in China: Not An Opera:

Operas are usually dramatic, to say the least.  There are songs of emotional torment, followed by florid suicide scenes, followed by songs of emotional torment over florid suicides.   In 1987 composer John Adams and librettist Alice Goodman premiered their opera, “Nixon in China,” which used Nixon’s “opening” of China as the storyline for a new opera that Adams saw as “part epic, part satire, part a parody of political posturing.” 

On April 6 singer and songwriter Bob Dylan appeared in concert in China for the first time.  It seems that some felt that Dylan’s appearance should have had some of the elements Adams ascribed to his work, and more of that classic opera drama.  Alas, it appears that “Zimmy” simply showed up and did his professional job, and then went home.  But in the crushed expectations of those taking Dylan to task for not somehow providing a more transcendent moment in China, maybe we are provided with a transcendent moment of another sort.  

The highest profile Dylan-in-China basher might have been New York Times columnist Maureen Dowd, who turned her gaze away from a planet on fire with rioting and war to take a 69 year-old folk singer to task for not singing the right “anthems” while he was inside a “dictatorship.”   Dylan allowed Chinese officials to pre-approve his set list of songs, and Dowd says this means that Dylan has “broken new ground in selling out.”  Later she turns Dylan’s own lyrics on him, implying that “All the money you made / will never buy back your soul.”  Thanks, Ms. Dowd.  We now have our emotional torment, or at least, yours.  

There’s so much to contemplate in the expectation that Bob Dylan must carry a specific message into China that I’m not certain I’ll give Dowd’s angst proper consideration here. But let’s start with the general notion that because Bob Dylan authored certain works of gripping beauty at the time of the American Civil Rights movement, he somehow disappoints us when he doesn’t perform those specific works in the China of today.  And Dowd was clearly disappointed, citing Dylan’s “whole new kind of sellout” as worse than “Usher crooning to Qaddafi’s family, or Elton John raking in a fortune to serenade gay-bashers at Rush Limbaugh’s fourth wedding.” 

Full disclosure: I was absorbed with Dylan in my college years and fairly studied the guy in the books available then.  That culminated in hitch-hiking to Hibbing, Minnesota with a roommate to see Dylan’s hometown.   So I feel I can speak with some credibility on Dylan’s roots.  In high school, Dylan wanted to be Little Richard.  He allegedly broke the pedal off of a school upright piano in an attempt to get more sound out of it during a student talent show.  It was always going to be about rock music. 

But when Dylan arrived at college, he quickly assessed the situation:  Folk music is what “goes over” right now.  And he didn’t need to gather a band.  He bought a harmonica holder and started writing songs. Not to take all the romance out of the music of our lives, but Dylan made a business decision.  An impressive number of those folk songs turned out to be truly great, with melodies that stayed in mind and messages that hit the center of the storm.  At the time Bob Dylan was crafting careful and meaningful poetry meshed to melody, most Americans were listening to the Beach Boys, Leslie Gore, Al Martino, and Bobby Vinton.  Skeeter Davis had a big hit right around the time of “Blowing in the Wind” with “The End of the World, ”although it was hardly the nuclear-blasted end Dylan’s emerging constituency would later contemplate.  

Dylan, especially these days, might be the first to tell you that he’s never seen himself as all that different from Skeeter Davis.  And Davis was no pushover. In 1973, during a performance at the Grand Ole Opry, Davis dedicated a gospel song to street evangelists arrested by Nashville police. America was divided during those last days of the Nixon administration, and The Grand Ole Opry had conservative management. Thanks to her “political” commentary, Davis was suspended from the Opry.  We’ll never know if she would have stood up to interference with her set list in China.  

Dylan has never accepted that he has a role he must play.  But as an artist, and not just a building contractor or advance man for KFC, did Dylan have an obligation to create a confrontation between his most inspiring work and the political reality of China? 

There are creative people who view all of their output as an opportunity to say something. And it’s not unexpected that we hold those artists to a higher standard than, say, the writers at any animation factory turning out the third or fourth sequel of a once-charming idea.  But I believe Dylan created a significant event simply by performing in China, and further that he acknowledged the complexity of his world view in defying any one categorization of his appearance.  Maybe the man feels that as an American he has no business lecturing other countries right now in light of Iraq, Abu Ghraib, or the cupidity represented by the Gulf oil spill.  And that would be very different from Maureen Dowd, who feels there’s no problem taking time off from any number of serious crisis situations to hector Bob Dylan in the New York Times, for which she will be handsomely paid.  

in Opinion
Related Posts

Column: SB 9 Ended R-1 Zoning, but It’s Not Meeting Goals

March 11, 2023

March 11, 2023

By Tom Elias More than a year after it took effect, the landmark housing density law known as SB 9...

SMa.r.t. Column: The Urgency to Retrofit Earthquake-Deficient Buildings

March 6, 2023

March 6, 2023

Recent early-morning tremors off the Malibu coast, and the huge and terrible earthquake in Turkey and Syria have made us...

SMa.r.t. Column: ​​Reinforcing the Future – A Revisit

February 27, 2023

February 27, 2023

Six years go we discussed, in these pages, the city’s then-renewed earthquake-retrofit rules. At the time we argued that the...

Column: The Inevitable Conversions Begin Multiplying

February 25, 2023

February 25, 2023

By Tom Elias It’s a phenomenon from New York to Dallas to Fresno and Los Angeles, one that seemed inevitable...

Column: The Fantasy World of California Housing Policy

February 20, 2023

February 20, 2023

By Tom Elias If you’re looking for sure things among bills under consideration in the state Legislature, think of one...

SMa.r.t. Column: Santa Monica City Council – Planners, Politicians, or Developers?

February 19, 2023

February 19, 2023

Santa Monica – a progressive city 20 years ago, a chaotic city today! A city that is struggling for its...

SMa.r.t. Column: What’s Wrong With This Picture?

February 16, 2023

February 16, 2023

The picture shown above is the future of Santa Monica. Large tall buildings along the Boulevards and Avenues plus Downtown...

SMa.r.t. Column: To a Better Housing Element

February 3, 2023

February 3, 2023

Your City is busy rewriting much of its zoning code to implement our new Housing Element as demanded by the...

Santa Monica Police Chief’s Message to the Community

January 30, 2023

January 30, 2023

January 27, 2023  Dear Santa Monica Community,  The Santa Monica Police Department (SMPD) would like to extend our heartfelt condolences...

Column: State Usurping Key Powers From Cities

January 28, 2023

January 28, 2023

By Tom Elias All over California last fall, hundreds of the civic minded spent thousands of hours and millions of...

Column – A California Positive: Kids Swarm Extra Classes

January 24, 2023

January 24, 2023

By Tom Elias It’s become a cliché, the shibboleth that California has lousy public schools and most of the kids...

SMa.r.t. Column: Let’s Get Real and Apply Practical Common Sense

January 20, 2023

January 20, 2023

This week’s column is a letter to the City Council, written by Arthur Jeon and sent in this past week....

SMa.r.t. Column: Water Water Everywhere

January 13, 2023

January 13, 2023

The new year has started with water, lots of WATER. The west coast and particularly central and northern California have...

S.M.a.r.t. Looks Ahead

December 31, 2022

December 31, 2022

It’s that time of the year again, when people and organizations look ahead and make resolutions to try to do...

SMa.r.t. Column: Refugees in our Midst

December 22, 2022

December 22, 2022

We published this article exactly five years ago. We leave it to the reader to consider whether this article is...