July 1, 2025 Breaking News, Latest News, and Videos

Santa Monica Accused of Not Explaining Denied Parking Appeals:

When motorists get parking tickets in Santa Monica, some pay for their tickets within the allotted time while others decide to contest their citations through a process that is mandated by state law. In 2010 the City of Santa Monica collected nearly $16.5 million in revenue from parking fines. In 2006 that figure was more than $13.6 million – an increase of about $715,000 a year on average.

The state law for contesting tickets changed in 2008. Those changes took effect in January 2009. The current process includes an initial review of the correspondence from the person who received the ticket by the City’s parking violations office. This correspondence must include the reasons why the individual believes they were inappropriately ticketed. It must be submitted within 21 days after the ticket was issued.

However, the parking fine does not have to be submitted. The person then receives a letter, which includes a decision on the initial review. If the individual’s reasons are found valid, the letter states the ticket’s dismissal. If the reasons are found invalid, the law requires that a statement be provided explaining why the ticket is not being dismissed. The ticket holder then has the option to appeal a second time if their ticket is not dismissed.

In 2010, according to the Santa Monica City attorney’s office and the finance department, the Santa Monica Police Department issued 288,092 parking citations of which 20,307 of were contested.

The second appeal includes paying the citation fine and requesting an administrative hearing within 21 days of the date the initial review letter was issued. The individual will then receive a letter stating whether the ticket was dismissed. If the ticket is dismissed, the ticket holder will receive a refund through the mail for the amount of the parking fine. Once again, if the ticket is not dismissed an explanation must be given as to the reasons it was not dismissed. If the ticket is not dismissed the ticket holder can appeal this decision in court by paying a $25 fee.

For 2010, the number of citations dismissed in favor of the appellant after the initial review was 9,891, almost half of those contested. The number of those heard by the hearing officer was 2,062 (10.15 percent of the contested) and the number dismissed by the hearing officer was 158 (7.66 percent of those heard). In that year alone, there were 53 court appeals and 41 of those tickets (77.36 percent) were dismissed in favor of the appellant.

In February of 2011, Santa Monica resident Harriet Epstein received a parking ticket and decided to appeal it. She wrote a letter to the City’s parking violations office explaining why she believed she should not have received the ticket. She then received a computer-generated letter that stated the result for the initial review. Her citation was not dismissed and there were no reasons given. The letter just stated, “The review has confirmed that the citation was properly issued and is valid. The reason given does not invalidate the citation.”

Epstein appealed again by going to an administrative hearing. Her husband, attorney Stan Epstein, attended the hearing as her legal representative. After the hearing, she received a letter saying that the citation was valid, but no explanation of why her citation could not be dismissed was given.

Stan Epstein then complained. He said he pointed out that the City was not following the state mandated procedures for contesting parking citations by not giving specific reasons why the ticket was not dismissed.

Alan Seltzer from the City attorney’s office reviewed the complaint but would not speak directly to the Santa Monica Mirror about the issue. Don Patterson, the City’s business and revenues operations manager, issued a statement on May 4. Patterson said that the City attorney’s office looked over the City’s citation administrative review process and concluded the following: “Our current administrative processes and notices meet the minimum requirements of applicable state law. The City continuously reviews all of our processes in an ongoing effort to improve customer service and we have been in the process of reviewing and updating various parking related notices over the past several months.”

Before the statement was issued, Joe Lawrence from the City attorney’s office said the City’s parking review procedures “were consistent with other cities.”

Epstein reacted to the City’s statement in an e-mail to the Mirror. “The pathetic attempt by City lawyers … is a bad faith effort to support their advice in 2008 which resulted in daily conduct by the City and its processing agency that violates California law and has cost motorists millions in fines that should not have been paid to Santa Monica … Simply saying ‘the citation is valid,’ as the City does twice, gives the trier of fact no information as to what the City is saying in response to the particular claims of the motorist in each individual case,” Epstein said. “Furthermore, the motorist is assisted in deciding whether to appeal when the City provides a specific reason countering her statements.”

In an e-mail to the Mirror, Harriet Epstein said, “It’s disgraceful for the City to illegally collect parking violation fines from motorists by breaking California state law. You can’t violate the law to enforce the law. I think everyone who has ever contested a Santa Monica parking ticket and paid a fine should demand a refund.”

in News
<>Related Posts

Three-Bed Palisades Highlands Townhouse Hits Market for $1.7M

June 30, 2025

June 30, 2025

The Mediterranean-style property, located at 1529 Michael Lane, is part of a 71-unit community A remodeled 1,919-square-foot townhouse in the...

Six-Bed Mar Vista Hilltop Home Under Construction Lists for $5.3M

June 30, 2025

June 30, 2025

The private backyard is complete with a pool, spa, fire pit, built-in BBQ, and areas for outdoor dining A stunning...

(Video) Getty Villa Reopens Six Months After Dodging Destruction of Palisades Wildfires

June 29, 2025

June 29, 2025

With the reopening also comes a new exhibit, “The Kingdom of Pylos” Getty Villa Reopens Six Months After Dodging Destruction...

Free Virtual Planetarium Shows Coming to SMC in July

June 29, 2025

June 29, 2025

The virtual format is in place as construction of the new SMC Planetarium and Observatory nears completion The Santa Monica...

Santa Monica Adopts $793.3M Budget for FY25-27, Prioritizing Housing and Safety

June 29, 2025

June 29, 2025

The budget preserves core services and invests in major projects, including over $1 billion in hotel investments The Santa Monica...

Iranian Pastor in West L.A. Speaks as Church Rocked by Immigration Raids 

June 28, 2025

June 28, 2025

Five Detained as Fear Spreads Through Persian Christian Faith Community  Fear has spread through a West Los Angeles congregation after...

California Doubles Down on Hollywood: $750M in Tax Credits Approved for Film and TV Industry

June 28, 2025

June 28, 2025

State Lawmakers Back Major Expansion of Production Incentives, Raising Job Projections Los Angeles’ film and television industry is poised to...

Park: “Our Water Infrastructure Must Be Emergency-Ready Every Day”

June 28, 2025

June 28, 2025

Councilwoman expressed cautious relief at the news but emphasized the need for robust infrastructure The Los Angeles Department of Water...

Washington Square Pizza Opens to the Public

June 28, 2025

June 28, 2025

New York Style Pizza “By-The-Slice” Now at the Beach By Nick Antonicello  Washington Square Pizza formally opened its doors today...

California Allocates $5B for Road Repairs, Transit Expansion

June 28, 2025

June 28, 2025

The funding aims to improve road safety, reduce traffic congestion, and promote cleaner transportation California is investing nearly $5 billion...

THIS SUNDAY: Palisades Symphony Presents “Best of Broadway”

June 28, 2025

June 28, 2025

The performance will feature a full orchestra playing iconic selections, from John Philip Sousa’s *El Capitan* and George Gershwin’s *The...

LAPD Updates Immigration FAQ to Clarify Enforcement Role

June 27, 2025

June 27, 2025

The document, available in English and Spanish, outlines the department’s policies and limits regarding immigration status The Los Angeles Police...

Three Santa Monica College Student Films Selected for International Film Festival

June 27, 2025

June 27, 2025

The LA Shorts International Film Festival, the city’s longest-running shorts festival, screens over 350 films annually and draws 10,000 attendees...

EEEEEATSCON Los Angeles Returns with Star Chefs, Firefighter Tribute, and Wildfire Relief Efforts

June 27, 2025

June 27, 2025

Culinary Festival Features Exclusive Restaurant Collabs, Support for Small Businesses  EEEEEATSCON Los Angeles, the celebrated food festival curated by The...

Suspect Charged by Los Angeles DA with Shooting of Santa Monica Cop and Teens

June 27, 2025

June 27, 2025

Faces Attempted Murder Charges and Over 100 Years to Life in Prison if Convicted. Criminal charges have been filed against...