June 29, 2022 Breaking News, Latest News, and Videos

Santa Monica City Hall Mulls Nativity Scene Ban:

The weather may be heating up and the official start of summer is less than one month away, yet the Santa Monica City Council was rather occupied about the onset of winter at its Tuesday meeting, courtesy of a potential ordinance banning nativity scenes and other religious or non-religious displays at Palisades Park.

For nearly 60 years, City Hall had allowed nativity scenes and other displays to be erected at Palisades Park during the Christmas and holiday season despite a blanket prohibition of showcasing private structures in Santa Monica’s public parks.

However, last December there were more individuals and groups seeking to erect displays than there was space for, forcing City Hall to rely upon a random lottery to determine who would be granted access to the limited display space at Palisades Park.

In the months that have passed since, City Hall has contemplated banning all displays at Palisades Park in hopes of averting courtroom showdowns or legal settlements of any sort. On May 22, City Hall and council members took one step closer toward determining whether to codify the banning of all winter displays at Palisades Park.

With neither a deliberation nor a vote, council members are expected to take up the issue again at its next public meeting on June 12 and perhaps come to a vote on a proposed ordinance.

A major issue in crafting a new ordinance and policy direction with respect to nativity scenes and winter displays: City Hall cannot have a system in place that, City Attorney Marsha Jones Moutrie told council members, appears to favor “the content of one set of displays over others.”

Acknowledging community support to allow nativity scenes to remain in place, Moutrie warned council members from ultimately adopting a policy that would appear objective on paper but indirectly allow the display of nativity scenes. Doing so may pose legal complications, she inferred.

“Because of the First Amendment restrictions, we don’t have an array of choices,” Moutrie said. “We have … two general choices. One general choice is that we can allow winter displays without regard to their content, because we can’t censor First Amendment expression in the park. Or, we can prohibit winter displays in the park.”

Moutrie added the general rule of law governing all Santa Monica area parks is to prohibit structural displays of any kind. Palisades Park’s winter displays have been, by ordinance, the only exception.

The sentiment during public comment ranged from allowing the nativity scenes to remain as an exercise of freedom of speech and maintaining tradition to acknowledging the difficulty providing a fair forum for celebratory religious expression on public land.

Supporters expressed concern that if nativity scenes were ultimately banned, Santa Monica would lose a sense of community.

“I don’t think it’s right to take it away from the community,” Santa Monica native Judy Mulligan told council members. “This has been something that has brought the community together. It brought businesses together.”

If approved in its current form, the ordinance would eliminate private, unattended winter displays in Palisades Park, eliminate legal risks, save “staff time and resources necessary to operate a constitutionally valid regulatory system,” and protect “the views of the park and ocean from Ocean Avenue without precluding the installation of displays on other non-governmental property.”

The prohibition would conform the “usage of Palisades Park to the long standing, City-wide standard which prohibits unattended displays in parks,” a staff report to council members stated.

A pair of state case laws governs how cities may regulate religious and non-religious holiday displays in city parks.

The 1993 Ninth Circuit case Kreisner v. San Diego stated: “a City may permit private displays through a content-neutral permit allocation process.” Three years later, the same court in Jewish Congress v. Beverly Hills ruled: “a City, which allows religious displays in a park, cannot refuse to allow other displays in the park protesting the religious displays.”

“Based on these cases, staff explained that the City cannot favor particular displays, including Nativity displays, and cannot prohibit displays that criticize other displays,” the staff report said.

Of course, nativity scene supporters contend City Hall does not have to be so stringent in regulating displays at Palisades Park. In an attempt to find a middle ground, nativity scene backers suggested City Hall consider reforming the rules of applying for the winter displays and allowing a “holiday decoration forum.”

It was in 1953 when the first nativity scene was displayed in a public setting. According to Nativity Scenes Committee Chairman Hunter Jameson, the Santa Monica Chamber of Commerce partnered with community churches to start the display in 1953 in an attempt to “attract more visitors and shoppers to town.”

“The business alliance continued as a major donor and organizer until 1982, when tough financial times forced its exit,” Jameson said.

in News
Related Posts

Six Family-Fun Westside Fourth of July Events

June 29, 2022

June 29, 2022

Fireworks, parades, runs and more taking place across the Westside  By Ashley Sloan  Pacific Palisades  The Pacific Palisades will be...

California Credit Union Awards Grant to Santa Monica Teacher

June 29, 2022

June 29, 2022

Building electric circuit friendship detectors and applying engineering principles to solve real world problems are Westside school projects receiving funding...

Santa Monica’s Building Bridges Art Exchange Presents: J.J. Martin’s “Role Models”

June 28, 2022

June 28, 2022

A traveling exhibit in partnership with Indianilla Cultural Center, Mexico City and Real de Catorce Cultural Center, Real de Catorce,...

Santa Monica City Council Approves New Rules to Streamline Meetings

June 28, 2022

June 28, 2022

Pilot program will run through end of year By Dolores Quintana At the Santa Monica City Council meeting on June...

Banning Construction of New Gas Stations in Los Angeles?

June 28, 2022

June 28, 2022

Motion from LA City Councilmember Paul Koretz calls for banning the building of any new gas pumping facilities By Sam...

Child Of Elon Musk Receives Approval For Name And Gender Change: Santa Monica Beat – June 27th, 2022

June 27, 2022

June 27, 2022

Local news and culture in under 5 minutes.* Child Of Elon Musk Receives Approval For Name And Gender Change * Smash...

Pico Boulevard Affordable Housing Project Tops Out

June 27, 2022

June 27, 2022

Brunson Terrance coming to 1819 Pico Boulevard in Santa Monica By Dolores Quintana Community Corp. of Santa Monica has completed...

The Los Angeles Real Estate Market May Finally Be Slowing Down

June 24, 2022

June 24, 2022

Real estate sales drop 21 percent in past year By Dolores Quintana The Los Angeles real estate market is showing...

Redevelopment Complete of Former Westside Pavilion Macy’s

June 24, 2022

June 24, 2022

Developer announces complete of West End at Pico and Overland Developer HLW, on behalf of GPI Companies and in partnership...

Mayor Himmelrich’s Tax Transfer Measure Is Favored to Qualify for the November Election

June 24, 2022

June 24, 2022

In a cursory review, the City Clerk’s office verified 10,277 of the over 11,000 signatures  By Dolores Quintana Santa Monica...

Active Shooter Training Set for Santa Monica Middle School Friday

June 23, 2022

June 23, 2022

Drill to take place at John Adams Middle School Friday morning By Sam Catanzaro ​​An active shooter training will take...

Metro Church and Cafe Fundraising To Keep Space in Santa Monica

June 23, 2022

June 23, 2022

Non-profit church and coffee shop shut down following false vermin complaint By Dolores Quintana Metropolis Santa Monica is a multi-use...

New Coffee Shop Open on Montana Avenue

June 23, 2022

June 23, 2022

Go Get ‘Em Tiger up and running on corner of Montana and 10th  By Dolores Quintana A new coffee shop...

15-Year Department Veteran Selected as Santa Monica’s Next Director of Library Services

June 22, 2022

June 22, 2022

Erica Cuyugan leads Santa Monica Public Library After performing a nationwide search, the City of Santa Monica recently selected Erica...