July 5, 2025 Breaking News, Latest News, and Videos

Nativity Scenes Or Naïve Activity Scene?:

It’s June, always a great time to get riled-up early about whether or not those nativity scenes with the mannequins should return to Palisades Park this Christmas. Before I launch into any discussion about that, you are probably owed a few disclaimers.

Full disclosure: I grew up Methodist in Wisconsin. Because of my age, I was a kid at a time when there was never any issue that the birth of Jesus might be represented in people’s front yards by means of molded plastic figurines with light bulbs in them. We never had any of those in our own front yard, which instead featured flood lights and a plywood cut-out of the ubiquitous Coca Cola Santa, sans Coke bottle.

Second disclosure: My favorite statement on the meaning of Christmas continues to be the animated “A Charlie Brown Christmas” TV special. It’s charming, beatnik hip, appealing, and funny. And it still manages to capture a true spirit of the holiday season if not the only spirit of the holidays for all. It may not surprise you to learn that initially execs at CBS Television were not big on the show. Then it aired as a special on Dec. 9, 1965 and drew in 15.4 million viewers, placing it second in the ratings that week after the western series “Bonanza.” We’ll return to the Peanuts gang in a moment.

It might be time to deal with some hard truths about the Palisades nativity scene dust-up. The decorations themselves, first displayed in 1953 and by mere dint of that somehow “traditional” for Santa Monica, now have a somewhat dingy and even bizarre appearance. To protect the mannequin scenes, each is covered with storm fencing that causes the entire display to look like the figures are being held for questioning. Any uplifting impact the display might have is, by my lights, mitigated by its real appearance.

America in 1953 was more like the Wisconsin neighborhood of my youth. Times have changed. We now recognize and accept that the time of the year we call “the holiday season” involves celebrations of all kinds, not just the story of the nativity. Yet I feel that any attempts to mitigate the Palisades display with balancing displays reflecting other views, whether fairly realized by a lottery or not, are doomed to only reduce the potential for the entire tableau to echo any sort of joy.

In dealing honestly with the Palisades display issue, it should be recognized by all sides that a city park public land venue holiday display that leans heavily on any one religion or religious view has an inherent advocacy or even proselytizing intent: It’s just naïve to think otherwise. But it’s in this simultaneously clear yet often murky area that Santa Monica struggles with the Palisades nativity issue. The Christian holiday of Christmas becomes “Christmas time,” and that “time” becomes a default zone in which representations of the nativity seem natural and even correct. And then because that’s been the case for decades, attacks on nativity representations become attacks on “tradition.”

A few years back the folks that manage the Third Street Promenade invested in holiday decorations that featured a theme of ice and snow, beautifully evading any religious issues. While Christmas reds and greens appear here and there in the Promenade’s display there’s also a lot of blue ice and silver white snow, blue and silver/white being traditional Hanukkah colors. The Promenade loves the holiday season for obvious reasons, and most definitely does not intend to put-off any potential shoppers. I now find their wily navigation of potential conflicts to be contemporary and pleasing. I like the downtown temporary ice skating rink, open to skaters of all faiths, even better.

But a person who likes traditional holiday representation might quibble. And I don’t think we need more plastic ice floes installed in Palisades Park. So what are we to do about the Palisades nativity scenes? There’s a quandary in the City asserting that the nativity scenes be banned, because it will feel like a loss of freedom of speech no matter how you parse it. Yet I strongly disagree with those who assert that the loss of the nativity scenes would cause Santa Monica to lose a sense of community.

Allow me to call on Linus from the Peanuts gang to help me make a modest proposal. In the aforementioned TV special, Linus uses his endearing scratchy voice to remind Charlie Brown “what Christmas is all about.” True, he then quotes from the Gospel of Luke. But Linus ends on this: “… and on earth, peace, good will toward men.”

Linus of course meant women as well as the LGBT community; back in 1965, Linus was pressed for time. But how about peace as a theme for any display in Palisades Park? Could students be persuaded to contribute new displays that spoke to the global yearning for peace? Could Santa Monica artists be involved in the creation of new works for the season inspired by the simple notion that all unite in a wish for peace on earth? I don’t know for certain that these new displays would all be cheerful or even bright. But they would, unlike our now perennial debates over the nativity scenes, be filled with a beautiful hope.

in Opinion
<>Related Posts

SM.a.r.t.Column: Happy Fourth of July 

July 2, 2025

July 2, 2025

SMart (Santa Monica Architects for a Responsible Tomorrow) hopes you are enjoying a great 3-day weekend as part of your...

SM.a.r.t Column: Cities That Never Shut Up – The Roaring Cost of Urban Noise

June 26, 2025

June 26, 2025

In today’s cities, silence isn’t golden—it’s extinct. From sunrise to insomnia, we’re trapped in a nonstop symphony of shrieking car...

SM.a.r.t Column: Santa Monica Needs to See the Light

June 19, 2025

June 19, 2025

How Santa Monica’s Growing Light Pollution Is Eroding Human Health, Safety, and Sanity There was a time when our coastal...

SM.a.r.t Column: California’s Transit Death Spiral: How Housing Mandates Are Backfiring

June 15, 2025

June 15, 2025

California’s ambitious housing mandates were supposed to solve the affordability crisis. Instead, they’re creating a vicious cycle that’s killing public...

SM.a.r.t. Column: A City Dying by a Thousand Cuts

June 5, 2025

June 5, 2025

Santa Monica, once celebrated for its blend of coastal charm and progressive ideals, is slowly bleeding out — not from...

SM.a.r.t Column: Oops!! What Happened? And What Are You Going to Do About It?

May 29, 2025

May 29, 2025

Our Santa Monica Architects for a Responsible Tomorrow (SMa.r.t) articles have, over the past 12 years, collectively presented a critical...

SM.a.r.t Column: Why Santa Monica Might Need a Desalination Plant, and Maybe Even Nuclear Power

May 22, 2025

May 22, 2025

Santa Monica is known for its ocean views, sunny skies, and strong environmental values. But there’s a challenge on the...

SM.a.r.t Column: SMO (So Many Options) Part 3: “Pie in the Sky”

May 17, 2025

May 17, 2025

SMO: Fantasy, Fact, and the Fog of Wishful ThinkingBy someone who read the fine print Every few months, a headline...

SM.a.r.t. Column: Owner Occupancy Protects Against Corporate Over-Development

May 2, 2025

May 2, 2025

This week SMa.r.t. will have as guest columnist Mark Borenstein. Mark is a long-time Santa Monica resident, a retired attorney,...

Opinion: Declaration of Economic State of Emergency in Malibu & Pacific Palisades: A Direct Result of the Devastating Impact of the Palisades Fire

April 27, 2025

April 27, 2025

Malibu and Pacific Palisades Request Emergency Financial Measures By Ramis Sadrieh, Chairperson, Malibu Pacific Palisades Chamber of Commerce    On behalf...

SM.a.r.t Column: The World’s Happiest Cities

April 27, 2025

April 27, 2025

Almost every year, we see new cities, regions, and countries that make the list(s) of our planet’s happiest and healthiest...

SM.a.r.t Column: A City for Everyone

April 20, 2025

April 20, 2025

Santa Monica dazzles with its ocean views, sunshine, and laid-back charm. But beyond the postcard image lies a more complicated...

SM.a.r.t Column: Part II: Rebuilding Resilient Communities: Policy and Planning After the Fires

April 13, 2025

April 13, 2025

The January 2025 wildfires that devastated Pacific Palisades and Altadena left an indelible mark on Los Angeles County. Beyond the...

SM.a.r.t Column: Innovative Materials for Fire-Resistant Rebuilding After the LA Fires

April 6, 2025

April 6, 2025

In the aftermath of the devastating 2025 Los Angeles wildfires, homeowners face the daunting task of rebuilding their lives and...

Opinion: Supervisor Lindsey P. Horvath Community Column Regarding a More Accountable Homeless Services System

April 3, 2025

April 3, 2025

By Lindsay Horvath, Los Angeles Board of Supervisors This week marks a significant milestone in our fight to end homelessness...