July 7, 2025 Breaking News, Latest News, and Videos

Santa Monica College District Wastes Taxpayer Dollars On Meritless Appeal: OpEd:

By Mitra Moassessi / SMC Faculty Association president

In March of 2011, the Office of Academic Affairs sent a letter to three of our part-time Associate Faculty members informing them that their Associate Faculty status would be terminated at the end of the Spring 2011 semester. They were also informed that they would not receive additional assignments from Santa Monica College.

The letter referenced article 6.6.8 of the collective bargaining agreement between the District and the Santa Monica College Faculty Association, which lists the conditions under which the Associate Faculty status can be terminated.

Condition (b) provides associate faculty status can be terminated if “The associate faculty member fails to perform the normal and reasonable duties of his/her assignment or is otherwise guilty of misconduct as defined by Education Code 87732.”

In all three cases the faculty member’s termination was triggered by a complaint against the faculty member by a student, which resulted in investigations by the Office of Human Resources. The investigations consisted of interviews with the faculty member and students, none of which were under oath. In all three cases, the Office of Human Resources found the faculty members guilty of misconduct.

The Faculty Association didn’t agree with the decision of the court of Human Resources, a court in which the prosecutor and the judge were the same person. Furthermore, the Association believed that the investigation contained significant inaccuracies and the District offered no direct evidence to establish guilt. Consequently, the association filed grievances on the three cases, maintaining that the terminations of the faculty members were in violation of the contract.

The District denied that its decisions were in violation of the contract and claimed that Associate Faculty can be terminated “at-will” and the district is not obligated to prove guilt.

After going through the informal and formal process of the grievance procedure, as has been defined in article 12 of the collective bargaining agreement, all three cases resulted in arbitration, which is the final level of the grievance process.

Three different impartial arbitrators each reviewed one of the three cases and considered both sides of the arguments. The arbitrators issued their reports on January 9, 2012, February 10, 2012, and March 12, 2012. The three different and impartial arbitrators came to the same conclusion: the Association’s grievance was granted and the district must reinstate the faculty member.

Article 12.3.9 of the collective bargaining agreement between the District and the Santa Monica College Faculty Association states: “the decision of the impartial arbitrator shall be binding on the parties”.

In the history of the Faculty Association, every time a grievance has resulted in arbitration, the parties have agreed that binding arbitration means the decision of the arbitrator is binding and the parties must comply with it. Under the guidance of the district’s legal counsel, who is an hourly paid consultant, the word binding apparently does not actually mean binding. On April 17, 2012, the district filed a petition with the Superior Court of California to vacate the contractual binding arbitration awards, claiming that the arbitrators had exceeded their authority and the District had the right to terminate any part-time faculty, including Associate Faculty, at-will.

The petition to vacate the arbitrators’ decision was heard at the Superior Court of California, Santa Monica Courthouse, on June 26, 2012. Two months later the Association received the court’s ruling. The court denied the district’s petition to vacate the arbitration award and granted the Association’s request to confirm the arbitration award.

On October 2, 2012, the Board of Trustees discussed the ruling of the Superior Court of California at their closed session. On October 3, the district filed an appeal of the Superior Court’s decision with the California Court of Appeals. That appeal remains pending.

According to a document provided by the District’s Fiscal Services, the total cost of these three cases, not including the staff time, for the period of July 2011 to October 1, 2012 has been $74,648.38. That is more than the annual salary of a full-time faculty member with a PhD and six years of experience. Obviously the District believes that spending tax payer money to keep part-time faculty unemployed is a sensible way to be fiscally responsible and fulfills the Board of Trustees’ fiduciary responsibility.

The decision of three impartial arbitrators and the Superior Court of California has apparently not satisfied the District’s desire to completely ignore its binding, contractual obligations. Instead, the District is wasting taxpayer dollars on a completely meritless appeal.

The Faculty Association anxiously awaits the California Court of Appeal’s denial of the District’s appeal.

in News
<>Related Posts

Hama Sushi Hosts Weekly Music and Comedy Open Mics

July 5, 2025

July 5, 2025

The venue, a Venice Beach staple since 1979, has recently expanded its legendary happy hour to the entire patio Hama...

Connections Breakfast to Network Local Business Professionals in Malibu

July 5, 2025

July 5, 2025

The event, sponsored by Malibu Country Mart, will feature a breakfast mixer where attendees can meet new contacts  A Connections...

12th Annual Gopher Scramble Golf Tournament to Benefit Venice Heritage Museum

July 5, 2025

July 5, 2025

The museum opened to the public in March 2024 at the Main Street Design Center with its inaugural exhibition, “This...

Michael Madsen, Star of Reservoir Dogs and Kill Bill, Dies at 67 in Malibu

July 4, 2025

July 4, 2025

Actor Remembered for His Intense Performances and as a Poet  Actor Michael Madsen, known for his distinctive gravelly voice and...

Ruskin Group Theatre to Stage ‘The Fantasticks’

July 4, 2025

July 4, 2025

A timeless tale of young love and life’s bittersweet beauty, the show is reimagined with modern flair for contemporary audiences...

Film Review: F1: The Movie

July 4, 2025

July 4, 2025

FILM REVIEWF1: THE MOVIERated PG-13155 MinutesReleased June 27th F1: The Movie will envelop you in a racecar. You will be...

Big Blue Bus Launches Prohibition Order Program to Bolster Safety

July 4, 2025

July 4, 2025

The orders, which can range from 30 days to one year, target offenses that threaten the safety and comfort of...

Col. Eric Swenson Honored by LA for Historic Debris Removal Effort

July 3, 2025

July 3, 2025

Swenson, with a distinguished military background including a Ph.D. and multiple master’s degrees from Penn State and other institutions, has...

(Video) A visit to New York Bagel & Deli in Santa Monica

July 3, 2025

July 3, 2025

Authentic NY Style Bagels with Extra Creamy Cream Cheese and Multi-Cultural Desserts. Located at 2216 Wilshire Blvd. A visit to...

(Video) Legacy, Reimagined: Architecture, Design & Construction by Home Front Build Los Angeles

July 2, 2025

July 2, 2025

Go To Homefrontbuild.com For More Information @home_front_build Legacy, Reimagined: Architecture, Design & Construction by Home Front Build Los Angeles. Go...

(Video) Gladstone’s Malibu Prepares for Reopening after Surviving Palisades Fires

July 2, 2025

July 2, 2025

With One Half of its Structure Slightly Charred and Undergoing Repairs, Gladstone’s Malibu is Reopening its Patio Space Just in...

Santa Monica Public Library Launches Community Mapping Survey

July 2, 2025

July 2, 2025

The initiative aims to shape the library’s programs and services to better meet community needs, fostering an inclusive and accessible...

Third Street Promenade Loses Bibibop Asian Grill

July 2, 2025

July 2, 2025

Bibibop opened at the Santa Monica location in 2017 after taking over a former ShopHouse space Bibibop Asian Grill, a...

Proposed Rebuilding Authority for Wildfire Recovery Sparks Local Control Debate

July 2, 2025

July 2, 2025

Plan Aims to Streamline Rebuilding but Raises Questions Over Community Input A proposed “Resilient Rebuilding Authority” to oversee recovery from...

Pentagon Orders Troop Drawdown in LA: 150 National Guard Members Reassigned to Wildfire Duty

July 2, 2025

July 2, 2025

Federal Forces Begin Partial Withdrawal From Protest Response as California Leaders Push Back U.S. Northern Command announced Tuesday that 150 National Guard...