April 2, 2025 Breaking News, Latest News, and Videos

What’s in a Cupcake?

By Steve Stajich

 

It’s not a secret that there are those who have long yearned to uncouple the Santa Monica-Malibu Unified School District (SMMUSD.) But as recently as spring of 2016 meetings with representatives from both cities to explore the possibility realized that the doing of it might, as reported by Zahira Torres in the L.A. Times on March 11 2016, “prompt the kind of high-priced, hyper-detailed legal wrangling that marks any stormy high-profile divorce.”

Long simmering feelings in Malibu about seceding from the conjoined school district were highlighted in a New York Times article earlier this month by Dana Goldstein that looked at how monies raised by PTA events in well-heeled Malibu are pooled across the school district and distributed to all the schools. Parents in Malibu aren’t crazy about supporting PTA galas where, according the New York Times piece, “10-person tables cost between $2,000 and $15,000” and parents could bid on auction items like “a Las Vegas vacation, private chef services and a pink guitar signed by the Red Hot Chili Peppers” knowing that at least some of money raised would be shifted to Santa Monica schools with need.

Not that Santa Monica is a poor cousin somehow hitting on Malibu for some spare change. But in a time when inequalities between rich and poor public schools gets more attention because of the gilded new administration in Washington, the splitting of PTA funds over our district schools has been something of a national model to be admired. Still, you might see how some Malibu locals have been doing more than a little head scratching about the program.

Indeed, the New York Times article cited a startling statistic generated by a report from the Center for American Progress: Schools that serve just one-tenth of 1 percent of American students collect 10 percent of the estimated $425 million that PTA’s raise nationwide each year. I’m no pastry goods expert, but it seems that the price of a PTA bake sale apple pie must vary wildly from one place to the next… at least across the breadth of our nation.

But, you say, there’s no shortage of folks with money in either Santa Monica or Malibu. That known, shouldn’t the districts split so that each can tend to its children as needed?

One view is that sharing PTA donations across schools is pragmatic because all of the district’s students feed into two high schools. And much as we rarely discuss it, our own city has needy students. The New York Times article cited Edison Language Academy in Santa Monica, where half the children qualify for free or reduced price lunch. In the March 16 2016 L.A. Times piece about Malibu wanting to split out, Malibu School Board President Laurie Lieberman got to the heart of the matter: “We exist to serve all of our students and we can’t very well say, ‘You want to be your own school district for your own reasons… and we’ll support you to the detriment of the remaining students’.”

Torres reported in her L.A. Times piece that so-called educational secession has bubbled-up in other cities including Dallas and Memphis, but the schism between Malibu and Santa Monica becomes more interesting because it “features two wealthy beach communities in a high-performing school district.” The article also pointed out that Santa Monica schools are more diverse than Malibu’s, with about 30 percent of Santa Monica students coming from disadvantaged families.

We’re not talking about a city with students who are ingesting asbestos because there’s no money to clean up the buildings. But a break-up of the SMMUSD might represent a decay and corrosion of another kind.

The selection of Betsy DeVos as Secretary of Education was a controversial choice by our new President because of her long record of supporting school choice. You know, vouchers to flee ‘bad’ schools so that schools that need help can just be abandoned and left gasping for oxygen. Then it became clear that she didn’t know much about education policy past her position on kids with the resources getting the schools they want. Oh, and she’s rich and has acknowledged no personal experience with student loans. A skeptic might say there’s a kind of “Let them learn cake!” mentality at work.

But that’s not us here on the beach we share with Malibu. And if there is a move afoot to create something other than what we have now with our school district, then we must be sure that change would truly represent what we want and who we are in both Malibu and Santa Monica. Because the message will carry far and wide, and there’s more than just a little concern that it will hurt those who are already struggling on several levels to get the education they deserve.

Home made baked goodies for bake sale on the table.
Home made baked goodies for bake sale on the table.
in Opinion
<>Related Posts

SM.a.r.t Column: Bring Back The Music 2.0

March 23, 2025

March 23, 2025

This is an update of the article appearing in the SM Mirror on Feb 1, 2025 On January 28th, 2025,...

Letter to the Editor: Close the Fairview Library??

March 17, 2025

March 17, 2025

By the Santa Monica Public Library Board, Judith Meister, Chair, Dana Newman, Vice Chair Antonio Spears, Boardmember Daniel Cody, Board Member...

SM.a.r.t Column: Fire Safety in Los Angeles: Reimagining an Age of Megafires

March 16, 2025

March 16, 2025

Los Angeles stands at a critical juncture in its relationship with fire. It is true that climate change intensified vegetations...

Santa Monica Civic Auditorium: The Cultural Icon Santa Monica Needs

March 9, 2025

March 9, 2025

Santa Monica is a city of innovation, creativity, and world-class attractions, yet it lacks a central cultural destination that reflects...

SM.a.r.t Column: The Perils of Passing the Buck: How Self-Certification Threatens Public Safety in Building Design and Construction

March 2, 2025

March 2, 2025

In the bustling city of Santa Monica, California, a quiet revolution is underway in the world of building design and...

SM.a.r.t Column: Bring Back The Music

February 16, 2025

February 16, 2025

On January 28th, 2025, the City Council did a wise thing and agreed to continue the process, for 30 days,...

SM.a.r.t Column: The Water Crisis Behind LA’s Fire Disaster: A Legacy of Outdated Infrastructure

February 9, 2025

February 9, 2025

A firefighter filling a trash can with pool water during the devastating 2025 Los Angeles fires tells a story more...

SM.a.r.t Column: California’s Fire Safety Evolution: Meeting Modern Wildfire Challenges

February 2, 2025

February 2, 2025

The devastating fires that struck Los Angeles in January 2025 echo a pattern of increasingly destructive wildfires reshaping California’s approach...

SM.a.r.t Column: Peril, Prevention, and the Path Forward

January 26, 2025

January 26, 2025

The recent Palisades and Altadena fires brought Los Angeles’ inherent contradictions into sharp focus as residents fled their homes in...

SM.a.r.t Column: A New Path Ahead

January 19, 2025

January 19, 2025

The recent Palisades Fire is profoundly impacting the people of Los Angeles, displacing families, destroying property, and creating an enduring...

SM.a.r.t. Column: Adaptive Liveability

January 2, 2025

January 2, 2025

You know, sometimes you walk by a building and think, that place has some stories to tell. What if those...

SM.a.r.t Column: Happy Holidays

December 22, 2024

December 22, 2024

S.M.a.r.t. (Santa Monica Architects for a Responsible Tomorrow) is wishing you a wonderful holiday season. We hope you are surrounded...

SM.a.r.t. Column: Preserving Santa Monica

December 15, 2024

December 15, 2024

Since Giving Tuesday I’m sure you have been bombarded with appeals from countless organizations, local, national, or even international that...

SM.a.r.t Column: Climbing The Vertical Learning Curve

December 8, 2024

December 8, 2024

The city is facing a financial crisis, the roots of which stretch back decades but have been made worse by...

SM.a.r.t Column: It’s Time To Inspect Balconies

November 24, 2024

November 24, 2024

About nine years ago, a fifth-floor balcony in a Berkeley apartment building collapsed, tragically killing several students gathered on it...