September 27, 2022 Breaking News, Latest News, and Videos

Opinion: SMa.r.t. “Who’s Listening!?”

 

This article was being written as our City Council was spending a weekend retreat in Virginia Park addressing the City’s five strategic goals using “data driven planning” to solve “mobility,” “inclusiveness and diversity,” re-purposing the “Santa Monica Airport,” “homelessness” and childhood “education.” Shouldn’t they also be looking at “safety” and “happiness”?

Are data driven decisions just a smoke screen to hide behind as they pursue an agenda driven primarily by the need to fund a huge pension shortfall? Is data driven decision making meant to replace resident driven priorities? Is “number crunching” a better way to establish policy than a human based approach? Apparently so, as the council is upset with residential backlash and is choosing to rely on staff and digital data, rather than residents! But aren’t they elected by the residents, not developers? Their job is to listen to the residents. That being said, there was little discussion about data driven analysis when the city manager emphasized moving from process to focus instead on outcome. The meeting ended with an entire wall of “stickers,” destined to be turned into yet another report?

hacker
Data tracking. Photo: Thinkstock

It was more a therapy session than a planning session. There was no discussion about a master plan or overall vision for our city. The general plan or Land Use and Circulation Element (LUCE) adopted in 2010 is not a master plan and specifically excluded the downtown, Memorial Park, Bergamot, the public yards, the airport, the Big Blue Bus terminal, the Civic Center auditorium and parking area, etc. The City is the largest landowner in Santa Monica – how will their properties be used to create a vision for our city – one that emphasizes culture, recreation, open-space and nature, and also include the necessary expansion of infrastructure – water, power, police, schools, parks, etc.? Why does our City Council and staff find it so hard to look at these overall issues? Why do we piecemeal plan rather than truly master plan?

When it comes to city planning, the City appears to be playing “catch up.” The size and quantity of projects being approved could stretch our city’s infrastructure and resources to the breaking point. It is not only an issue of cost but also one of time. The scale and complexity of even a large building pale in comparison to the infrastructure and needs of an entire city. It often seems that the council is approving large projects with little or no regard for the ability of our city’s infrastructure to accommodate the additional burden in the short term and the potentially detrimental longterm effects. This is bad planning and a formula for disaster.

Currently our city is listening to those saying “housing at all costs” and is focused on growth and inclusivity while paying lip service to truly affordable housing and diversity. All this while relying on the replacement of older water consuming toilets in an extremely short-sighted way to address the need for expansion of infrastructure. There is not a 6 or 7 story, even a 12 story project, they haven’t approved, usually ill-designed, but which includes 10 or 15 percent affordable units and will likely meet or push even higher the median rent of $5,100.

Incentivizing 3 and 4 story mixed-use projects and creating villages of commercial and residential buildings, rather than just sidewalk storefronts with housing above would keep rents more in line with a lid on land prices and less costly wood frame construction. And with a 3 and 4 story limit on the boulevards, you could comfortably add as much housing as was ever needed or wanted in the city.

And if we are to expand housing, how does this translate into a true community culture instead of a traffic culture? In an article in USA Today from 2017, Santa Monica tops the list of 5 cities for the worst traffic in the country

Instead of public relations publicity stunts like the unconscionably costly City Hall Annex, where an extra $80 million of construction and financing costs for a 50,000 square foot addition to City Hall will allow us to be the first-on-the-block to exceed all environmental standards. Why not use the money instead to provide solar arrays on all public buildings – schools, libraries, etc. – and still have money left to build a sewage and waste-water purification plant. The importance of a true, long overdue master plan cannot be overstated.

Unfortunately we have a City Council and City Manager whose forward thinking is turning into a dense, dark, and suffocating environment. In contrast, last weekend I had occasion to spend the night in downtown Santa Barbara – in the morning walking through an environment of 1 to 4 story buildings (most 1 to 2 stories and the occasional 3 story building) with a mix of department stores, boutiques, and mom-and-pop shops; restaurants and coffee shops in a relaxed, open, wonderful environment.

What we’re allowing in Santa Monica is unnecessary, unwanted by residents, and just bad planning. A proposed Miramar condo/hotel – the width and length of 3 football fields! Our City Council should schedule their next weekend retreat in Santa Barbara instead of Virginia Park and come to appreciate and realize the environment they are fast ruining.

Unfortunately, there’s corruption in all segments of our lives – from the pharmaceutical industry to college sports and unfortunately also extending into civic, as well as our national politics. Has our beach town been sold to developers? It feels like it, and if it has, it must be stopped! Our City Council, supported by developer driven campaign funds, feels untouchable and spends our tax money on public relations campaigns preaching to its residents, rather than listening to them. None of what the city is doing addresses the real question – what is our vision for the future? To answer this question the importance of a master plan is paramount! In the following weeks, we will address and evaluate these overriding issues and goals – stay tuned.

In the meantime, what’s the takeaway – “that might makes right? – until you see the light.” Council and City Manager, maybe it’s time to recheck your eyeglass prescriptions.

Ron Goldman for SMa.r.t. (Santa Monica Architects for a Responsible Tomorrow)

Thane Roberts AIA, Architect, Robert H. Taylor AIA, Ron Goldman FAIA, Architect, Dan Jansenson, Architect, Building and Fire-Life Safety Commission, Samuel Tolkin Architect, Mario Fonda-Bonardi, AIA, Planning Commissioner, Phil Brock, Santa Monica Arts Commission.

Related Posts

Man Arrested for Santa Monica College Sexual Assaults

September 27, 2022

September 27, 2022

Christopher Noah Griddine II being held on $1 million bond By Sam Catanzaro A 27-year-old man has been arrested for...

SMa.r.t. Column: SMCLC Rejects Gelson’s Project

September 26, 2022

September 26, 2022

This week our SMa.r.t. column is guest written by the Santa Monica Coalition for a Livable City (SMCLC). They are...

Framing Nearly Complete on Lincoln Blvd 47 Unit Mixed Use Building: Santa Monica Real Estate Report – September 26th, 2022

September 26, 2022

September 26, 2022

Property, Developments, and Listings on the Westside.* Framing Nearly Complete on Lincoln Blvd 47 Unit Mixed Use Building* City of...

Renderings Released for Santa Monica Library-Adjacent Affordable Housing

September 23, 2022

September 23, 2022

38 units planned to at 1333 7th Street By Dolores Quintana The Foundation For Affordable Housing has proposed a new...

Kim Kardashian Buys Cindy Crawford’s Former Malibu Estate for $70 Million

September 23, 2022

September 23, 2022

Sale priciest residential transfer in Malibu of 2022 and is also the year’s fourth-priciest sale in the state By Dolores...

Santa Monica Mayor and City Council Call for an End to Needle Exchange Program at Reed Park

September 23, 2022

September 23, 2022

By Dolores Quintana Santa Monica Mayor Sue Himmelrich has formally requested that Los Angeles County end the Harm Reduction Syringe...

City of Malibu Continues Opposition to County Action to Move Juvenile Prisoners to Santa Monica Mountains Near Malibu

September 23, 2022

September 23, 2022

By Matt Myerhoff, Media Information Officer for the City of Malibu   The City of Malibu continued its strong opposition to...

Student Hospitalized Following Fight Near Santa Monica High School

September 22, 2022

September 22, 2022

Olympic High School student taken, discharged from hospital following Monday fight in alley behind Samohi By Sam Catanzaro A student...

Film Review: “The Woman King”

September 22, 2022

September 22, 2022

FILM REVIEWTHE WOMAN. KINGRated PG-13135 Minutes The Woman King is a drama and a superb action film based on the...

New Orleans Fried Chicken Institution Willie Mae’s Now Open for Delivery in LA With Venice Location Coming Soon

September 22, 2022

September 22, 2022

By Dolores Quintana While Willie Mae’s Scotch House Restaurant has not yet opened their sit-down restaurant in Venice, the company...

Santa Monica Hotel Hosting Monthly Drag Brunch

September 22, 2022

September 22, 2022

Drag Me to Brunch at Lowes Santa Monica Beach Hotel on the third Sunday of every month By Dolores Quintana...

Famous Italian Singer Zucchero to Play Beverly Hills Theatre on Sept. 30

September 21, 2022

September 21, 2022

Zucchero will play at Beverly Hills’ Saban Theatre, one of several American stops on his World Wide Tour  By Susan...

‘Sameday Health’ Launches Monkeypox Testing at Venice Beach Location

September 21, 2022

September 21, 2022

Get a same day appointments and 48 hour test results for covid-19, Flu, and Monkeypox testing now available at the...

Downbeat 720 Returns to In-Person Performances at the Virginia Avenue Park Teen Center

September 21, 2022

September 21, 2022

Downbeat 720, the City’s long-running open-mic for high school performers, returns in-person beginning Tuesday, September 27, 2022. It will be...