September 30, 2022 Breaking News, Latest News, and Videos

Santa Monica City Council Rejects Scooter Cap Proposal

Electric scooters are here stay, at least for the time being.

On Tuesday night, June 12, in front of a packed council chamber, Santa Monica City Council unanimously approved a 16-month pilot program that will allow dockless, shared mobility rental companies like Bird and Lime to continue operating in the city.

Photos: Sam Catanzaro. Supporters of electric scooters showed up at rally organized by Bird at City Hall prior the City Council meeting.

“There’s no denying the popularity and ease of shared mobility devices that can help Santa Monica reach its goal of being a multimodal city,” said Santa Monica Mayor Ted Winterer. “This pilot approach will allow us to understand usage and operations in order to create a long-term program that establishes a safe, equitable and sustainable mobility option in Santa Monica.”

The pilot program, which will begin September 17, establishes a dynamic cap on the number of devices a company can have. Operators can exceed the cap if they can show that each device is being used at least three times a day. It still unclear how many devices operators will be allowed to deploy once the program begins. Electric scooter and bike rental companies celebrated the decision, as the council members rejected a proposal by city staffers that had called for an initial cap of 1,500 total scooters for the entire city.

“We applaud the City of Santa Monica for formally embracing innovative transportation, and look forward to collaborating with them as they work to further establish regulations around an environmentally-clean, shared mobility program for scooters,” wrote Lime Spokesperson Mary Caroline Pruitt in a statement.

The program will permit up to four rental companies – two electric scooter services and two electric bike services – to operate in the city. Operators will be chosen through an open application process that begins in July. In addition to creating a dynamic cap, the program levies fees on vendors and requires them to increase the safety of devices by educating riders, share real-time utilization data with the City, ensure fair and equal distribution of devices while instructing operators to develop a system that will remedy improper parking.

Last week, City Staff presented City Council a proposal to cap the number of devices in the city to 500 per operator and 1,500 total and on Tuesday evening, some of these staffers encouraged council members to adopt this cap.

“To avoid oversupply, we are recommending a flexible cap that would start at 250 per operator and go up to 500 per operator,” said Francie Stefan, Mobility Manager for the City of Santa Monica.

Mayor Pro Tem Gleam Davis and Councilmember Terry O’Day voiced concern that the cap may lead to an unequal distribution of scooters, as providers would be encouraged to put devices only in high-density areas.

“Why have a cap at all? What’s the purpose?” O’Day said. “The cap as I heard it was too low in the staff recommendations.”

Davis also expressed concern that a hard cap would be a potentially fruitless effort in Santa Monica. Bird and Lime devices are popular in many areas like Westwood and Venice that border Santa Monica but are not part of the city’s jurisdiction. Operators could flood these areas with devices and Santa Monica could do nothing to prevent riders from taking them into the city.

“What happens when people ride into Santa Monica from Venice or West Los Angeles or Pacific Palisades? I’ve seen scooters in all three places. Do we put up a wall and say ‘I’m sorry that’s scooter number 250, you can’t come in’? I don’t understand how we enforce a cap on a mobility item,” Davis said.

A rally organized by Bird prior to the event also featured stakeholders voicing opposition to the cap proposed by city staff. David Estrada, Chief Legal Officer for Bird, argued that capping the number of devices in the city was environmentally irresponsible.

“Why are we here capping the solution rather than the problem?” Estrada said during the rally. “Bird can help Santa Monica leaders meet their audacious goal of reducing car trips to achieve full carbon neutrality if the City Council votes against the proposal.”

More than 30 members of the public spoke at the Council meeting and while many residents voiced their contempt towards these scooters, most speakers expressed support for the devices and opposition towards any cap.

“I oppose the cap on the number of scooters. The ubiquity of the scooters maximizes their utility,” said Santa Monica resident Chad Billmyer at the meeting. “A cap only serves to squash the usefulness, reliability and transportation breakthrough that scooters provide.”

While City Council rejected the cap proposal, they did approve a staff recommendation to levy fees on device operators. Each company selected will have to pay a base operator fee of 20,000 dollars plus a per device fee of $130. These funds will pay for two full-time employees approved by City Council, one program coordinator and one enforcement liaison.

“The cost is not born to the City or the public….this would fund a program coordinator and an enforcement liaison necessary to create the system to facilitate these devices operating,” Stefan said. “This also compensates the public for use of public land for commercial purposes.”

The fees were approved unanimously but in the Council meeting, Councilmember O’Day asked Stefan if similar fees are levied on the Breeze Hulu bikes.  Stephan said that the city does not currently levy a fee on Breeze. In response, O’Day questioned the fairness of the fee.

“Everyone else has to pay for it but the City’s service doesn’t?” O’Day said.

The council’s decision was applauded by enthusiasts of the scooters. Mike Matzke, who has ridden a Bird scooter every weekend for the past two months, says the dynamic cap is in line with the principals the United States is founded on.

“I personally like the deregulation. I think that kind of freedom is kind of what we are founded on as a country,” Matzke said. “As long as the riders have a conscious about the place they put the scooters not blocking the sidewalks, I don’t think it should be a problem.”

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

in News
Related Posts

Fresh Corn Grill Closes Santa Monica Location

September 29, 2022

September 29, 2022

Restaurant ceases operations September 23 By Dolores Quintana Fresh Corn Grill, a small chain based in Westwood that serves “a...

Santa Monica’s Love Coffee Bar Expanding to Mar Vista

September 29, 2022

September 29, 2022

3519 S Centinela Avenue location coming for popular Santa Monica coffee shop  By Dolores Quintana Love Coffee Bar, a Santa...

Dr. Jane Goodall Speaking at Youth Event Wednesday at Temescal Park

September 27, 2022

September 27, 2022

Seven Arrows Elementary hosting event Wednesday for students from around region Seven Arrows Elementary, an independent kindergarten through 6th grade...

Five Santa Monica Artists Awarded City Artist Fellowships

September 27, 2022

September 27, 2022

The $16,000 Artist Fellowship will be presented to painter and sculptor Meg Cranston The City of Santa Monica awarded five...

Santa Monica High School Orchestra Program Presents Disney in Concert Around the World

September 27, 2022

September 27, 2022

Submitted by the Santa Monica-Malibu Unified School District For the first time since the fall of 2019, the Santa Monica...

Trailhead Improvement Project Begins at Cheeseboro Canyon

September 27, 2022

September 27, 2022

Access to trails will continue, but use of temporary parking lot required The National Park Service is revitalizing the trailhead...

Santa Monica Man Killed by San Bernardino County Sheriff’s Deputies After Hitting a Deputy With Car and Attempting to Attack Him With a Knife

September 27, 2022

September 27, 2022

Marlon Bonds shot by San Bernardino County Sheriff’s Deputies Saturday night in Rancho Cucamonga  By Sam Catanzaro A Santa Monica...

Man Arrested for Santa Monica College Sexual Assaults

September 27, 2022

September 27, 2022

Christopher Noah Griddine II being held on $1 million bond By Sam Catanzaro A 27-year-old man has been arrested for...

SMa.r.t. Column: SMCLC Rejects Gelson’s Project

September 26, 2022

September 26, 2022

This week our SMa.r.t. column is guest written by the Santa Monica Coalition for a Livable City (SMCLC). They are...

Framing Nearly Complete on Lincoln Blvd 47 Unit Mixed Use Building: Santa Monica Real Estate Report – September 26th, 2022

September 26, 2022

September 26, 2022

Property, Developments, and Listings on the Westside.* Framing Nearly Complete on Lincoln Blvd 47 Unit Mixed Use Building* City of...

Renderings Released for Santa Monica Library-Adjacent Affordable Housing

September 23, 2022

September 23, 2022

38 units planned to at 1333 7th Street By Dolores Quintana The Foundation For Affordable Housing has proposed a new...

Kim Kardashian Buys Cindy Crawford’s Former Malibu Estate for $70 Million

September 23, 2022

September 23, 2022

Sale priciest residential transfer in Malibu of 2022 and is also the year’s fourth-priciest sale in the state By Dolores...

Santa Monica Mayor and City Council Call for an End to Needle Exchange Program at Reed Park

September 23, 2022

September 23, 2022

By Dolores Quintana Santa Monica Mayor Sue Himmelrich has formally requested that Los Angeles County end the Harm Reduction Syringe...

City of Malibu Continues Opposition to County Action to Move Juvenile Prisoners to Santa Monica Mountains Near Malibu

September 23, 2022

September 23, 2022

By Matt Myerhoff, Media Information Officer for the City of Malibu   The City of Malibu continued its strong opposition to...

Student Hospitalized Following Fight Near Santa Monica High School

September 22, 2022

September 22, 2022

Olympic High School student taken, discharged from hospital following Monday fight in alley behind Samohi By Sam Catanzaro A student...