March 5, 2024 Breaking News, Latest News, and Videos

Attorney in Voting Rights Case “99 Percent Certain” City Will Change to District Elections

Special election also possible.

By Sam Catanzaro

Los Angeles County Superior Court Judge Yvette M. Palazuelos has ruled in favor of the Pico Neighborhood Association in a voting rights case against the City of Santa Monica, putting the future of at-large elections at stake in the City. The decision, which was handed down on November 5 and filed on November 8, was released to the public on November 13, says at-large elections in Santa Monica are in violation of the California Voting Rights Act (CRVA).

Both sides will appear in court December 7 for a post-trial hearing to decide the appropriate solution for violating the CVRA.

While the City said they plan on appealing the ruling, R. Rex Parris of Parris Law Firm, an attorney representing the plaintiffs, told the Santa Monica Mirror that he is “99 percent certain” Santa Monica will change to district-based elections. 

“I’m 99 percent certain that they are going to turn it into districts,” Parris said. “This means there will be a change in the power structure of Santa Monica. It will mean that people who are not able to raise hundreds of hundreds of thousands of dollars will now be able to compete in an election.”

Depending on what is decided at the December 7 hearing, Parris told the Mirror that the plaintiffs will ask the City to hold a special election to elect new City Councilmembers.

“As soon as that order becomes final the people sitting in office are sitting there illegally,” Parris said. “We will be asking her to order a special election.” 

The case, Pico Neighborhood Association et al. v. City of Santa Monica, pitted voting rights advocates against the City of Santa Monica. The plaintiffs, led by resident Maria Loya, argue that the City’s at-large election system dilutes the Latino vote in City Council elections and is in violation of the 2002 California Voting Rights Act, which was passed to increase opportunities for Latinos and other minorities to elect representatives of their choice.

The City, however, argues that Latinos do enjoy success in City Council elections, pointing to Latino Councilmember Tony Vazquez, who is one out of seven councilmembers. Defense lawyers argue that this makes City Council 14.3 percent Latino, greater than the 13.1 percent of the City’s 89,736 residents who are Hispanic or Latino. The City also points to Mayor Pro-Tempore Gleam Davis, who testified during the trial that her adopted parents told her that her biological father is from Mexico.

The City also argues that district-based elections will not substantially enhance Latino voting power. In addition, they claim that at-large elections make sense for the 8.3 square mile city, pointing to the fact that voters have twice rejected district-based elections in 1972 and 2002.

In a press release Tuesday, attorneys for the City indicated that they plan on appealing Judge Palazuelos’ decision.

“We received today the court’s tentative ruling. We are disappointed that it contains no reasoning in support of the court’s decision, which we believe is based on an unjustified adoption of the plaintiffs’ misguided and unsupported view of the law. In accordance with the court’s order, we will file briefing on the issue of remedies. Once the court’s ruling is final, we plan to appeal, which will allow the California Court of Appeal to address the significant legal issues of first impression posed by this case,” said defense lawyer Theodore J. Boutrous Jr., Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

Plaintiff attorney Parris, however, is confident that his plaintiffs will prevail in the event of an appeal and that they appeal by the City is a misuse of taxpayers’ dollars.

“Nobody has ever prevailed against a judge who has ordered a district-wide election because that clearly is the favored policy of the law,” Parris said. “All they want to do is spend the taxpayer’s money in order to stay in office…If I was a citizen of Santa Monica, I would be outraged that they spent millions of dollars, and indicate that they will spend millions more, just so they can stay in office illegally”

The Santa Monica Mirror has reached out to the City asking how much they estimate will be spent on legal fees in an appeal, but they have not responded at the time of publishing.

in News
Related Posts

Malibu Canyon Road Safety Inspection By LA County Public Works Department Completed

March 4, 2024

March 4, 2024

Engineers Examine Rockslide Area to Ensure Road Safety for Commuters Los Angeles County Public Works Department officially reopened Malibu Canyon...

Suspect in Custody After Breaking Into Woman’s Residence, Masturbating While She Slept

March 4, 2024

March 4, 2024

The Man Was Arrested for Burglary, Indecent Exposure and Attempt to Commit Rape By Zach Armstrong A homeless man has...

“We Must Have Significant Green Space Within a 10-Minute Walk of Every Resident”: Mayor Brock Issues 2024 State of the City Speech

March 4, 2024

March 4, 2024

Plans Were Announced to Rename Virginia Avenue Park After the City’s First Black Recreation & Parks Commissioner By Zach Armstrong...

Instagram Executive Puts Spanish-Style Venice Home on the Market

March 4, 2024

March 4, 2024

Nestled in the heart of the East of Lincoln neighborhood, the bungalow includes coved ceilings According to a report by...

Seven-Bedroom Beachfront Home Lists for $12.5M

March 3, 2024

March 3, 2024

Built in 1929, Amenities Include a Sparkling Pool, Home Theater and Elevator  This beachfront residence, boasting panoramic views from Palos...

LA City Council Greenlights Master Leasing Program to Tackle Homelessness Crisis

March 3, 2024

March 3, 2024

Unanimous Vote Sets Stage for Different Approach to Expand Housing Options The Los Angeles City Council came one step closer...

LAHSA Report Exposes Failures of Anti-Camping Ordinance, Allegedly Kept Secret Since November

March 3, 2024

March 3, 2024

City Controller and Council Members Speak Out Against Withheld Report  LA City Controller Kenneth Meija posted comments on social media...

Construction Alert: Topanga Canyon Boulevard Faces Nightly Closures Starting March 4

March 1, 2024

March 1, 2024

Caltrans Announces 18-Mile Project Spanning Chatsworth to PCH Commuters in the Los Angeles area should prepare for significant delays as...

Film Review: Nyad

February 29, 2024

February 29, 2024

FILM REVIEWNYADRated PG-13121 MinutesReleased November 3rdOscar Nominations: Best Leading Actress, Best Supporting Actress “I failed many times, but I can...

Security Officers Being Deployed at Big Blue Bus Stations and Routes

February 29, 2024

February 29, 2024

The Guards will be provided by a firm with other security contracts with the city of Santa Monica  By Zach...

Leap Day Brings Once-in-Four-Year Deals at Popular Restaurants All Day Long

February 28, 2024

February 28, 2024

Krispy Kreme, Dunkin’, and More Roll Out Special Offers to Mark the Occasion Leap Day, that rare additional day occurring...

Sweet Lady Jane’s Social Media Tease Continues As Locations Sport Hiring Notices

February 28, 2024

February 28, 2024

Mysterious Posts Leave Fans Eager for the Return, But Questions Linger By Dolores Quintana After resurfacing on social media, the...

Upcoming Ice Cream Shop on Montana Ave. Will Serve Multitude of Vegan Flavors

February 28, 2024

February 28, 2024

The Company Has Come a Long Way Since Its Humble Beginnings as a New York City Food Truck By Zach...

(Video) Pro-Palestine Protest at the Beverly Wilshire Hotel

February 28, 2024

February 28, 2024

Protesters were there to protest the arrival of U.S. Representative Nancy Pelosi Counter-protesters drove by in a car. @smmirrornews Pro-Palestine...

(Video) Restaurants Replace Glass Front Doors After Late Night Robbery Spree in Del Ray

February 28, 2024

February 28, 2024

Seven restaurants and small businesses in Del Rey and Venice, including Nick the Greek and Dudley Market, were robbed. Council...