August 9, 2025 Breaking News, Latest News, and Videos

City Council Changes Rules on Public Comments at Meetings

By Cailley Chella

Santa Monica City Councilmembers are tired of meetings that last till 1 and 2 a.m., literally. So they’re taking measures to shorten meetings by trying to cut down on time spent on comments made by the public, but they’ll have to balance Santa Monica residents’ first amendment right to freedom of speech.

“The idea that we’re going to have a coherent conversation about something at 1 or 2 in the morning when we all have day jobs is just not realistic,” said Santa Monica Mayor Gleam Davis during the February 27 City Council Meeting.

Under previous rules, speakers are allowed two-minutes per item, before the item is considered on by City Council. Speakers are limited to six minutes total in each meeting. In addition, speakers are allowed to accept a one-two-minute donation of time from another member of the public who has signed up for public comment.

During this meeting, a new resolution was unanimously approved which makes it so that members of the public who are willing to cut their speaking time in half are allowed to speak first during public comment. Those who wish to speak for the full two-minutes will do so afterwards. In addition, the resolution also gives priority to K-12 students so that they can get home before curfew. The rules passed by Council also grant speakers using an interpreter double time.

These rules will be in place for the Tuesday, March 5 City Council meeting.

“What we’re looking for is to have quality engagement and conversation in this meeting,” said Mayor Pro Tem Terry O’Day. “Not to curtail people’s input, but rather to make sure that by having a predictable and efficient meeting that everyone can be heard.”

Residents are torn. On one hand, Jerry Rubin says he fully supports the new rules.

“As someone who speaks at about every council meeting, I don’t see this as something that’s restricting peoples’ right to speak,” Rubin said. “I think this is a balanced item that’s respecting the need of a community to have shorter council meetings.”

Others like Johnathan Foster are appalled.

“People have been dying to be able to speak, and you would take it away,” Foster said.

Denise Barton agreed, telling the council, “What this really shows is that you do not care or want to hear what the residents have to say.”

Councilmembers noted multiple times that they don’t want to restrict anyone’s speech, saying they believe these rules will actually increase the public’s ability to be heard.

“The public has to be able to stay with us through our meeting…if they have to wait till midnight or 1 in the morning they just won’t be heard,” said Councilmember Kevin McKeown. “We’re struggling with how to balance input from a large number of people, so as many as possible get heard on all the items that they care about.”

City Manager Rick Cole noted there are 88 cities in Los Angeles County and that many other councils have had to put time limits on comments from the public. According to their official city council agendas, both Santa Monica and West Hollywood allow two minutes per speaker, Los Angeles allows one minute, and Malibu, Beverly Hills, Culver City and Burbank all allow three minutes per speaker.

Councilmember Ted Winterer said it’s about quality, not quantity and suggested that the council try to communicate better with the public to cut down on time.

“If we can educate the public that it’s a much more effective way to present your point to get your five or six salient points about the issue, have five or six speakers speak to that and then have the other 30 people in the room who support that stand up, we’re all gonna be better off in the long run because we’ll have more intelligent dialogue,” Winterer said.

Some Councilmembers were also wary of the rule giving students a priority. Councilmember McKeown reminded everyone that when the council previously had this rule, adults would bring students just to skip the line.

“It has the potential for great abuse,” McKeown said.

The council said they’ll continue to keep an eye on the issue and make more changes as needed.

“I do think that this is a dynamic process,” said Councilmember Greg Morena. “I’d like to keep it as such so that we review this in some periodic basis to try to keep some type of scorecard to see how we’re doing…and so the public also knows how we’re keeping score.”

Editors note: a previous version of this article incorrectly stated that “These new rules approved by Council will only take effect during meetings if fifteen or more members of the public wish to speak on one item, or if forty or more members of the public wish to speak on any combination of items.” 

This was the original proposal that City Staff recommend, but City Council decided to get rid of this threshold at the Feb. 26 meeting. The City Clerk has, however, been instructed to look into potential thresholds council could adopt in the future. 

<>Related Posts

Boil Water Notice Issued for Parts of Malibu After Construction Disruption

August 8, 2025

August 8, 2025

 Caltrans Bridge Work Triggers Precautionary Advisory Residents in sections of Malibu are being urged to boil tap water before use...

Big Blue Bus Returns to Palisades This Weekend

August 8, 2025

August 8, 2025

The Route 9 reinstatement is part of a larger set of service changes taking effect After months of limited operations,...

Providence Relocates Palisades Clinics to Santa Monica

August 8, 2025

August 8, 2025

The relocated clinics are now accepting both existing and new patients Providence has permanently relocated its primary care and pediatric...

Film Review: The Naked Gun

August 7, 2025

August 7, 2025

FILM REVIEWTHE NAKED GUNRated PG-1385 MinutesReleased August 1st   The Naked Gun plays to high expectations due to its historic legacy,...

Children’s Hospital to Expand Pediatric Orthopedic Services in Santa Monica with $10M Gift

August 7, 2025

August 7, 2025

The funding will support expanded clinic space, new equipment, and the recruitment of additional orthopedic specialists in Santa Monica Children’s...

‘Dad Bod’ Contest Comes to Venice Restaurant This Weekend

August 7, 2025

August 7, 2025

The competition will unfold over three themed rounds: a beachwear walk, a tongue-in-cheek “talent show,” and a final flex-off judged...

City Preps for Return of SaMoHi, Pali High Students by Boosting Safety

August 7, 2025

August 7, 2025

Efforts to ensure student safety include reactivating school crossing guards, completing pedestrian safety upgrades, and promoting free public transit As...

Hot Dog on a Stick and Santa Monica Brew Works Team Up for Santa Monica’s Dog Days of Summer

August 7, 2025

August 7, 2025

Dog-Friendly Event in Santa Monica Supports Local Rescue Group  Santa Monica’s four-legged residents will get their day in the sun...

Santa Monica’s ICARUS AI Launches Global Grant Initiative, Empowering 5,000 Lives Through Education

August 6, 2025

August 6, 2025

SANTA MONICA, CA – ICARUS AI https://icarus.education/ a local Artificial Intelligence and education technology company, headquartered right here in Santa...

Santa Monica’s Chez Jay Celebrates 66 Years with Retro Bash by the Beach

August 6, 2025

August 6, 2025

Landmark Restaurant Celebrates With Classic Cars, Live Music, Celebrity Lore One of Los Angeles County’s most storied restaurants will mark...

Swiss Firm Partners with California Startup to Aid Wildfire Recovery With AI Robots

August 6, 2025

August 6, 2025

The robotic microfactories are designed to fabricate structural wall panels on-site with high precision, aiming to speed up the construction...

Film Review: Weapons

August 6, 2025

August 6, 2025

By Dolores Quintana You might be asking yourself what the film Weapons is about. Not to worry, writer and director...

Trial Date Set for Alleged ‘Ketamine Queen’ in Matthew Perry’s Death

August 5, 2025

August 5, 2025

Woman Accused in Matthew Perry’s Overdose to Face Jury The woman accused of supplying the fatal dose of ketamine that...

Santa Monica to Enter Mediation Over Ebony Beach Club Land Seizure

August 5, 2025

August 5, 2025

The decision follows a year-long investigation into White’s efforts to open the Ebony Beach Club—a nonprofit intended to provide a...

(Video) Palisades Rec Center Completes Construction of First Responder-Themed Playground

August 5, 2025

August 5, 2025

The new playground–which replaces a near-40-year-old one–was made with funds largely generated by the FireAid Benefit Concert. Palisades Rec Center...