March 19, 2024 Breaking News, Latest News, and Videos

SMa.r.t. Column: Downtown Deception

Three weeks ago the Planning Commission approved a 140 unit eight story skyscraper downtown which meets all the requirements of the Downtown Community Plan, but misses several significant City urban goals. This building at 601 Colorado is a forerunner of a large number of similar projects which on paper meet the letter but not the intent of our codes.

The Downtown Plan was supposed to incentivize (primarily with bonuses from added density and parking reductions) the construction of multi bedroom apartments for families. If a developer wanted these bonuses by building larger Tier 2 and 3 type projects, not only would they pay extra fees and have to provide among other things more affordable units, but they would also have to meet a specific mix of unit types: 15 percent maximum studios, 20 percent minimum 2 bedroom apartments and 15 percent minimum three bedroom apartments. 

This unit mix was supposed to ensure that the downtown with its added density, and enhanced transportation options (Expo Line, Big Blue Bus hub and the 10 Freeway) would be a friendly place for all types of families to settle. The shape of the “family” is appropriately not specified: it could be college roommates, or couples with young children, or multigenerational families, or seniors with a live in caregiver, or people running a home business or art career or any possible combination of that elusive thing we call a family. The important thing was that the downtown would provide housing for the full profile of life from infants to seniors. 

Unfortunately, these large upcoming buildings by WS Communities (a progeny of NMS) among other developers, are not really full of multi-bedroom apartments but are a series of very small one bedroom apartments with a shared microscopic kitchen. These one-bedroom apartments have been aggregated into clusters, that by opening selected doors might look like a two or three-bedroom apartment but would actually be unlivable for a family with any sense of shared space. They essentially have no kitchen, dining room or living room big enough for the entire family (however it is defined) to cook, eat or lounge together. They have a fatal misallocation of space for family life.  For example the very small (988 square feet average) three bedroom apartments have three bathrooms. Two of the bathrooms are so small they have to put their sinks outside those bathrooms. Most three bedroom apartment renters would be happy with two bathrooms so that more room could be dedicated to the living spaces. By cramming three one bedroom apartments into the space of a small three bedroom apartment, the bedrooms, shrink to the point that with a queen size bed there is no room for a dresser or desk much less a place to turn around a wheel chair. The analogous discussion would apply to the two bedroom apartments which are however slightly larger proportionally to their bedroom count. 

“If we don’t build real family apartments they won’t come. In this case our downtown will be less than it could be, because we allowed developers to build deceptive unit mixes that made it impossible for families to live there.”

Mario Fonda-Bonardi

In other words these apartments are for workaholic members of the gig economy who are never home or for wealthy students who are briefly camping out downtown. As soon as they want to throw a birthday party, to live with a lover or spouse, much less to have children, they have to decamp to find a real two or three bedroom apartment. Since these natural life events happen to everyone, what this really means is high turnover for the building owner with more opportunities to raise the rent. So not only does the starting rent from three one bedroom apartments exceed the rent from a three bedroom apartment of the same floor area, the churning of roommates means that the rent escalator, will be accelerated even further for a large portion of downtown residents. This is particularly true because NMS/WS owns such a large percentage of the downtown apartments and properties under development that they exercise essentially monopolistic pricing over the whole area. You know these small units will be very expensive.

These units are designed for a college dorm or hotel lifestyle where people accept their straitened circumstances because they know it will be temporary. But their small size makes them unlivable for long term residents, so the stability of the downtown population is decreased by their continual need to find more habitable quarters. Thus downtown becomes a transient hub of not just the homeless but also of the poorly housed by these cramped units. There will be those who will argue that we cannot afford to build real family apartments anymore and people will simply have to learn to live in smaller and more expensive cells. Perhaps this is true, but we should not accelerate this trend by allowing and approving such deception in the unit mix of these large buildings. 

Finally there is one other problem with packing people in this way. The City allows these transit adjacent types of apartments downtown to have significantly reduced parking requirements which for this building totals 95 cars compared to a similar building in the rest of the City which would require 235 cars. This is part of the City’s noble experiment to see if they don’t build the parking spaces, people will magically abandon their cars. The jury is still out on that experiment, but the data is being skewed by such buildings. When you treat this building as what it really is: as 210 one bedroom apartments, just the downtown’s wishful thinking load of 1/2 car per unit totals 105 cars. The actual load using the City’s numbers for the rest of the City would be a more realistic 315 cars. You have to believe that the real load is somewhere between those two numbers, because the wealthy tenants who can afford these units will also have cars and will need to park them somewhere.There will be a scramble to rent adjacent downtown parking spaces. Its unclear who will benefit from that parking shortage, but it is certain the streets will be in greater gridlock from these types of projects. 

The reverse of the famous phase “If we build it, they will come”is also true. If we don’t build real family apartments they won’t come. In this case our downtown will be less than it could be, because we allowed developers to build deceptive unit mixes that made it impossible for families to live there. 

By Mario Fonda-Bonardi AIA

For Santa Monica Architects for a Responsible Tomorrow

Sam Tolkin, Architect; Dan Jansenson Building and Safety Commissioner, Architect; Mario Fonda-Bonardi, AIA, Planning Commissioner; Ron Goldman, FAIA; Thane Roberts ,Architect; Bob. Taylor, AIA; Phil Brock, Arts Commissioner. 

Related Posts

Time is Running Out To Give Public Input on Malibu’s Revised Housing Element

March 18, 2024

March 18, 2024

City Asks Residents to Comment on Strategies for Addressing Housing Needs The City of Malibu has released an updated Revised...

Fatal Crash Claims Life of Woman on Pacific Coast Highway in Malibu

March 18, 2024

March 18, 2024

Accident Victim Identified in Thursday Night Accident A woman tragically lost her life in a Thursday evening crash along the...

California Wildlife Center Responds to Distressed Marine Mammal at Little Dume Beach

March 18, 2024

March 18, 2024

Third Gray Whale Stranding of 2024 Prompts Concern in Malibu On the morning of Saturday, March 16, the California Wildlife...

Woman Drives Car In Ocean After High Speed Police Chase

March 18, 2024

March 18, 2024

Law enforcement officers pursued her along the I-110 and I-405 until she reached the vicinity of Venice Beach A woman...

Santa Monica Authorities Seek Public’s Help After Sexual Assault Incident

March 17, 2024

March 17, 2024

SMPD Urges Anyone With Information to Come Forward Authorities in Santa Monica are seeking information from the public after a...

SM.a.r.t Column: Can California ARBs Balance Affordable Housing with Community Character in the Face of New Housing Laws?

March 17, 2024

March 17, 2024

By suggestion, I attended the March 4th ARB (Architectural Review Board) meeting that addressed the Gelson Lincoln Boulevard Project.  After...

FBI Seeks Victims of Alleged Online Exploitation Scheme Allegedly Run by Resident of Santa Monica

March 17, 2024

March 17, 2024

Individuals Urged to Come Forward in Investigation of John Douglas Burch The FBI’s Philadelphia Field Office is urging individuals to...

(Video) Sarah Kate Ellis, President and CEO of GLAAD Responds to News of Nex Benedict’s Cause of Death

March 15, 2024

March 15, 2024

Sarah Kate Ellis, President and CEO of GLAAD, responds to the release of the Oklahoma Medical Examiner’s Ruling on Nex...

Venice Family Clinic Announces Inaugural HEART Gala to Celebrate Health and Art

March 15, 2024

March 15, 2024

Event Honors Creative Community and Supporters of Vital Health Care Services Venice Family Clinic, a non-profit community health center dedicated...

“Love Lies Bleeding” is Ripped: Actress Katy O’Brian Talks Love, Sex, and Vulnerability

March 15, 2024

March 15, 2024

Katy O’Brian is a Breakout Star Who Shines in Loving and Hilariously Violent Crime Film English film director Rose Glass’...

Pacific Park on Santa Monica Pier Sold to SC Holdings, $10M Investment Planned

March 14, 2024

March 14, 2024

The Cultural Institution Set for Exciting Upgrades Santa Monica Amusements LLC (SMA), the operating group of Pacific Park on the...

Woman Returns $1K Worth of Stolen Items After Store Finds Her Social Media Account

March 14, 2024

March 14, 2024

For the Owner, the Incident Is Perhaps Indicative of an Environment at the Palisades Village Where Smaller Businesses Are More...

LAPD Identify Suspect Who Struck 6-Year-Old Girl Last Weekend

March 14, 2024

March 14, 2024

An Arrest Was Made Following “Another Incident” in Venice By Zach Armstrong  The Los Angeles Police have identified Ahsante Lamar...

SMC to Host Free Screening of West Coast Hip Hop Documentary

March 14, 2024

March 14, 2024

Free Presentation Includes Audience Q&A with Hip Hop Icons Santa Monica College (SMC) is set to host a complimentary screening...

IRS Launches Direct File Pilot of Free Filing Tool for Taxpayers in California, 11 Other States

March 14, 2024

March 14, 2024

Free, Convenient Online Tax Filing Option Now Available for Eligible Individuals The Internal Revenue Service (IRS) announced the official launch...