March 23, 2023 Breaking News, Latest News, and Videos

It’s Time to Reevaluate Scooter Rules

When an elderly lady tripped over a scooter lying on the sidewalk a year ago and fractured her hip and elbow, a perfect storm of inadequate City enforcement and dubious corporate behavior in Santa Monica became visible and transparent. 

The lady’s daughter had dropped her off in front of Emeritus College on Second Street. Stepping onto the curb, the woman tripped over a scooter and fell to the pavement.  She suffered multiple fractures in her hip and elbow, and underwent complicated and difficult surgery. The scooter had been left in the middle of the sidewalk illegally, in a zone designated as a no-dropoff area for scooters. The penalty for this violation, if it existed at all, proved ineffective as a deterrent both to the user and to the scooter company. The elderly lady’s life-course is now irreversibly altered.

Scooter-related violations continue with depressing regularity. A quick walk around the downtown area, the streets near the community college and other places reveals large numbers of scooters and electric shared bicycles, abandoned in the middle of sidewalks, obstructing curbside handicapped ramps, walkways and driveways throughout the city. And it’s not just scooter users: freelance scooter-charging operators, hired by mobility companies to retrieve the vehicles, charge their batteries and distribute them in the mornings, often park the scooters within bus stops, obstructing passengers trying to board or disembark buses.

The impact of these violations on pedestrians reads like a trauma center case-study handbook. A 67-year-old man, recovering from neck surgery, trips on a scooter on Main Street and puts his prior surgery recovery in danger.  A 72-year-old woman exiting a coffee shop on Main Street maneuvers around three electric scooters parked outside the entrance, trips and falls, and is hospitalized with multiple injuries. A 57-year-old woman, walking down 17th Street with a group of people, trips over a scooter lying across the sidewalk and breaks her foot. A colleague’s neighbor, around 80 years old, trips over a scooter while walking to church. Her severe injuries make it impossible for her to continue living alone. She is forced to abandon her home and neighborhood of 40 years and moves to an assisted-living facility in another city.

It seems incredible that such violations continue to victimize pedestrians, more than a year after a staff report unequivocally showed that impounding scooters and fining companies can dramatically reduce the number of violations. Why isn’t the City doing more to protect pedestrians from becoming victims of these vehicles and their users? Why does the City allow scooter companies to park their vehicles along streets, such as Lincoln Boulevard, where higher speed limits make scooter use illegal, thus almost inviting riders to break the law? Why does the City allow scooter users to ride across crosswalks? Doing so is not only illegal, it puts pedestrians in even greater danger, and yet a brief visit downtown shows frequent and widespread use of the crosswalks by scooter riders, especially during holidays when the area is densely populated by pedestrians.

In a recent City Council meeting to discuss extending the 18-month scooter “pilot project”, Council members expressed anxiety about the financial viability of the scooter companies.  Shouldn’t the priority be pedestrians? Where actual pedestrians are concerned, the often-touted idea of a “walkable city” seems to have disappeared. Even in the most recent staff report, the “Shared Mobility Pilot Program Summary Report” from November, the main references to pedestrians discussed collisions between scooters and pedestrians, not the actual dangers to pedestrians posed by improperly parked and discarded vehicles.

The city also shuts its eyes to other hazards and costs of these vehicles. It is strange that in this “environment-first” city there is no law, for example, that requires scooter companies to recycle batteries. There is no tracking of vehicles that have been removed from service (often after only two to four months) to understand their fate. There is no tracking of carbon emissions by internal combustion vans and trucks used to pick up and deliver scooters. There is no data showing a reduction in car trips coinciding with arrival of masses of scooters. The true environmental benefits of scooter use, touted by scooter companies worldwide, have been seriously challenged by numerous investigations, but our city displays no interest in these studies, and instead promotes the use of scooters in its efforts to eliminate parking structures and publicize its environmental leadership. 

In the effort to promote scooters as a way of eliminating cars, the city has relied on user data reported by users themselves, a dubious and unreliable source of information on which to base city policy. In a recent City Council meeting, the then-mayor used that questionable data to tout the program’s impact on reducing car use in the city. How many car trips were replaced by scooter rides in the first 18 months? Millions, she said. Millions of car trips. How do we know this? Well, users said so. Any hard evidence? None presented, only the self-reported surveys.

Other cities have done a lot more to make sidewalks safe for pedestrians. Phoenix, for example, requires companies to use so-called geofencing technology to prevent riders from ending a session outside of designated parking zones. Riders parking outside those zones continue to get charged by the minute until they move the vehicle to an approved spot. If a scooter is reported parked outside a parking zone, the company is forced to relocate the scooter or get fined. Sacramento assigns parking enforcement officers to take photos of scooters that block sidewalks. They use handheld devices used for cars, now modified for scooters and e-bikes, to record the time and locations of the violations. Tel-Aviv just introduced a new law that, among other things, reduces e-scooter speeds to safer and more manageable levels. All of these things can, and should be done in our city as well.

It is time for city leaders to step up, acknowledge the real hazards created by shared e-scooters to pedestrians in this community–a group that includes the most vulnerable populations we have–and take effective measures to end the problem. If we don’t do it, victims’ lawyers will. Already there are two important lawsuits against the city–the elderly lady mentioned at the top of this article, and a woman suffering from paraplegia who works in Santa Monica, and has her access to her job continually blocked by mis-located scooters.

Other cities have addressed this problem effectively. We can, and should, follow their lead without delay.

Daniel Jansenson, Architect, Building and Fire Life-Safety Commission

Santa Monica Architects for a Responsible Tomorrow: Thane Roberts, Architect, Robert H. Taylor AIA, Daniel Jansenson Architect, Building and Fire Life-Safety Commission, Ron Goldman FAIA, Samuel Tolkin Architect, Mario Fonda-Bonardi AIA, Planning Commissioner, Phil Brock, Arts Commissioner

Related Posts

Survey: Should Officials Remove Barriers to Outdoor Dining?

March 23, 2023

March 23, 2023

The COVID-19 pandemic drastically changed the way we live our lives, and one of the most significant impacts has been...

Gasolina Cafe Owner, Sandra Cordero, to Open New Tapas Bar in Santa Monica

March 23, 2023

March 23, 2023

Tapas bar expected to open late spring in former Heroic Italian space at 516 Santa Monica Boulevard  Sandra Cordero, the...

California’s AB 1217 Could Supersede Costly Outdoor Dining Permits Proposed by Municipalities

March 22, 2023

March 22, 2023

Legislation would preempt local ordinances and preserve regulatory flexibility for struggling neighborhood restaurants By Sam Catanzaro A new bill proposed...

Emerging Artist Jesse Liu Opens First-Ever Exhibition in Venice Gallery

March 22, 2023

March 22, 2023

“Spring Fever” currently on display at Yiwei Gallery By Keemia Zhang Local artist Jesse Liu has opened her first solo...

Santa Monica Place Invites LGBTQIA+ Artisans to Apply for Made With PRIDE Marketplace

March 21, 2023

March 21, 2023

Partnering with Streetlet, the marketplace will take place each weekend in June and showcase local goods made in Southern California....

Santa Monica Councilmember Phil Brock Appointed to National League of Cities Council on Youth, Education, and Families

March 21, 2023

March 21, 2023

Brock to collaborate with group of local leaders to develop and guide programs for communities across the country Santa Monica...

Santa Monica Receives $70,000 Donation From Kiwanis Charities for Scoreboards in Two Parks

March 21, 2023

March 21, 2023

Donation will fund the installation of new scoreboards at Historic Belmar Park and Los Amigos Park The Santa Monica City...

Should Santa Monica Close the Airport?

March 21, 2023

March 21, 2023

Santa Monica City Council recently voted to begin the process of closing Santa Monica Municipal Airport. The decision was kick-started...

City Council Puts Plan for Use of Parking Lots for Affordable Housing in Motion

March 21, 2023

March 21, 2023

Sites are located at 1217 Euclid Street, 1211-1217 14th Street and 1146 16th Street By Dolores Quintana ​​During the Santa...

Santa Monica Warns Residents of Crypto Ponzi Scheme

March 21, 2023

March 21, 2023

City says 30 + households in Santa Monica have reported being victimized by CryptoFX, LLC Over 30 households in Santa...

Man Arrested for Sexual Assaults Targeting Homeless Victims

March 20, 2023

March 20, 2023

Anthony Pittman faces rape charges in connection to series of sexual assaults A West Hollywood man has been arrested in...

SMa.r.t. Column: Going Bare

March 20, 2023

March 20, 2023

(part 3 of 3 articles) Every City faces periodic interruptions to its normal life. Some interruptions in our City are...

Santa Monica Mall Owner, Macerich, Finds Way Out of Retail Property Crisis

March 19, 2023

March 19, 2023

Move comes amidst a crisis for retail property owners, with loans coming due for refinancing with much higher interest rates...

Historic Santa Monica Property “The Witbeck House” Listed for Sale at $22.5M

March 19, 2023

March 19, 2023

Greene & Greene-designed home features 26,000+ square foot lot with five bedroom home A historic property known as The Witbeck...

New Affordable Housing Complex Completed in Santa Monica’s Pico Neighborhood

March 18, 2023

March 18, 2023

Las Flores offers 73 one-, two-, and three-bedroom apartments at 1834-1848 14th Street By Sam Catanzaro Community Corp. of Santa...