September 20, 2021 Breaking News, Latest News, and Videos

Plaintiffs in Voting Rights Case Against Santa Monica Petition for Rehearing

Decision “contains several critical legal and factual mistakes,” says petition

By Sam Catanzaro

Earlier this month an appeals court ruled in favor of the City of Santa Monica in a case that alleged that the city’s at-large elections diluted Latino voting power. Now the plaintiffs are petitioning for a rehearing, claiming the decision “contains several critical legal and factual mistakes.”

The case filed by plaintiffs Pico Neighborhood Association, Maria Loya and Advocates for Malibu Public Schools alleges that Santa Monica’s at-large election system dilutes Latino voting power in violation of the California Voting Rights Act (CVRA) and discriminates against Latino voters in violation of the Equal Protection Clause of the California Constitution.

In a ruling released February 15, 2019, Los Angeles Superior Court Judge Yvette M. Palazuelos ordered that all future elections for seats on the Santa Monica City Council be based on a seven-district map drawn by an expert for the plaintiffs, including a 30 percent Latino district. The City then appealed this decision.

On July 9, a three-judge panel from the California 2nd District Court of Appeal ruled in favor of the city saying that Latinos, who account for 14 percent of Santa Monica’s electorate, lack the numbers to win an election in the 30 percent Latino district ordered by Judge Palazuelos.

Kevin Shenkman, an attorney representing the plaintiffs, on July 24 filed a petition for rehearing to the 2nd District appeals court.

“The Opinion’s holding that the inability to create a hypothetical majority minority district in Santa Monica is fatal to the CVRA claim contravenes the plain language of the statute,” Shenkman wrote. “The Opinion also errs in ignoring the trial court’s factual finding, based on contested expert testimony and other evidence, that Latino-preferred Latino candidates who lost citywide often would have won election had the contest been limited to the remedial district proposed.”

In addition, Shenkman argued that the judges failed to follow clearly established principles governing the evaluation of factual evidence for determining the existence of intentional discrimination as protected by the Equal Protection Clause.

“Most starkly, the Opinion fails to cite or follow Village of Arlington Heights v. Metro. Housing Dev. Corp (1977) 429 U.S. 252, which held that in order to find an Equal Protection violation a trial court need not find that discrimination was the defendant’s ‘sole’ or “primary” purpose, just that a discriminatory purpose infected the actor’s decision-making,” Shenkman wrote.

As reported by the Santa Monica Outlook, Shenkman noted that it is “highly unlikely” that the case would be reheard, but said that the petition lays the groundwork for a potential appeal to the California Supreme Court.

in News
Related Posts

Is Cash Coming Back for the Big Blue Bus?

September 17, 2021

September 17, 2021

Santa Monica City Council discusses possibility of restoring cash service for buses  By Dolores Quintana Santa Monica lawmakers recently discussed...

UCLA Study Suggests Nearly Half of LGBT Renters Behind on Rent Fear Eviction Within 2 Months

September 17, 2021

September 17, 2021

UCLA study sheds light on concerning issue  By Susan Payne According to a recent UCLA study, nearly half of the...

Santa Monica Police Conducting DUI Checkpoint Friday Night

September 16, 2021

September 16, 2021

DUI and license checkpoint coming to undisclosed location  By Chad Winthrop Santa Monica police will conduct a DUI checkpoint Friday...

Veteran Killed in Stabbing at Encampment Alongside West Los Angeles VA

September 15, 2021

September 15, 2021

Wednesday morning incident under investigation    By Sam Catanzaro A homicide investigation is underway following a stabbing at a homeless encampment...

Santa Monica Partners with McCabe’s Guitar Shop for a Reimagined Annual Concert Series

September 14, 2021

September 14, 2021

Americana in the Park, a New Free Concert Series Launches this September and October By Sam Catanzaro The City of...

Vaccine and Mask Mandates for Santa Monica College In-Person Classes this Fall

September 14, 2021

September 14, 2021

As Santa Monica College returns for the fall semester new protocols are in place, learn about campus capacity, vaccine and...

Santa Monica Beat – Will Big Blue Buses Accept Cash Fare Again?: September 13, 2021

September 13, 2021

September 13, 2021

Local news and culture in under 5 minutes. * Will Big Blue Buses Accept Cash Fare Again? * Video Game...

Report Urges Against Splitting Santa Monica-Malibu School District

September 9, 2021

September 9, 2021

LA County Office of Education Division of Business Advisory Services releases report ahead of September 18 meeting By Sam Catanzaro...

Distinguished Speaker Series Expands to Long Beach, Celebrates 24 Years of Candid, Relaxed Evenings With Renowned Changemakers

September 7, 2021

September 7, 2021

Series features Former President George W. Bush in September, 24 years after his mother and former First Lady of the...

Two Classic Car Shows Are Coming To The Westside To Support Hispanic Heritage: Santa Monica Beat – September 7, 2021

September 7, 2021

September 7, 2021

Local news and culture in under 5 minutes. * Two Classic Car Shows Are Coming To The Westside To Support...

Road Rage Leads to Shooting in Santa Monica

September 7, 2021

September 7, 2021

Santa Monica police investigating September 6 incident By Sam Catanzaro Santa Monica police are investigating an incident of road rage...

Santa Monicans Frustrated After Getting Ticketed for Return of Weekly Street Sweeping

September 2, 2021

September 2, 2021

Residents say they were not notified resumption of regular sweeping this week  By Sam Catanzaro Many Santa Monica residents are...

Pacific Park’s Ferris Wheel Salutes American Workers With A 130-Feet Tall Waving American Flag Over Labor Day Weekend

September 2, 2021

September 2, 2021

Pacific Park on the Santa Monica Pier will honor American workers with the Ferris Wheel’s dazzling display of red, white...

Police Investigating Report of Shots Fired on Santa Monica Pier

September 1, 2021

September 1, 2021

SMPD investigating Tuesday night incident By Sam Catanzaro Police are investigating reports of shots fired on the Santa Monica Pier....