May 24, 2025 Breaking News, Latest News, and Videos

SMa.r.t. Column: The Future of Our City Is At Stake

On 2003, we embarked on the LUCE (Land Use Circulation Element) – a planning process outlining the future of our city. It took time and a lot of residential input before completing in 2010. Quoting the LUCE:

“The LUCE is a conservation plan.”

“Santa Monica has sought to maintain and perpetuate its small beachfront town character.”

“The intent is for the City to be generally a low scale community.”

“Concern is with the loss of character-defining buildings, particularly courtyard buildings” – which are representative of Santa Monica’s DNA!

“High density housing in the LUCE is 3-4 story multi-family with 30 ft and 40 ft height limits.”

“New boulevard use will emphasize mixed local serving ground floor commercial uses with 2-3 floors of residential above.”

“Paramount is the need to enhance pedestrian, bike, and small shuttle connections from the neighborhoods to retail services and the boulevards.”

“Throughout the City, open space will increase in size and quality?”

The desire of the community as noted above was to “achieve a balance between the human and the natural community” – a beachfront city, not an urban city, one that preserves its human scale and family life. 

Were these principles followed? Why are we going through a planning process that creates enormous negative impacts in our city? Unfortunately toward the end of the LUCE process, the development community along with a few of Santa Monica’s development friendly legal practitioners inserted the concept of Development Agreements which allows significant height increases, reduced parking, and increased density most often resulting in banal design, etc. – all in exchange for marginal contributions to the city budget or housing affordability. The Planning Commission and City Council have allowed developers to push beyond the limits of the LUCE with D.A.’s (Development Agreements) providing them and their corporate backers with substantially greater economic returns. This has resulted in our beachfront community rapidly losing its human scale and our quality of life!

To underline the inherent hypocrisy imbedded in the process, in March, 2008 Ted Winterer, then president of the Ocean Park Association and now a two-time City Councilmember, wrote an article in a local paper entitled “It’s hard to trust City Hall on development” – opining on how to “slow down the continuing over-development of our city!” Was he successful – hardly?! Today we face an uncertain future with a build to the max City Council including Mr. Winterer who has done a 180 degree about face regarding development. (With full disclosure, I am an architect who can speak from both sides, having developed 20 residential and commercial projects.)

So are we on a road to “nowhere”? How will this fast changing and diminishing quality of life affect our city? What will its future be? Just another piece of a larger metropolis. Recently the City Council finished constructing a 50,000 sq ft city hall annex at twice the cost of comparable municipal buildings. It then spent over $25 million fighting district elections and residents’ effort combatting the enormous benefit of development contributions to “friendly” incumbent re-election campaigns! In the time of Covid-19 shutdowns the City Council has pushed us to financial chaos with its “build more, tax more” approach. These unnecessary expenditures are coupled with huge pension obligations, crushing traffic, rising crime, homelessness and a reduced quality of life. Why would anyone even consider voting for these 5 incumbents?? And consider that four were actually appointed, not elected, to their first terms!

Santa Monica is currently built on a system of who you know and the greatest return on investment. But why does our City Council want a dense beachfront city? Have we lost our humanity? The council overspends on construction projects and pension obligations, and then becomes dependent on sales and property taxes and hotels and tourism. And increasing density has put an enormous strain on our infrastructure – from roads and water to police and fire personnel and equipment, and more. A philosophy of “more, more, more” instead of living within our means. Do we really want a city of elevators, narrow corridors and hand sanitizers instead of sunlight and blue skies. A city where everything looks similar – banal block apartment and office buildings with narrow or non-existent balconies. We need a new vision for our city instead of building more projects with still more staff all based on an addiction to tourism. Why are we pushing for more density – it’s idiotic, especially with an economic fallout that’s likely to last for five years or more. We need to be a city of “adaptive reuse” replacing our current mantra of “demolish and higher” – a beachfront town, not a downtown urban city.

We are currently in chaos – and not just financially. The rioting of May 30 represented a failure of leadership – indicative of the past eight years. Peaceful protesters were overtaken by looters and arsonists. We proved to be a soft target that day. We weren’t ready for war, it was just another sunny afternoon in Santa Monica. And once again our city management was missing in action. That day was indicative of our city’s increasing crime rate, with Santa Monica statistics putting us down as the 257th safest city in California. 

But the real tragedy is the process that allows this to happen. Developers are first and foremost about themselves and council members need to understand this. They need to stop approving significant changes which are presented as minor ones – and then are approved because developers are their biggest source of election funds. We need to live within the environment we found and not continue to manipulate it.

With the wheels of the City starting to come off, what can we do to not only maintain, but regain our beachfront environment. Instead of following, the LUCE, we have a piecemeal planning process, with piecemeal D.A.’s, with all their piecemeal, pervasive problems. 

This Council has created a financial nightmare, and Covid-19, with its economic and social unrest has shed light on our city’s internal failures. And then there’s Terry O’Day who shamefully suggests suspending long established community oversight regulations to “immediately stem the Covid losses.” The way our Council acquiesces to the development community resulting in the demise of our beachfront city is unbelievable. We don’t need Miramar Hotels that look like cruise ships or a Hampton Inn that resembles the plain rectangular boxes delivered from Amazon or Walmart. We have a Council that has the unique ability of demonstrating financial irresponsibility combined with a lack of transparency. We cannot continue to rely on development and taxes! We need to stop manipulating our environment and instead just living with it and in it?

This is all to say we need a clean slate of candidates who are not beholden to the development community. Just as we can’t afford four more years of existing Washington politics, we can ill-afford this Council. There are answers, but not by renewing this Council! We need to remember the people who got us into this mess are not the ones to get us out!! We need a Council willing to honor the LUCE which we, the residents, spent seven years drafting, but which very little is adhered to. We need a new City Council who will maintain the soul and beauty of our community.

BOTTOM LINE – WE NEED BROCK, FONDA-BONARDI, DE LA TORRE, AND PARRA FOR OUR CITY COUNCIL!!!!

Ron Goldman for SMa.r.t. (Santa Monica Architects for a Responsible Tomorrow)

Thane Roberts, Architect, Robert H. Taylor AIA, Ron Goldman FAIA, Architect, Dan Jansenson, Architect, Building and Fire-Life Safety Commission, Samuel Tolkin Architect, Mario Fonda-Bonardi, AIA, Planning Commissioner, Marc Verville, CPA (inactive), Phil Brock, Santa Monica Arts Commission. For previous articles see www.santamonicaarch.wordpress.com/writings.

<>Related Posts

Resilient Palisades Named Nonprofit of the Year by Sen. Ben Allen

May 23, 2025

May 23, 2025

Volunteer-led group honored for climate resilience work and wildfire recovery efforts Resilient Palisades, a grassroots environmental organization based in Pacific...

Governor Announces Early Reopening of Pacific Coast Highway After Wildfire Closures

May 22, 2025

May 22, 2025

Major Stretch of PCH Reopens May 23 After Months of Wildfire-Related Closures Governor Gavin Newsom announced Wednesday that State Route...

SM.a.r.t Column: Why Santa Monica Might Need a Desalination Plant, and Maybe Even Nuclear Power

May 22, 2025

May 22, 2025

Santa Monica is known for its ocean views, sunny skies, and strong environmental values. But there’s a challenge on the...

Film Review: Final Destination: Bloodlines

May 22, 2025

May 22, 2025

FILM REVIEWFINAL DESTINATION: BLOODLINESRated R110 MinutesReleased May 16th  This is the sixth entry in the Final Destination movie franchise that...

Bay Cities Deli Temporarily Closed After Health Violations

May 22, 2025

May 22, 2025

Eleven violation points were attributed to the presence of rodents and insects Bay Cities Italian Deli & Bakery, a popular...

Man Arrested in Stabbing Near Santa Monica Pier

May 22, 2025

May 22, 2025

Victim hospitalized with non-life-threatening injuries following altercation A man was arrested after allegedly stabbing another man during an altercation near...

Exclusive Interview with Cardinale du Vin’s New Chef-in-Residence Paul Chuanchaisit

May 22, 2025

May 22, 2025

The Westside Wine Bar Expands Its Culinary Horizons With a Bold New Menu By Dolores Quintana Cardinale du Vin is...

Palisades Bakery Aids Displaced Residents with Deliveries, Cookbook Donations After Fire

May 21, 2025

May 21, 2025

The bakery’s relief effort is aimed at ensuring that displaced residents continue to have access to familiar foods during recovery...

Memorial Day Weekend in L.A.: Rosé, Beach BBQs, and Brunches Ring in the Summer

May 21, 2025

May 21, 2025

The Westside Is Packed With Culinary Events, Pop-Ups, and Parties This Weekend Angelenos looking to kick off the summer season...

Summer at Annenberg Beach House to Include Sunset Picnics, Yoga Classes and the Annual Cardboard Yacht Regatta

May 21, 2025

May 21, 2025

The Beach House, located on the former Marion Davies estate, remains free and open to the public The Annenberg Community...

(Video) Interview with Chef Roy Choi for his new book The Choi of Cooking

May 21, 2025

May 21, 2025

We speak with the world-famous Socal Chef in Manhattan Beach at the Los Angeles Public Library.

FDA Probes Salmonella Outbreak Tied to Recalled Cucumbers Distributed in California

May 21, 2025

May 21, 2025

At Least 26 People Sickened and 9 Hospitalized in Multiple States  Federal health officials are investigating a multistate outbreak of...

10th Annual MAINopoly: A Taste of Main Street Comes to Santa Monica This Weekend

May 21, 2025

May 21, 2025

Annual board game-inspired food event set for Sunday, May 25 The 10th annual MAINopoly: A Taste of Main Street will...

Michelin Three Star Institution Brings 20th Anniversary Culinary Experience to Beverly Hills

May 21, 2025

May 21, 2025

Grant Achatz’s Alinea Heads to Beverly Hills for Summer Residency Renowned chef Grant Achatz and his team at Alinea, Chicago’s Michelin...

$2.2M Awarded to LA County for Wildfire Prevention Ahead of 2025 Fire Season

May 21, 2025

May 21, 2025

The grants mark the first disbursement of funds from Proposition 4, a bond measure that provides millions for wildfire resilience...