August 5, 2021 Breaking News, Latest News, and Videos

Saving a Failed Marriage Part 3 – Reconciliation ??

This is the third of a four-part article dealing with the very serious problem in which the development community in bed with Sacramento has challenged the residents of Santa Monica.

The first article outlined the failure of past City Councils, in collaboration with developers, produced only 8% of a 30% goal of “inclusionary” housing in exchange for increased height and density.  And reducing rents for the 8% inclusionary housing has only increased rents for the 92% of market rate units.  The city has become a cash cow for developers!  To correct this glaring problem, I’m suggesting the use of a modest amount of the 177 parcels owned by the city, much of which is either inefficiently used, or not in use.  This property would be developed by the city for affordable “garden apartments.”  Without the benefit of zero land cost, lower construction cost, and with reduced financing, permit processing costs, and city property taxes, there would be a 30-35% overall savings.  And this would also result in reduced rents for the remaining 92% market rate units. Additionally, it could pave a way for renters of the affordable units built on city property to apply their rental payments toward ownership once the city’s construction loan is paid off from their monthly rentals.

The second article dealt with the unfortunate partnership between developers and Sacramento under the guise of a substantial housing shortage calling for Santa Monica to provide 8,900 units of housing, including 6,000 affordable, in the next 8 years.  But currently with over 4,000 vacant units in Santa Monica, and with 1,100 in construction, we instead have an affordability crisis?  The SCAG numbers are a runaway trainwreck.  This baseless number translates into an all-out effort to “upzone” our city.  This ecologic and economic disaster of providing for a 20% increase in population also requires a corresponding 20% increase in infrastructure – water, power, sewage, police & fire, schools & libraries, etc.  Not only is this 8,900 number baseless, but our zoning capacity as currently exists can provide this growth should it ever be necessary!  Increasing housing supply through de-regulation is nonsense – benefitting only developers and land speculators.  “Upzoning” is the antithesis of a progressive housing policy.

Which brings us to this third article which I believe leads to a path forward – a path of reconciliation to maintain Santa Monica’s DNA.  “Upzoning” and “inclusionary” housing is not the answer for our vibrant and creative community.  It’s time to look beyond the lunacy of SCAG and discuss real solutions, what our city could look like while still allowing profitable but also creative development.  Vacant or underutilized downtown, boulevard, and multi-family zoned properties along with repurposing vacant retail and office space, providing ADUs (Accessory Dwelling Units) on single-family properties and even conversion of Airbnb units are all adequate answers to provide the density, height, design and open space necessary and appropriate to Santa Monica while staying within our basic height limits of 32 feet and 3 stories.  And this can provide profits appropriate to the developers without adding one more foot in height, much less one story!  In other words, existing zoning has substantial capacity, without “canyonizing” our community!

Downtown:  The downtown area is over 4.2% of our city. 15% of this area is either vacant or paved parking or has a one-story building on a portion of the site.  This represents over 1 million square feet of property and 2.75 million square feet of development at a 2.75 FAR (floor area ratio).  This would provide over 2,200 – 2nd, 3rd & 4th floor apartments above 650,000 sf of new ground floor commercial or live/work space.  After recouping the lost income from 2 years of construction and leasing, the property’s owner/developer will then realize a 300% increase in net income.

Boulevards:  The boulevards are 7.6% of our city.  There are currently 20-25 block-long sites and 30-35 half-block sites which are vacant with surface parking or a combination of parking and smaller one-story buildings. Re-developing these properties, with 2-stories of residential overlooking ground floor commercial or live/work space around courtyards or meandering sidewalks behind “Mom & Pop” shops, will offer relief from the continuous building blocks hugging narrow sidewalks.  These properties re-developed can provide over 2,000 apartments and 800,000 sq ft of ground floor commercial or live/work space.  And lost income during the 2 years of construction and leasing can become a 300% or more increase in rentable income in the 3rd or 4th year.  Instead of “upzoning,” let’s use this mandate as a vehicle to re-direct the character of our boulevards!

R2 Multi-family:  There are more than 30-35 parcels within a block of these boulevards which are vacant or with surface parking and could house over 500 garden apartments!

Vacant Commercial:  There’s literally a ton of vacant retail and office space, more than one million sq ft – 15-20% in Santa Monica with vacancies even higher on the Promenade and along the mall in Santa Monica Place where both Bloomingdales and Banana Republic permanently closed!  Wouldn’t mixed-use along these 2 malls look awfully attractive in addition to invigorating tourism and bringing back “mom & pop” space which couldn’t afford the recent higher corporate rents!  Upper floor office space can re-locate to the ground floor.  And re-purposing vacant retail and office space is easier to remodel and quite economical with existing parking, the building’s shell already in place, and permit processing much easier.  And there’s all the hotels in question!  And of course all this potential is limited by the capacity of our infrastructure!!!  By code, every new building must be net zero, which means 3 stories in height!  All this in addition to the 4,000 currently vacant units along with 1,100 currently under construction!  Goodbye “upzoning” !!

ADU’s & Jr. ADU’s:  And when you add 9,000 single-family homes to the list along with Airbnb units standing vacant from the lack of tourism, the capacity far exceeds any reasoned limit of growth.

So how can we turn a negative into a positive?  How can we take advantage of all this capacity while dealing with unrealistic state mandates?  Can we make this housing element positive instead of “canyonizing” our city?  And what will our city look like after 8 years of this housing mandate?  Will we continue to be a low-rise city?  Can we discuss the quality of growth as well as the quantity of growth?  If we need to plan for all this housing, can we also plan for the environment the residents will dwell in?

With our city divided and our city administration in flux, with an interim city manager and city attorney, we are a house divided, a city divided!

Next week’s article will address these issues – please stay tuned.

Ron Goldman FAIA for SMa.r.t.

(Santa Monica Architects for a Responsible Tomorrow)

Thane Roberts, Architect, Robert H. Taylor AIA, Ron Goldman FAIA, Architect, Dan Jansenson, Architect, Building and Fire-Life Safety Commission, Samuel Tolkin Architect, Mario Fonda-Bonardi, AIA, Planning Commissioner, Marc Verville CPA Inactive, Michael Jolly, AIRCRE

For previous articles see www.santamonicaarch.wordpress.com/writing 

Related Posts

New Street Furniture Program Coming to Bus Stops Across Los Angeles

August 4, 2021

August 4, 2021

StreetsLA is debuting a new program adding shade, seating, and other amenities to bus stops across Los Angeles. Brought to...

New Renderings Revealed for Future Multi-Use Building on La Cienega blvd

August 4, 2021

August 4, 2021

The SHop will be a multifamily housing and office space replacing the self-storage facility on the corner of La Cienega...

New West LA High-Rise Apartment Building Reaches its Final Height

August 4, 2021

August 4, 2021

“The Landmark” is the tallest apartment building West of the 405 and the first new high-rise built in the last...

Santa Monica’s UCLA Hospital Ranks No. 1 in State, No. 3 in Nation

August 3, 2021

August 3, 2021

Highest set of rankings ever for UCLA Health  By Sam Catanzaro UCLA Health hospitals have ranked No. 1 in both...

La County Health Lifts Water Advisory For Santa Monica Beaches: Santa Monica Beat – August 2, 2021

August 2, 2021

August 2, 2021

Local news and culture in under 5 minutes. * La County Health Lifts Water Advisory For Santa Monica Beaches *...

Man Killed in Santa Monica Hit and Run

August 2, 2021

August 2, 2021

Fatality occurs early Monday morning on Santa Monica Boulevard By Sam Catanzaro A man was killed in a hit and...

Millions of Gallons of Partially Treated Sewage Continue to be Discharged Into Santa Monica Bay

August 2, 2021

August 2, 2021

Hyperion Water Reclamation Plant still not operating at full efficiency following July spill  By Sam Catanzaro Three weeks after a...

Update on $870M UCLA Student Housing Expansion Project

August 2, 2021

August 2, 2021

UCLA is expanding student housing with 3 buildings currently in development. Video brought to you by Hillside Memorial.

Library Director Patty Wong to Leave Santa Monica

July 30, 2021

July 30, 2021

Santa Monica Public Library (SMPL) Director Patty Wong announced recently that she will leave Santa Monica to take on the...

City Council Prioritizes Housing for Historically Displaced Households

July 28, 2021

July 28, 2021

At its meeting on July 13, Santa Monica City Council made changes to Santa Monica’s Affordable Housing Production Program and...

Homeless Man Charged with Hate Crime in Assault of Korean Woman in Santa Monica

July 27, 2021

July 27, 2021

Melvin Taylor faces charges in connection to July 23 incident By Sam Catanzaro Hate crime charges have been filed against...

Homeless Advocate Arrested Near Shelter on Suspicion of Dealing Drugs, Claims no Wrongdoing

July 27, 2021

July 27, 2021

65-year-old Garry Featherstone accused of selling meth, PCP By Sam Catanzaro A self-described homeless outreach advocate was recently arrested near...

Off Leash Dog Park And Picnic Area Coming To Downtown Santa Monica: Santa Monica Beat – July 27, 2021

July 27, 2021

July 27, 2021

Local news and culture in under 5 minutes. * Off Leash Dog Park And Picnic Area Coming To Downtown Santa...