February 7, 2023 Breaking News, Latest News, and Videos

SMa.r.t. Column: Power to the People

Electrical power is now determining much of modern life from smartphones, to electric toothbrushes, to scooters to cars and beyond the usual lights and air-conditioning. Its generation distribution and consumption is no longer just a question of lifestyle choices but is now shaping the evolution of our City and region. 

We are fortunate in Santa Monica that we have a choice to purchase our power from two sources. We can buy our power from SCE which generates their power from a mix of about 50% renewable and 50% fossil fuel sources OR, for slightly more cost,  from the Clean Power Alliance (CPA) which is essentially a power brokerage that buys its power from renewable clean power sources such as photovoltaics (PV), windmills, hydroelectric,  geothermal, etc.. The CPA then sends this “clean” power to you via the same power lines and transformers that SCE uses. 

The advantage of shifting our power sources to almost all renewables is two fold: it reduces our City’s contribution to global warming by reducing the greenhouse gases vented by burning, coal, oil or gas and it also reduces the cancer and asthma among other disease caused by the  air pollution spewed by the combustion of those same fuels.

Current Pollution Impacts

While global warming is increasingly cooking our entire society, our polluted air already silently kills a catastrophic number of people each year in the LA basin. Approximately 9000 Californians EACH year die due to air pollution particulate matter (http://publichealth.lacounty.gov/eh/tea/toxicepi/criteriaairpollutants.htm) which corresponds proportionally to about 20 Santa Monicans or about 5 times our typical 4 annual deaths from our automobile accidents. Needless to say residents with pollution weakened respiratory systems are much more vulnerable to respiratory viruses like Covid 19.

Since about 40% of LA’s air pollution comes from tail pipes (https://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-climatechange-california-insight-idUSKCN1PQ4MJ) even a small shift to electric cars powered by renewable sourced power can save hundreds of lives annually. While we may be the world’s capital of hybrids and Teslas, this is just the beginning of a long path to energy sustainability and resilience. 

No free lunch in the dessert

While relying on the CPA is a no brainer for those that can afford the extra cost, there are, however, some notable downsides:  

1.Because most of CPA’s power is produced in large desert (where land is cheap) PV collector arrays and windmills or by distant hydroelectrics far from our City where it is actually consumed, we endure unavoidable transmission losses (mostly heat from transmission wires) which  makes our entire system less efficient.

2. These large installations also have serious consequences for the local ecology including PV shading which alters the heat balance of the desert, windmills relentlessly massacring migratory birds and butterflies,  and other effects on plants and animals (and the scenic quality) where their size disrupts the local ecology. 

3. Most of these large installations are located  on the East side of the San Andreas Fault. In the event of an inevitable large movement there, we could possibly be cut off from this power source temporarily or for a long time based on how fast the reconstruction progresses. Our society is extremely and increasingly dependent on constant power and any interruption would be catastrophic. This is CPA’s most serious downside. 

4. Unlike remote power sources, buildings that generate their power locally, usually but not always from their rooftops, often have a visible meter in the lobby or even in individual units say, where the occupants can, in real time, regularly see how the sun is doing in meeting their power needs. This immediate feedback reminder encourages personal conservation which is a significant variable in the overall power balance. When the renewable sources are far away and visually disconnected from us, we are inclined to forget our personal role and just treat it all wantonly as “free” power since we are told it comes from the wind or the sun.

5. Eventually our expanded demand for sunny deserts and the best desirable windy hills and valleys, which today seems infinite, but are actually finite (remember the oceans too  felt infinite  till we filled them all with micro plastic) will collide with other cities (San Diego, Phoenix, Las Vegas) and Indian reservations  who are also trying to put their City or tribes on a sustainable footing. These solar/wind  wars, like water wars in the West  will be highly divisive, pricy and unnecessary if we have already shifted our City to locally produced power. 

In other words CPA’s  large distributed power installations, while  a necessary first step,  increase our ecological “footprint,” although certainly much less than the current global disastrous ecological “footprint” of  the oil industry that generates most of our power and Mid-East conflicts today. By shrinking our ecological footprint to more exactly fit our city,  we live within our means which has many ecological, social, health and financial benefits in the regional and worldwide scramble for increasingly scarce resources. 

Power self-sufficiency and local density

Eventually that shrinkage means using our buildings themselves to generate power in the City where we consume most of it. In practical terms this means roof top PV solar collectors and a zoning code that prevents or minimizes  their shading from neighboring buildings.

With todays technology these collectors can generate all the power needs of a typical 3 story building. However, as PV collectors get more efficient (eg generate more power from the same exposed area) AND as buildings get more efficient (more efficient refrigerators, elevators,  air-conditioners etc, etc.) we can increase the height and density of buildings and still live within our “means”. Assuming these technological improvements, I feel that, to make our City sustainable and resilient, our zoning code should have 2 stories in the residential areas, 3 stories along the boulevards and 4 stories in the downtown areas and transit hubs. 4 stories should be considered because their additional demand will shortly be met by improvements already on the horizon  in PV collector efficiencies and it gives us greater leverage in reducing urban sprawl. 

Naturally future far reaching technological improvements might lift us beyond the  2/3/4 story limits which can always be increased if all the other urban needs (water, open space, fire, police, schools , etc.) can also be met.

Looking Ahead

Finally we will soon need to face the huge problem of night time power storage on an industrial scale. Batteries, flywheels, uphill water pumping, phase change materials , etc., and other new storage technologies will be needed to store all that locally produced  sun and wind power for nighttime usage.  For the foreseeable future though, we will still need to maintain our fossil fuel infrastructure but can start pruning it by judicious decommissioning as more local renewable sources and our storage capacity increase.    

I know these are complex issues but there is a sustainable and resilient path forward to power our City of the future .

By Mario Fonda-Bonardi for S.M.a.r.t Santa Monica Architects for a Responsible Tomorrow

Thane Roberts, Architect, Robert H. Taylor AIA, Ron Goldman FAIA, Architect, Dan Jansenson, Architect, Building and Fire-Life Safety Commission, Samuel Tolkin Architect, Mario Fonda-Bonardi, AIA, Planning Commissioner,

Marc Verville CPA Inactive, Michael Jolly, AIR CRE. 

For previous articles see www.santamonicaarch.wordpress.com/writing

in Opinion
Related Posts

SMa.r.t. Column: To a Better Housing Element

February 3, 2023

February 3, 2023

Your City is busy rewriting much of its zoning code to implement our new Housing Element as demanded by the...

Santa Monica Police Chief’s Message to the Community

January 30, 2023

January 30, 2023

January 27, 2023  Dear Santa Monica Community,  The Santa Monica Police Department (SMPD) would like to extend our heartfelt condolences...

Column: State Usurping Key Powers From Cities

January 28, 2023

January 28, 2023

By Tom Elias All over California last fall, hundreds of the civic minded spent thousands of hours and millions of...

Column – A California Positive: Kids Swarm Extra Classes

January 24, 2023

January 24, 2023

By Tom Elias It’s become a cliché, the shibboleth that California has lousy public schools and most of the kids...

SMa.r.t. Column: Let’s Get Real and Apply Practical Common Sense

January 20, 2023

January 20, 2023

This week’s column is a letter to the City Council, written by Arthur Jeon and sent in this past week....

SMa.r.t. Column: Water Water Everywhere

January 13, 2023

January 13, 2023

The new year has started with water, lots of WATER. The west coast and particularly central and northern California have...

S.M.a.r.t. Looks Ahead

December 31, 2022

December 31, 2022

It’s that time of the year again, when people and organizations look ahead and make resolutions to try to do...

SMa.r.t. Column: Refugees in our Midst

December 22, 2022

December 22, 2022

We published this article exactly five years ago. We leave it to the reader to consider whether this article is...

Column – Superintendent’s Message: Farewell SMMUSD

December 21, 2022

December 21, 2022

Dear Parents, Guardians, Staff, Students and Community Members, I write this last message to the community with both a heavy...

Pacific Ocean Park– A Positive & Optimistic Place in Santa Monica’s History

December 16, 2022

December 16, 2022

It’s the Holidays again, and we hope your spirits of joy and happiness are being well celebrated! In continuation of...

The Street Seen: Crescent Bay Park

December 12, 2022

December 12, 2022

Our guest columnist this week is Ocean Park local, Mark Gorman. Mark writes a semi-monthly local blog he calls “Street...

​​Column: No One Very Pleased as New Rooftop Solar Rules Improve

December 9, 2022

December 9, 2022

By Tom Elias, Columnist Only rarely does the California Public Utilities Commission, long known as the least responsive agency in...

A SMa.r.t. Thanksgiving

November 23, 2022

November 23, 2022

SMart has much to be thankful for this year: We are thankful for the courage of all who face death...

SMa.r.t. Column: Renting and Owning. The Santa Monica Long View

November 18, 2022

November 18, 2022

In May, 2020, SMa.r.t. urged the city to consider establishing community land trusts, in which community-owned land is leased at...

SMa.r.t. Column: Santa Monica Housing Development – Poison Pills, Bad Data and the Blame Game

November 11, 2022

November 11, 2022

Prior councils have made long term decisions that have locked the city into an extraordinarily fixed path, the consequences of...