January 16, 2022 Breaking News, Latest News, and Videos

Food Review: Pizza That Lives up to the Hype

Prime Pizza, now on the Westside, serves up a top-notch slice

By Kerry Slater

A highly anticipated pizza joint recently opened its first Westside location that lives up the hype with NY-style pies that compete with anywhere in Los Angeles. 

Recently Prime Pizza opened a location at 2219 Santa Monica Boulevard in West Los Angeles for daily service 11 a.m. to 10 p.m. With other locations in Fairfax, Little Tokyo and Burbank, the restaurant gained national recognition earlier this year when Barstool Sports’ Dave Portnoy gave the pizza an 8.1/10 rating, calling it the best pizza he has ever had in Los Angeles. 

“This is my number 1 pizza in LA I’ve had, hands down,” Portnoy said. 

So does this claim hold up? 

For dinner some friends and I ordered five different pizzas: cheese, pepperoni, sausage, Sicilian and white. For the sake of this review, I will stick to the cheese pizza, both because it was the best and also because it was the one I ate first when it was piping hot. That being said, all the pizzas offered at Prime were top notch with the exception of the white pizza, in my opinion. 

Off the bat, the first thing that stood out with the cheese pizza at Prime is the look. The marinara sauce really popped as did the crust with scattered charred bits (which is a good thing). For garnish, some basil strips were spread fairly evenly on top of the glistening mozzarella and sauce.  

Picking up a piece, things were off to a good start with the thin yet firm crust preventing the slice from flopping. From a taste perspective, this was as good a slice of cheese pizza as I have had in Los Angeles. The slightly tangy tomato sauce and cheese were perfectly proportioned and the result was a slice of pizza that was cruncy, rich and just greasy enough. 

So is Prime Pizza the best NY-style pizza in the Los Angeles-area? I am not going to make that claim since there are so many places I have not been to. I do feel comfortable, however, making the claim that Prime Pizza is arguably the best NY-style pizza on the Westside.

There are two other places in the area that offer comparable slices: Milo SRO Pizza (826 Pico Blvd, Santa Monica) and Joe’s Pizza (111 Broadway, Santa Monica). Prime, in my opinion, takes the crown. Not only because it is slightly the cheapest at $22 for a large pie–compared to $24 and $23 at Milo and Joe’s respectively–but also because it is the most consistent. I have been back twice since first drafting this review and it’s been just as stellar on both occasions, and I got the pies within 30 minutes of calling in my order. The last time I picked up a pizza from Joe’s it was too greasy and the last time I ordered at Milo SRO I had to wait an hour. 

So if you’re looking for some no-frills pizza, you can’t go wrong with Prime Pizza. 

Taste: 8.1/10
Value: 8.5/10
Quality: 8/10
Overall: 8.2/10

in Dining
Related Posts

Hurry Curry Coming to Santa Monica

January 12, 2022

January 12, 2022

Westside favorite to open in March on Ocean Park By Dolores Quintana Former Sawtelle favorite Hurry Curry of Tokyo will...

Montana Avenue Teahouse Opens After Long Journey

January 5, 2022

January 5, 2022

Buena Vida Tea now open at 726 Montana Avenue By Dolores Quintana Buena Vida Tea has fully opened its tea...

Food Review: Go Go Bird Brings LA-Style Fried Chicken to Westside

January 5, 2022

January 5, 2022

Chef Brandon Kida’s Go Go Bird comes to Citizen Public Market By Dolores Quintana Culver City’s Citizen Public Market has...

State Approves Demolition and Renovation of Original Hot Dog on a Stick in Santa Monica

January 3, 2022

January 3, 2022

Renovation plans call for demolition of 1946 stand on Santa Monica Beach By Dolores Quintana The original and beloved Hot...

Santa Monica Mirror’s Best Westside Dishes of 2021

December 28, 2021

December 28, 2021

By Sam Catanzaro Whether it’s breakfast, lunch, dinner or anytime in-between, the Westside has no shortage of world-class food to...

Langer’s Expands Delivery Service to Westside With Hefty Price Tag

December 22, 2021

December 22, 2021

$74 for two sandwiches  By Dolores Quintana Langer’s Deli, the venerated and 74-year-old institution, knows what the Westside has been...

Tyra Banks Closes Santa Monica Ice Cream Shop

December 21, 2021

December 21, 2021

Plus COVID-19 outbreak at Venice restaurant, popular Westside burger joint expands Westside Dining Scene December 23, 2021 | By Dolores...

Islands Closes in Marina, Schwartz’s Opening on Pico, Prime Pizza Coming to Santa Monica

December 15, 2021

December 15, 2021

Westside Dining Scene December 16, 2021 By Dolores Quintana and Sam Catanzaro Schwartz’s Opening on Pico In the Pico-Robertson District,...

Two Santa Monica Restaurants Vandalized

December 15, 2021

December 15, 2021

Numerous such incident occurring in the LA-area By Dolores Quintana In recent weeks, there have been several incidents of vandalism...

Former SpaceX Engineer Opening Robotic Pizza Restaurant

December 15, 2021

December 15, 2021

Stellar Pizza coming to LA-area in 2022 By Dolores Quintana Stellar Pizza, a new robotic pizza restaurant concept from a...

Renowned Tokyo-Born Ramen Restaurant Opens Third U.S. Location on the Westside

December 15, 2021

December 15, 2021

Ramen Nagi makes SoCal debut in Westfield Century City By Kerry Slater A legendary Japanese ramen restaurant has opened its...

CBD Restaurant Coming to Santa Monica

December 8, 2021

December 8, 2021

Chef Chris Sayegh copening Pico Boulevard restaurant By Dolores Quintana A CBD bar and restaurant will be coming to Pico...

One of LA’s Best Omakase Counters is Tucked Away in a Santa Monica Hotel Lobby

December 8, 2021

December 8, 2021

Sushi Chef Masa Shimakawa’s Soko restaurant offers an extraordinary culinary experience By Sam Catanzaro Tucked into the lobby of a...

Popular Wilshire Boulevard Sushi Spot Closes

December 1, 2021

December 1, 2021

Westside Dining Scene December 2, 2021 By Dolores Quintana Kimuya Sushi and Sports Bar in Santa Monica is no more...

Popular Gluten-Free Pasta Restaurant Opening Second Santa Monica Location

November 23, 2021

November 23, 2021

Impasta opening next year at 413 Santa Monica Boulevard.  A popular gluten-free pasta restaurant will be opening its second location...