January 27, 2023 Breaking News, Latest News, and Videos

SMa.r.t. Column: Water Woes Not Be Gone

Re-visiting a column of ours from 2014. The more things change, the more they stay the same.  

“Water Woes” from 12/29/14 

“By now everyone knows about the drought, although some people seem to be in denial about the problem it presents. For those who haven’t heard yet, there is a 20 percent reduction in water use proposed for residents and businesses. 

However, new developments‚ some of them especially water-intensive, continue to make their way through the planning process. Even as residents try to reduce their consumption, the city’s overall consumption is well on its way to new heights. 

Santa Monica gets much of its water from its own wells, purchasing the rest from the  Metropolitan Water District. MWD water, which comes from the Colorado River, rain and snowmelt, is especially susceptible to the effects of drought, and as the water supply from the state diminishes, the cost of that water will rise. 

To reduce the impact of an unstable state water supply, the City developed a plan to be water self-sufficient by 2020. Included in this plan are construction of two new wells, and various other water-conservation measures and treatment plant improvements. 

As with our current wells, new wells will draw from a vulnerable underground supply shared, and desired, by others, with no current restrictions on who can draw upon that underground source. 

New conservation measures, while laudable, will not reverse the rising water-consumption trend, because conservation cannot trump an increase in the number of users, and the proposed increased fees do not ‘make’ more water. 

In January 2013 the city consumed approximately 10 million gallons of water per day. We were asked to conserve a mere 200,000 gals per day, a reduction of two gallons per day per person, or 2 percent. One year later, in January of 2014, water consumption had jumped to 12 million gallons per day, a 20 percent increase! And now, after the State declared a severe drought and asked for voluntary conservation efforts, consumption has risen another 2 percent. 

Today we’re faced with mandatory cuts at the risk of significant penalties. Yet we see no serious attempt to put the brakes on excessive development, with several development agreements having just been presented to the Planning Commission and City Council. 

A 12-story mixed-use commercial/residential/hotel project proposed downtown, will have enormous impact on existing infrastructure, especially water demand. Two hotels have already been approved, and another very large mixed-use project at the Fred Segal site, as well as eight mixed-use residential/commercial projects in a four-block area along Lincoln Blvd.

Twenty-two projects in a 12-block area of downtown have applied for development agreements.  And this does not include the three proposed condo/hotel projects on Ocean Avenue that many in this community consider ridiculously over-scaled. 

City government has not asked us to subsidize new development. but that is the net effect of continuing to encourage and process large developments that increase the city’s water consumption, especially projects substantially larger than basic zoning allows. Is this something residents want? 

This past year has been the driest in recorded California history. There was a similar dry year over 100 years ago, but our population has grown 40 times since then‚ and with indoor plumbing and hygiene changes, consumption is probably closer to 100 times what it was then. 

The City’s solutions to water shortages depend on access to resources over which the city has little control. This includes the new wells, accessing regional aquifers over which we have no control of depletion since they are available to others. And with any shortfalls provided by the wells, the City will have to purchase water from MWD, whose sources are also being depleted. 

The reliance on uncontrollable resources means that a reliable plan cannot, in fact, be prepared,  and the risk of draconian cuts and ballooning costs increases with each new project being approved. We already see proposed rate increases to account for aging infrastructure, which loses about 13% through leakage, and these costs will increase further as the infrastructure must be adapted to all the new projects approved or in the pipeline. 

The City is already doing some things right, on the water conservation side. But more must be  done: 

The city must commit to the widespread use of greywater systems, and plan for a fully greywater-enabled city within the next twenty years; 

The city should require the installation of water meters in all dwellings and apartments; Efficient metering and control systems for hotels should be mandatory; 

A more aggressive water-use policing effort throughout the City should be implemented  immediately; 

A strong rain harvesting effort is needed as well. 

It is clear that with a severe drought upon us, we should all do our part to conserve water, even as we understand that conserving water is not the same as increasing the supply. 

The State requires new developments with more than 500 units to supply their own water, exclusive of the city’s supply. Such projects must go outside the city to obtain their own water.  As part of SMa.r.t, we believe that our City’s own policies on infrastructure and development should be held to the same standard of reduced demand, including placing a hold on large projects unable to provide their own water supplies.

There are at least 2100 new units in the pipeline just downtown, but the City does not require those projects to bring their own water because none reaches the 500-unit threshold (the defunct Hines project ‘oddly’ limiting itself to 498 units). 

Residents and local businesses already carry the weight of conservation in the city, even as the daytime population swells to over 300,000 transient visitors who consume water at hotels, restaurants, beach showers, and public restrooms. There is no reason to burden residents and local businesses with the increased infrastructure costs that large developments bring, in this water-constrained environment. 

For many years, comedians and radio pundits referred to Santa Monica as “the home of the  homeless.” Let’s make sure our city will never be known as “the home of the waterless.” 

Dan Jansenson, Architect and Bob Taylor, A.I.A. for SMa.r.t.” 

That column was seven years ago. In fairness, the City has made some minor improvements,  but, the drought conditions have worsened with much of the State in extreme drought conditions and some communities running out of water, and with draconian cuts up to 40% imposed on others. 

One has to ask with what logic would the State think a good solution to solving a worsening water shortage might be to increase density and population, and why would a go-along City  Council chose to not join other communities that have united to fight the State mandates. In the case of Santa Monica, the council, by not opposing, is agreeing to a potential 20% population increase in our 8.4 sq mi. beach town. Not very good math it seems. 

Bob Taylor, Architect, AIA for SMa.r.t. 

Santa Monica Architects for a Responsible Tomorrow 

Ron Goldman, Architect FAIA; Dan Jansenson, Architect, Building & Fire-Life Safety  Commissioner; Mario Fonda-Bonardi AIA, Planning Commissioner; Robert H. Taylor,  Architect AIA: Thane Roberts, Architect; Sam Tolkin, Architect; Marc L. Verville M.B.A.,  CPA (inactive); Michael Jolly, AIRCRE

Related Posts

Column – A California Positive: Kids Swarm Extra Classes

January 24, 2023

January 24, 2023

By Tom Elias It’s become a cliché, the shibboleth that California has lousy public schools and most of the kids...

Tour Your Future Dream Home with Shann Silver

January 23, 2023

January 23, 2023

Introducing the one-of-a-kind Designer Perfect Architectural home by Ken Ungar– your chance to experience SoCal living at its finest! With...

Million Dollar Listing To Sell Local Luxury Estate: Santa Monica Real Estate Report – January 23rd, 2023

January 23, 2023

January 23, 2023

Property, Developments, And Listings On The Westside.* Million Dollar Listing To Sell Local Luxury Estate* New Data Shows Luxury Brick...

Disbarred Attorney Sentenced to Prison for Deceiving Investors with Real Estate Scheme Involving Santa Monica, Hermosa Beach and LA Properties

January 22, 2023

January 22, 2023

Prosecutors say defendant DEREK Jones sold interests in real estate that he did not own DEREK Jones, a disbarred California...

Century-Old California Craftsman Home Hits Market Steps from Santa Monica Beach

January 21, 2023

January 21, 2023

$4.4 million price tag on Vicente Ter home Nestled on a tranquil, tree-lined block of Santa Monica, mere steps from...

California Business Group Files Lawsuit Against Santa Monica Transfer Tax Initiative

January 21, 2023

January 21, 2023

California Business Roundtable files lawsuit The Transfer Tax Initiative By Dolores Quintana A California business organization has filed a lawsuit...

SMa.r.t. Column: Let’s Get Real and Apply Practical Common Sense

January 20, 2023

January 20, 2023

This week’s column is a letter to the City Council, written by Arthur Jeon and sent in this past week....

Affordable Housing Development Takes Shape at Former Nikkei Hall Site

January 16, 2023

January 16, 2023

The Laurel will bring 57 apartments to Michigan Avenue and 14th Street A $37.3-million development named The Laurel is being...

Developer WS Communities Completes First Application For The Builder’s Remedy Project: Santa Monica Real Estate Report – January 16th, 2023

January 16, 2023

January 16, 2023

Property, Developments, And Listings On The Westside.* David Bonderman And Christa Campbell Buy Two Westside Homes For $30M Total* Developer...

Justice Department Secures Over $31 Million from City National Bank to Address Redlining Allegations

January 16, 2023

January 16, 2023

Represents the largest redlining settlement under Attorney General Merrick B. Garland’s Combating Redlining Initiative The Justice Department has announced a...

Two Santa Monica Deals Among Largest Leases in LA-Region for 2022

January 14, 2023

January 14, 2023

Lionsgate and Amazon among top-5 Los Angeles-area leases last year By Dolores Quintana Los Angeles’ office space real estate has...

SMa.r.t. Column: Water Water Everywhere

January 13, 2023

January 13, 2023

The new year has started with water, lots of WATER. The west coast and particularly central and northern California have...

City Approves 14 New Developments In Downtown Area: Santa Monica Real Estate Report – January 9th, 2023

January 9, 2023

January 9, 2023

Property, Developments, And Listings On The Westside.* City Approves 14 New Developments In Downtown Area * Gwyneth Paltrow’s Childhood Home Just...

New Green Spaces and Bike Lanes Seeking Funding From City

January 9, 2023

January 9, 2023

Former City Councilmember Mike Bonin announced last minute motions to improve infrastructure before his departure. .Video sponsored by DPP.

Mixed-Use Development Underway at 601 Wilshire in Santa Monica

January 8, 2023

January 8, 2023

Project will include 40 units and 6,000 square feet of retail space By Dolores Quintana Cypress Equity Investments has begun...