May 9, 2025 Breaking News, Latest News, and Videos

Report Urges Against Splitting Santa Monica-Malibu School District

LA County Office of Education Division of Business Advisory Services releases report ahead of September 18 meeting

By Sam Catanzaro

A recent report recommends Los Angeles County education officials deny moving forward with a proposal to split the public school district serving Santa Monica and Malibu. 

On September 2, the LA County Office of Education Division of Business Advisory Services released a report on a proposal to form a Malibu Unified School District (USD) from territory currently within the Santa Monica-Malibu Unified School District (Santa Monica-Malibu USD).

The analysis, prepared for the LA County Committee on School District Organization (County Committee), concluded that this split would negatively affect the financial status of the resulting Santa Monica USD, should it be approved, recommending that the County Committee deny moving the proposal forward. 

The Committee convened a first public hearing on April 17 and a second hearing is scheduled for September 18 where a decision will be made. 

The analysis found that eight of nine conditions required under the County’s education code were not substantially met. 

The primary reason given was that a resulting Malibu USD may not have, or be able to maintain, enrollment of at least 1,501 students, a number required under California law. 

“Staff has been informed anecdotally that wildfires (which occurred before the COVID-19 pandemic) have driven the population of students enrolled in Malibu area schools below 1501 because families who lost their homes have not yet been able to return. It is not clear if those families returned to Malibu area schools’ enrollment lists during the pandemic, nor is it clear what overall enrollment was in the district while it moved to online classes,” reads the report. 

In addition, the report cites recently-released U.S. Census data indicating a drop in the overall population in the City of Malibu. 

The analysis then goes on to dispute the argument made by supporters of the split that Malibu students are excluded from the community. 

“It is unrealistic to believe that Malibu residents (and thus Malibu students) never leave Malibu (notwithstanding COVID-19 pandemic restrictions), and vice versa, that residents and students of Santa Monicanever partake of recreational, civic, commercial and other offerings in Malibu,” the report states. 

Another factor cited in the report as a reason behind the recommendation to deny the split is the likelihood that a Malibu USD would lack diversity. 

“Malibu USD, if created, will be an entity that is vastly more White than the resulting Santa Monica USD or the current Santa Monica-Malibu USD,” reads the report, which projects that a Malibu USD would be 77.1 percent White and a Santa Monica USD would be 45.4 percent White. Santa Monica-Malibu USD is currently 49.5 percent White. 

Other reasons given behind the recommendation to deny the split were potential increased costs to the state, disruption of education programs, increased school housing costs and impacts to the fiscal management of the resulting two districts. 

The effort to split the school district began officially began in 2015 with a resolution from the City of Malibu to form a separate Malibu USD from territory within the boundaries of the existing Santa Monica-Malibu USD. Santa Monica-Malibu USD, headquartered in Santa Monica, serves 10,625 students with an annual general fund budget of $150 million. 

The City of Malibu has 10,654 residents, and the City of Santa Monica has 93,076 residents, according to the 2020 U.S. Census. The supporters of the split argue that the city centers of Malibu and Santa Monica are separated by several miles, and Santa Monica and Malibu have become distinct communities. 

“Residents of Malibu have expressed concern and frustration that they are not adequately represented by the Santa Monica-Malibu USD governing board due to its at-large system of election, and that their concerns about the policies and practices of Santa Monica-Malibu USD go largely unaddressed. The unification of a Malibu USD from the existing territory of Santa Monica-Malibu USD will benefit all children in Santa Monica, as well as Greater Malibu. Organization of a Malibu USD enables all residents of Greater Malibu to have representation on their local school board through adoption of by-trustee-area elections,” the petitioners argued in their resolution. 

Santa Monica-Malibu USD, has expressed support for the creation of a Malibu USD, but not under the current proposal which it argues would negatively impact the district and students.

The implication that the Santa Monica-Malibu USD is some sort of rogue or illegal composition is false,” Santa Monica-Malibu USD writes. “We are guided by state mandated metrics of sufficiency and performance, not public opinion polls. Santa Monica-MalibuUSD is a high-performing district according to the most recent assessments (which have been suspended during the COVID-19 pandemic), noting that the district has a graduation rate of 94.6%out of all students, compared to a statewide graduation rate of 86.6%, according to the CDE. It is also a district that serves both students of high academic achievement and those of significant need (including English Language Learners (ELL) (8.2%), foster youth (.2%), homeless youth (.5%), students with disabilities (12.5%) and youth from families categorized as low socioeconomic status (SES) (27.5%).”

In addition, Santa Monica-Malibu USD, argues it is not clear what kind of school district the City of Malibu intends to support in the form of a Malibu USD. 

“The City of Malibu, in its proposal, merely lists a series of complaints about the Santa Monica-Malibu USD,” Santa Monica-Malibu USD writes. 

It should be noted the County does not require that petitioners such as the City of Malibu submit an educational plan before submitting a proposal. 

<>Related Posts

Sunshine Beach Volleyball Camps: Register Open for Summer Camps

May 8, 2025

May 8, 2025

Summer is coming. For young volleyball athletes, that means registration for the Sunshine Westside Beach Camp and South Bay Beach...

World-Class Brew: Santa Monica’s Own Takes Home Top Beer Honors

May 8, 2025

May 8, 2025

Basil, Citrus, and Craftsmanship: See Which Local Brewery Just Won Big Santa Monica Brew Works (SMBW) just took home a...

Film Review: Thunderbolts*

May 8, 2025

May 8, 2025

FILM REVIEWTHUNDERBOLTS*Rated PG-13126 MinutesReleased May 2nd The Thunderbolts are a highly unique part of the Marvel Comics universe of superheroes...

Santa Monica Cashier Cited for Selling Alcohol to Minor

May 8, 2025

May 8, 2025

The ABC is conducting compliance checks statewide The Santa Monica Police Department cited a retail clerk at Bristol Farms, located...

Santa Monica Pier to Host Final Locals’ Night of the Season on May 15

May 8, 2025

May 8, 2025

Highlights include a classic car show, free salsa lessons, and performances by punk bands Cycotic Youth and No Reaction The...

(Video) A Fourth Palisades Restaurant Reopens Months After the Wildfires

May 8, 2025

May 8, 2025

The Reopening Coincided with Cinco de Mayo Celebrations The Reopening Coincided with Cinco de Mayo Celebrations. pic.twitter.com/gHgWqVSjY8 — Santa Monica...

Shore Hotel: Your Destination for Local Events, Celebrations

May 8, 2025

May 8, 2025

Cinco de Mayo, Pride Month and More Parties This Summer Shore Hotel, a luxury hotel nestled in the heart of...

(Video) Petitgrain Boulangerie’s Party For Its One Year Anniversary

May 8, 2025

May 8, 2025

We got the gifts with a DJ, free cookies, croissants and affogatos. Congratulations to the co-owners Clémence de Lutz and...

(Video) Socalo’s Cinco de Mayo Celebration

May 8, 2025

May 8, 2025

Co-Owner Susan Feniger Offers Diners Chapulines While Co-Owner Mary Sue Milliken works behind the scenes. Chef Makes Tlayudas on the...

Badmaash to Open Third Location in Venice This Summer

May 8, 2025

May 8, 2025

In a shift toward wellness-conscious dining, the new menu will emphasize brothy soups, raw preparations, and lighter dishes The popular...

Meet the Man Behind the Burritos: Severiano Gonzalez Marks Four Decades at Tito’s Tacos

May 7, 2025

May 7, 2025

One Man’s Dedication, Four Decades of Flavor: Tito’s Senior Cook Speaks By Dolores Quintana Severiano Gonzalez is the senior cook...

Chef Zach Pollack Opens Italian-Californian Restaurant Cosetta in Santa Monica

May 7, 2025

May 7, 2025

The menu includes bar offerings like bluefin tartare with ossobuco aioli and small plates such as burrata agnolotti salad Cosetta,...

Santa Monica Physical Therapist Arrested for Sexual Battery; Police Seek Additional Victims

May 7, 2025

May 7, 2025

The arrest stems from a February 19 report of a suspected sexual battery at Select Physical Therapy A licensed physical...

Tyla Teams Up with Erewhon for Limited-Edition “Bliss” Smoothie Benefiting Girls’ Education

May 7, 2025

May 7, 2025

Tyla’s Smoothie Is Here. Blissfully Bright, Nutrient-Packed, and for a Good Cause Erewhon has teamed up with Grammy-winning musician Tyla...

Camp Integem: Step into the Future

May 7, 2025

May 7, 2025

Explore, Create, and Launch Beyond! This summer, kids are invited to make magic as they journey into the fun-filled, hands-on...