May 22, 2022 Breaking News, Latest News, and Videos

Preliminary Injunction Granted to Halt Demolition Of Parking Structure 3

January 24 hearing set following LA Superior Court Judge ruling

By Dolores Quintana

The Santa Monica Bayside Owners Association’s (SMBOA) petition to temporarily halt the demolition of Public Parking Structure 3 has been granted for now. 

Los Angeles Superior Court Judge Michelle L Beckloff, who previously granted SMBOA’s petition for a temporary restraining order, also issued this preliminary injunction to the group in this case. The injunction does not compel the City to continue to operate Parking Structure 3, on 4th Street between Arizona Avenue and Santa Monica Boulevard. Both the City Council and The California Coastal Commission oppose this petition that seeks to block demolition of the structure to build new and affordable lower-income housing on the property.

Justice Beckloff wrote in the ruling, “Based on a balance of the likelihood of success on the merits of the parties’ competing harms, the court finds Petitioner has demonstrated entitlement to a preliminary injunction during the pendency of the litigation.” as quoted by The Santa Monica Lookout. SMBOA is required by the judge’s rulings in their favor to post a bond of $150,000 to cover the damages that could be awarded to the City if the plaintiffs lose the suit by Jan 24 at 5:00 p.m. or they will forfeit the temporary injunction relief. 

Then on Jan. 28, the court will hold a hearing to make any changes to the bond amount based on the arguments that both sides present on the matter. Judge Beckloff wrote that the hearing will also “set trial on the petition on an expedited basis.”

This ruling came only days after the City Council agreed to engage EAH Inc. in an exclusive agreement to build the sustainable affordable housing on the site of Parking Structure 3 with the units aimed towards housing unhoused residents of Santa Monica. City Officials said that EAH was identified as the developer to head this project based “on the team’s depth of experience in the areas of permanent supportive housing, larger developments, supportive services, and property management.” as quoted by The Santa Monica Outlook.

EAH’s proposal states that they would be responsible for the construction of the new housing and then would be in charge of the management of the property ensuring that “all residents would be supported with services to ensure housing retention and good-neighbor actions,” according to City Officials quoted by the Santa Monica Lookout. City officials further stated that  “The unique needs of the households occupying the supportive housing component of the development would be addressed by intensive case management services. As the development concept is further refined, supportive services will be designed to align with the needs of the residents.”

The City Council also issued the directive to their staff and the developer to continue “to work collaboratively on ways to move the affordable housing forward as quickly as possible.” on the same day that they approved EAH as the developer for the project. 

In fact, Mayor Sue Himmelrich made clear her views on the subject and said, “Our region suffers from a dearth of affordable housing, and we in Santa Monica are committed to improving the crisis and getting people into housing that can be the foundation for stability. We aren’t waiting for private development to lead the way. We are leading by making available a precious resource that makes it possible –- land. This is a project that addresses the biggest needs of the day, including homelessness, affordability, and equity, and reflects our community’s values,” Himmelrich said. 

The centerpiece of SMBOA’s argument is that the City of Santa Monica and its business owners cannot afford to lose the 337 parking spaces in Parking Structure 3. The City’s response is that the rebuilding of Parking Structure Six replaced that potential loss. SMBOA’s lawsuit further alleges that the California Coastal Commission’s ruling to grant permission to the demolition “erred in granting the permit because the legal requirement wasn’t met.” according to the group’s legal counsel.

Judge Beckloff’s ruling countered that assertion by saying that “the dispute before the court as presented by the Petitioner is somewhat confused” because it fails to “specifically address any alleged legal error or abuse of discretion.” Judge Beckloff did agree, however, that the petition “has sufficiently demonstrated [that] the City considered the demolition of PS 3 only in the context of rebuilding without its reconstruction.”

City spokesperson Constance Farrell said, “A final ruling is not likely on the merits until April, depending upon the final briefing schedule, which will be determined by the Court on January 28.”

Related Posts

Los Angeles Metro Sees 15.9 Percent Increase in Median Rent

May 20, 2022

May 20, 2022

Median rent of $2,258, according to recent report By Dolores Quintana The ongoing pandemic has exacerbated the issues of housing...

New Renderings for Frank Gehry Hotel Development in Santa Monica

May 20, 2022

May 20, 2022

Project would include hotel, apartments, retail and a museum By Dolores Quintana Slowly but surely, plans for a  Frank Gehry-designed...

Shared Mobility Plummets in Santa Monica

May 20, 2022

May 20, 2022

Recent report also shows that nearly half of riders make over $100,000 By Sam Catanzaro Shared mobility use in Santa...

Christopher Dishlip Selected as Santa Monica’s New Assistant Director of Public Works

May 20, 2022

May 20, 2022

Public Works Director Rick Valte announced the selection of Christopher Dishlip as Santa Monica’s new Assistant Director of Public Works....

Letter to Editor: Response to Himmelrich’s “We Walk the Talk” Column

May 20, 2022

May 20, 2022

By Beau Marks As a Santa Monica resident, I am dismayed by Sue Himmelrich’s response (“We Walk the Talk,” Santa...

Motional And UberEats Launch Autonomous Deliveries In Santa Monica

May 18, 2022

May 18, 2022

There Are Plans For Expansion Into The Rest Of Los Angeles Motional, a global driverless technology leader, and Uber Technologies...

Winston Pies Opening Third Location In Santa Monica

May 18, 2022

May 18, 2022

The restaurant used to be known as ButterCrust Pies Winston Pies is staying in Santa Monica when opening their third...

Only 10 Vaquita Porpoises Survive, But The Species May Not Be Doomed

May 17, 2022

May 17, 2022

Hope remains for the porpoise species not only survive but thrive with human help. By Stuart Wolpert The vaquita porpoise,...

The American Cinematheque Brings “Bleak Week” To Santa Monica’s Aero Theatre And The Los Feliz Three Theatre

May 17, 2022

May 17, 2022

33 Films From 18 Countries In One Week. By Dolores Quintana Sometimes when things are tough and you’re feeling down,...

Man Who Murdered His Family Members Pleads Guilty To Five Other Killings

May 16, 2022

May 16, 2022

Escobar injured an additional seven other people as well.  By Dolores Quintana A man, Ramon Escobar, has pleaded guilty to...

The price of gasoline in Los Angeles County Has Experienced The Largest Increase Since February

May 16, 2022

May 16, 2022

Gasoline prices in Orange County Have Also Increased By Dolores Quintana Regular self-serve gasoline in the county of Los Angeles...

Santa Monica Travel Summit Of 2022 Returns To Take On Tomorrow

May 16, 2022

May 16, 2022

The Event Was Held At The Jonathan Club On Santa Monica Beach By Staff Writer The 2022 Santa Monica Tourism...

City Council Extends Santa Monica’s Parklet Program: Santa Monica Beat – May 16th, 2022

May 16, 2022

May 16, 2022

Local news and culture in under 5 minutes.* City Council Extends Santa Monica’s Parklet Program * Santa Monica High School Students...

1221 Ocean Avenue Complex Sold For Record Price

May 16, 2022

May 16, 2022

Sold for a record price of $330 million. By Dolores Quintana The Irvine Company has sold 1221 Ocean Avenue to...

Office Construction Is Starting To Rise In Los Angeles

May 15, 2022

May 15, 2022

Property vacancies are still affecting growth.  By Dolores Quintana In March, the Los Angeles Metropolitan area had 3.2 million square...