June 3, 2025 Breaking News, Latest News, and Videos

SMar.t. Column: Has the Promenade Turned a Corner?

In large complex systems with dynamically balanced forces, it’s paradoxically often hard to tell when something has actually happened, For example, when did the British Empire start to crumble? What was the first sign of that change? Or for an example closer to home, are we now in a recession? Or has climate change already become irreversible? Analysts, scientists and historians will debate and disagree about these transformations, even later, long after the event has clearly happened. So SMa.r.t. (Santa Monica Architects for a Responsible Tomorrow), who have never shied away from controversy and always invites a debate, will make a prediction: the recovery of our beleaguered Promenade began on June 28, 2022.

On that day, the City Council appointed three new board members to DTSM (Downtown Santa Monica), the nonprofit that manages our 3rd Street Promenade (also called the mall) and its environs. The new board members are Leonid Pustilnikov, Luke M. Cain, and Lucian Tudor. These new appointees have “skin in the game” as business owners and younger Promenade stakeholders. So their points of view, which will not necessarily always be in lockstep, will significantly impact the 12-member board that runs your Promenade. Hopefully, they will have an energizing effect on the existing board that has struggled through the nuclear winter of Covid and crumbled under the combined impact of homelessness, crime, and the death spiral of retail and tourism. These problems existed long before Covid, as John Alle, who has been throwing up distress flares and photos about them for years, has amply documented. 

Covid actively accelerated that decay and brought it to a breaking point. So the question becomes how bad is the decay these new board members face? One metric is tourism which is down about 70% compared to pre-Covid. As the impression spread that our Promenade and its parking structures are unsafe and overrun with the anti-social homeless and opportunistic criminals, tourists which had already become a rare commodity, stopped coming. But not just the tourists but also city residents and the convention trade didn’t want to face the smell of urine and the hostile encounters that have become the common experience at our mall. The ambassadors, cleaning and parking staff and SMPD simply were not up to the task of creating a safe and clean urban experience at our Promenade. In reality, homelessness is a regional problem not solvable by one City alone and tourism likewise depends ultimately on the fiscal health of national and international travelers, exchange rates and other externalities outside DTSM’s control, but the impacts of homelessness and crime directly effect tourism and local visitors, so it has to be fixed in at least this critical nominal 9 block area that is DTSM’s domain and responsibility. 

With Amazon, like a Pac-man eating the retail world alive (which was already happening before Covid) and now anyone who could, started working at home during Covid, the retail and office vacancy rate has ballooned to somewhere between 26% and about 60% depending on reporting methodology. Some commercial landlords including hotels, have substantially cut their rates but no number of pop-up stores and other gimmicks will make up the difference of this real financial erosion that will certainly get worse if the incoming recession is deep and or prolonged and as commercial tenants increasingly don’t renew their leases. With the Westside Pavilion closed, our downtown, with its unique mix of semi-indoor and outdoor venues (i.e. SM Place and the Promenade) now directly competes with Caruso’s project in the Palisades, Century City which had a recent billion dollar+ makeover, the Beverly Center, Marina del Rey and Culver City. None of those destinations have our amazing beach and hotel access. But neither do they have the homeless siege and public safety challenges (including the May 31, 2020 debacle) we have in reality and, equally importantly, in the public perception. In other words, why would you go to the Promenade when all you hear, particularly from returning visitors, is how bad it has become? Why would you shop in a store without baskets and shopping carts, which were removed because criminals kept loading them up and just rolling them out the front door? Why would you visit a place where soon a security guard will need to be stationed in front of every establishment? And of course why would you open a business where your employees are afraid of the gauntlet they face just coming to work?

Spearheading the turnaround of this adverse public perception and reality is job one for these new DTSM board members. More important than adding new housing, more important than bringing back tourism, and more important than lowering the vacancy rate, DTSM must, with the City’s support, make our Promenade safe and clean.

So why should a resident care about the collapse of their Promenade? If we use simple self-interest (a necessary but not sufficient motivator) the benefits of healing the mall will recover millions of dollars of lost potential City income. If we use the 2015 taxable transactions (the last time this data was published by DTSM) collected from our Promenade and adjust for the current vacancy rate and probable inflation increases, we are losing somewhere between $25M and $40M of annual potential City income. In other words, had our Promenade and downtown been healed, there would not have been the City budget discussion last month of unfunded libraries, unavailable parks, or deferred park maintenance. Those resident priorities would have been more fully funded including the need for more homeless support services and law enforcement. Moreover, the annual order of magnitude of the money we could get by healing our mall and downtown is the same as might be received from the current parcel tax proposals being prepared for the next election. 

 So all Santa Monicans have a vested interest in healing their Promenade.

The decline of our Promenade is directly related to multiple policy failures. The key failure has been the City’s erratic neglectful homeless strategy that has not delivered real positive outcomes to any stakeholder, resident, merchant or the transient homeless demographic. That neglected community of over 1000, is overwhelmed by mental illness, poverty, PTSD, and substance abuse issues all driving increasingly serious crime and anti-social behavior. Compounding these city policy failures, the prior DTSM Board did not seize the opportunity to create a real, serious, and comprehensive business plan that would be ready to execute upon exit from the pandemic lockdowns. Unfortunately, homelessness and its attendant anti-social behavior, is now the major determinant of the public perception of our Promenade. In other words, people will, for a while, forgive boarded-up stores. They understand the economic brutality of Covid’s effects over the last 2 1/2 years. But people do not understand why it can’t be made safe and clean during the recovery period? This simple request is the new DTSM board’s marching orders.

It’s not easy to achieve this kind of turnaround, after this long-entrenched decline. It’s a lot of pressure to put on three new board members and their nine colleagues. But the longest journey begins with a single step. The City Council took that step a week ago by giving the DTSM board new leadership. S.M.a.r.t. wishes them the best of luck in this new endeavor and thanks them for their willingness to serve in this challenging position. 

 By Mario Fonda-Bonardi AIA

S.M.a.r.t Santa Monica Architects for a Responsible Tomorrow
Thane Roberts, Architect, Robert H. Taylor AIA, Ron Goldman FAIA, Architect, Dan Jansenson, Architect & Building and Fire-Life Safety Commission, Samuel Tolkin Architect & Planning Commissioner, Mario Fonda-Bonardi AIA & Planning Commissioner, Marc Verville M.B.A, CPA (Inactive), Michael Jolly, AIR-CRE.
For previous articles see www.santamonicaarch.wordpress.com/writing

<>Related Posts

Historic Venice Building Envisioned by Abbot Kinney Hits Market for $2.29M

June 2, 2025

June 2, 2025

Kinney envisioned the building as part of an institutional foundation to rival Renaissance Italy, focusing on education and culture A...

Malibu Moves to Ease Business Burden After Wildfire and Pacific Coast Highway Closure

June 2, 2025

June 2, 2025

City Pauses Minimum Wage Hike, to Review Event Rules to Aid Local Businesses To alleviate economic strain on local businesses...

Palisades Village to Reopen in 2026 with Revamped Retail, Dining, and Community Spaces

May 29, 2025

May 29, 2025

Elysewalker Set to Return With Park Reconstruction, Holiday Events, and Streetscape Upgrades Palisades Village, the open-air shopping and lifestyle destination...

SM.a.r.t Column: Oops!! What Happened? And What Are You Going to Do About It?

May 29, 2025

May 29, 2025

Our Santa Monica Architects for a Responsible Tomorrow (SMa.r.t) articles have, over the past 12 years, collectively presented a critical...

County Assessor Stresses Need For Fire-Affected Households to Update Addresses to Receive Relief Checks

May 28, 2025

May 28, 2025

Assessor’s Office Offers Automatic Tax Relief for Fire-Affected Homeowners Following the destruction caused by wildfires earlier this year, the Los...

SM.a.r.t Column: Why Santa Monica Might Need a Desalination Plant, and Maybe Even Nuclear Power

May 22, 2025

May 22, 2025

Santa Monica is known for its ocean views, sunny skies, and strong environmental values. But there’s a challenge on the...

Film Review: Final Destination: Bloodlines

May 22, 2025

May 22, 2025

FILM REVIEWFINAL DESTINATION: BLOODLINESRated R110 MinutesReleased May 16th  This is the sixth entry in the Final Destination movie franchise that...

State Farm Seeks New Insurance Rate Hikes for California Homeowners and Renters

May 20, 2025

May 20, 2025

Insurer Aims to Raise Premiums by up to 52% for Some Policyholders by 2026 Just one week after receiving approval...

Historic ‘Parry Residence’ in Pacific Palisades Lists for $25M

May 19, 2025

May 19, 2025

It is one of the earliest homes constructed in the Huntington Palisades and was prominently featured in a 1930 issue...

10-Unit Venice Townhouse with Ocean Views Listed for $6M

May 19, 2025

May 19, 2025

Built in 1975, the 14,025-square-foot structure sits on a 7,971-square-foot corner lot  A 10-unit townhouse complex just steps from the...

Elon Musk’s Tesla Renews Santa Monica Lease for 82,000-Square-Foot Service Center

May 18, 2025

May 18, 2025

Tesla Keeps California Roots with Santa Monica Service Center Renewal Despite relocating its corporate headquarters to Texas, Tesla has reaffirmed...

SM.a.r.t Column: SMO (So Many Options) Part 3: “Pie in the Sky”

May 17, 2025

May 17, 2025

SMO: Fantasy, Fact, and the Fog of Wishful ThinkingBy someone who read the fine print Every few months, a headline...

City to Issue Solicitations for Affordable Housing Development at Bergamot Station Arts Center

May 12, 2025

May 12, 2025

Proposals for the Bergamot Station Arts Center must prioritize maximizing affordable housing units while also considering potential artist housing and...

Historic Lloyd Wright-Designed Palisades Home Hits Market at $12.9M

May 12, 2025

May 12, 2025

Wright, the son of Frank Lloyd Wright, designed the estate for an Academy-winning composer A historic estate designed by architect...

Top Malibu Sale of 2025: Oceanfront Malibu Colony Home Sells for $26.8M

May 11, 2025

May 11, 2025

Old Hollywood-Era Home Sells After Over a Year on the Market Topping Malibu’s residential sales charts for the year, a...