June 2, 2023 Breaking News, Latest News, and Videos

Legal Battle in the Future for Santa Monica Following ‘Builder’s Remedy’ Debacle?

City Council members Phil Brock, Christine Parra and Oscar de la Torre have put forward an agenda item to address “‘residents’ concerns’

By Dolores Quintana

The issue of the 16 ‘Builder’s Remedy’ applications that were filed during the time period when Santa Monica’s Housing Element was rejected by the State of California may turn into a legal battle as reported by The Real Deal.com

Doug Sloan, the Santa Monica city attorney, said, as quoted by The Real Deal.com “We did engage outside counsel. It’s important to realize that, when looking at this builder’s remedy issue and the Housing Element law, the rules were not always very clear, and it was somewhat of a moving target from the state.” during a Santa Monica City Council meeting. 

Sloan explained, as quoted by The Real Deal.com “I don’t think over the last 18 months the council or staff could have done anything differently to avoid being where we are.” in response to a new motion regarding the Builder’s Remedy applications. 

City Council members Phil Brock, Christine Parra and Oscar de la Torre have put forward an agenda item to address “‘residents’ concerns’ about the permits and urged the council to “hire appropriate outside legal counsel”

Neither Sloan nor Brock responded to requests for comment on the matter, but during the City Council meeting Brock stated that one Builder’s Remedy application that was automatically approved for a 15 story building was, “beyond the pale” and “an unacceptable bar for the rest of the city.”

Sloan has apparently dropped hints about what the City Council may adopt as a legal strategy in the attempt to squash the Builder’s Remedy applications. The 16 approved applications were submitted between February and October 14 of 2022 while Santa Monica’s Housing Element was not in compliance with state mandates. Sloan plans to argue that the date of compliance should be earlier, starting in early September of 2022 when the City Council sent a letter to the state agency informing them that the new version of Santa Monica’s Housing Element was “substantially in compliance” and if the City Council approved it. 

The new version of the Housing Element was accepted by the Santa Monica City Council on October 11 and the approved plan was certified by the state agency days later. 

Sloan said, as quoted by The Real Deal.com, “We will be making a good argument that… that was really the cutoff. And so, some of these builder’s remedy applications we received after that we may not have to treat that way.”

While it is not known if this legal strategy will actually work, the legality of applications that are approved by the Builder’s Remedy process has not been settled in the courts. According to state law, certification happens when the final version of the Housing Element is submitted and Santa Monica’s Housing Element was still in draft form in early September and was revised in the time period between the letter and final adoption of the Element by the Santa Monica City Council. 

WSC Communities lawyer Dave Rand said, during an interview, “My hope is that the city is going to be selective — like they’re going to find certain projects unappealing and certain projects ok,” Rand said. “But you have council members who are about slow growth. And they’re putting a lot of pressure on their staff to push back on these projects, and so this is not going to be a cakewalk at all. It’s going to be a fight.” WSC Communities is the company that submitted the most Builder’s Remedy applications in Santa Monica during the non-compliance time period. 

This potential legal fight makes the issue of Builder’s Remedy applications much more high profile than it ever has been and could potentially lead to developers taking advantage of the loophole in other cities that have not had their Housing Elements approved by the state agency. Over 100 cities in Southern California have Housing Elements that have been rejected including the cities of Beverly Hills and West Hollywood.

Not everyone in Santa Monica is against these Builder’s Remedy projects, as quoted by The Real Deal.com, a resident who was in favor of these projects wrote as a comment to the agenda item, “I write to urge you to embrace Builder’s Remedy projects. Santa Monica needs more homes and affordable homes, not wasteful litigation!”

Related Posts

Free Meals for WGA Members During Strike at Bob’s Big Boy and Swingers Diner

June 1, 2023

June 1, 2023

Comedian and Host Drew Carey Is Paying For Meals For Striking WGA Members By Dolores Quintana As the Writers Guild...

(Video) Recap of The 8th Annual “Mainopoly” Tour of Main Street Restaurants

June 1, 2023

June 1, 2023

Come along the most recent Mainopoly tour of Main Street to check out its restaurants and shops. @smmirrornews Come tour...

Mystery Surrounds Closure of Michelin Recommended Restaurant Savida in Santa Monica

June 1, 2023

June 1, 2023

Santa Monica’s Beloved Crudo and Seafood Restaurant Abruptly Shuts Down on April 27 By Dolores Quintana After receiving a coveted...

Salvation Army to Distribute 2,000 Donuts at Santa Monica Promenade

May 31, 2023

May 31, 2023

Donuts Will Be Distributed at Various Locations Throughout the City. The Salvation Army Santa Monica will commemorate its 130-year anniversary...

Santa Monica Requests $6M To Expand Memorial Park

May 30, 2023

May 30, 2023

An Expansion Project Would Combine the 10.3-acre Park With an Adjacent 2.9 Acre Property. By Zach Armstrong The city of...

Get Ready For Cinematic Despair: American Cinematheque Presents Bleak Week

May 30, 2023

May 30, 2023

Explore the Darkest Depths of Humanity in a Gripping Showcase of Bleak Cinema Get ready for a captivating week of...

Sexual Assault Suspect in Custody After Stabbing Victim’s Friend

May 30, 2023

May 30, 2023

The Suspect Is Responsible for Another Recent Assault. On Saturday, May 27, 2023, at approximately 7:30 p.m., officers from the...

Mail and Package Thieves Detained by Santa Monica Police

May 30, 2023

May 30, 2023

The Suspect Possessed Counterfeit U.S. Postal Service Arrow Keys. Shortly before midnight on May 20, officers from the Santa Monica...

Pandemic-Induced Rent Debt Crisis Threatens Housing Stability

May 28, 2023

May 28, 2023

Low-Wage Workers and Communities of Color Disproportionately Affected By Dolores Quintana  Rental debt is an out-of-control problem that has worsened...

Spanish Revival Home On Market For Nearly $20M

May 26, 2023

May 26, 2023

The Property is Nestled Behind Gates and Features Eight Bedrooms By Zach Armstrong Over top of the Riviera Country Club,...

Santa Monica Ranked One of the Least Affordable U.S. Cities

May 26, 2023

May 26, 2023

Several Metrics Graded on a 100-point Scale to Make the Ranking. By Zach Armstrong The City of Santa Monica was...

(Video) Homelessness Exacerbated by Santa Monica Rail and Bus System

May 26, 2023

May 26, 2023

The METRO and public bus system has reportedly been a large factor in Santa Monica’s homeless population. @smmirrornews Homelessness in...

Health Advisory: Los Angeles County Health Warns Against Swimming This Weekend

May 26, 2023

May 26, 2023

Public Health Issues Caution as Bacterial Levels Exceed Health Standards  The Los Angeles County Department of Public Health cautions residents...

Women’s Boutique Closing After More Than 60 Years

May 25, 2023

May 25, 2023

Sumiko Started on Main Street in Santa Monica in 1962. By Zach Armstrong Women’s clothing boutique Sumiko is closing after...

With New Metro System, Santa Monicans Can Reach East L.A. Without Transfers

May 25, 2023

May 25, 2023

Riders Could Save as Much as 20 Minutes Going Downtown. By Zach Armstrong The Regional Connector transit project, a 1.9...