December 2, 2024 Breaking News, Latest News, and Videos

Open Letter On the California Voting Rights Case Against the City of Santa Monica

By Oscar de la Torre

Like many Santa Monicans and Californians who care about fair elections, I watched the California Supreme Court’s June 27 arguments in Pico Neighborhood Association & Maria Loya v. City of Santa Monica – a case filed more than 7 years ago to vindicate the voting rights of people of color in Santa Monica.  Within the first few minutes of his presentation, the City’s high-priced attorney, Theodore Boutrous, argued that the Santa Monica City Council now has two Latino/a members from the Pico Neighborhood, only one of whom could serve on a council chosen through district-based elections.  According to Mr. Boutrous, this was a reason to leave the at-large election system in place.

What Mr. Boutrous failed to mention is that from 1946 through 2019, Santa Monica’s at-large election system had resulted in the election of only one Latino councilmember – one out of 72 elected councilmembers in that span – and the Pico Neighborhood never had a person of color elected to represent our voice on the City Council. That is why I support a switch to more inclusive district-based elections, just as the Los Angeles Superior Court ordered in 2019. The fact is that the at-large election system in Santa Monica was deliberately implemented to keep people of color from the Pico Neighborhood off the City Council. This is a clear example of systemic racism. District-based elections strengthen our democracy by reducing the cost of running for a seat on the City Council. Elections by district ensure that every neighborhood in Santa Monica gets represented. 

I am unconcerned about my own political future; it is the future of the Pico Neighborhood, where I was raised by two immigrant parents with my 7 siblings, that I care deeply about.  I want the Pico Neighborhood to be guaranteed representation for the future, long after I am gone, so that my children who are being raised in the Pico Neighborhood can say one day that Santa Monica is fair to all of its residents. I also want minority communities throughout California to never go unrepresented and ignored, as the Pico Neighborhood has for many decades.  As a Democrat, I agree with what US Senator Alex Padilla wrote the day of the Supreme Court argument: “If the city of Santa Monica prevails, the CVRA’s protections against discriminatory at-large elections would be drastically weakened.  In other words, if the city has its way, California would be set back 20 years.” (https://tinyurl.com/yd49h22b)

The Pico Neighborhood has endured the neglect of an apathetic city government for over 75 years due to its lack of representation. Any personal political sacrifice I may have to endure to prevent another 75 years of suffocating ambivalence to the Pico Neighborhood pales in comparison.

My city council colleagues tell us that the City – among the richest in the world – cannot afford to keep our libraries open, offer after-school programs at our public schools, and keep our parks clean and safe.  Yet, they have no hesitation in spending many millions of dollars on attorneys to fight against the voting rights of Santa Monica’s residents of color in order to maintain their own political power.  Had the City simply adopted district elections in 2016, it could have avoided all the legal fees associated with the Pico Neighborhood Association’s case.  That’s the sensible action that dozens of other California cities have taken when faced with California Voting Rights Act (CVRA) claims.

This issue is not just about Santa Monica.  Racial and ethnic minorities throughout California are denied the representation they deserve by at-large election systems.  The CVRA has been instrumental in combating that inequity, yet some of my otherwise progressive colleagues would seek to cripple the CVRA in court so they might maintain their own political power and privilege.   My colleagues on the Santa Monica City Council cannot fight against voting rights and simultaneously call themselves “progressive.”  

We will all be remembered for where we stood on the voting rights of minorities – probably more than any other issue we address as city council members. Santa Monica’s “liberal” facade will be exposed once the California Supreme Court renders its decision. Some of my colleagues will, unfortunately, be remembered for standing in the schoolhouse door, obstructing the rights of minorities like so many of history’s “conservative” villains.  I choose instead to stand on the right side of history. 

-Oscar de la Torre, Santa Monica City Councilmember

in Opinion
<>Related Posts

SM.a.r.t Column: It’s Time To Inspect Balconies

November 24, 2024

November 24, 2024

About nine years ago, a fifth-floor balcony in a Berkeley apartment building collapsed, tragically killing several students gathered on it...

S.M.a.r.t Column: Your City is Broke

November 18, 2024

November 18, 2024

On December 10, the new City council will be seated fresh from their dominant win in the recent elections. There...

SM.a.r.t Column: Moving Ahead to the Future

November 10, 2024

November 10, 2024

As we write this, the election results are still trickling in. We’ll leave the deep analysis to others, but the...

Opinion: Fact Check: Why Vote Yes on Measure QS

November 1, 2024

November 1, 2024

Despite living in a famously progressive region, Santa Monicans are not immune from the same political misinformation and disinformation that...

SM.a.r.t Column: Lack of Oversight and No Accountability

October 31, 2024

October 31, 2024

S.M.a.r.t. periodically invites guest columnists to write opinion articles on topics of particular interests to our readers. Below is an...

SM.a.r.t Column: “Help! I’ve Fallen, and I …!!”, Cries Santa Monica!

October 25, 2024

October 25, 2024

Maybe fallen, but slipping for sure from being a desirable beachfront community that served all equally, the local residents who...

SM.a.r.t. Column: Vote

October 13, 2024

October 13, 2024

In a polarized country or City every vote counts. Regardless of which side of any issue or candidate you support,...

SM.a.r.t Column: Fact-Checking Election-Season Windbaggery

October 6, 2024

October 6, 2024

Claim: The state is requiring Santa Monica to build 9,000 apartments.Answer: Partially true, partially false. Santa Monica has a pretty...

SM.a.r.t. Column: Public Safety and Traffic Enforcement Can Help Save Lives and Revitalize Santa Monica’s Economy

September 29, 2024

September 29, 2024

We wholeheartedly endorse the candidates below for Santa Monica City Council. Their leading campaign platform is for increased safety in...

SM.a.r.t Column: Crime in Santa Monica: A Growing Concern and the Need for Prioritizing Public Safety

September 22, 2024

September 22, 2024

By Michael Jolly Over the past six months, Santa Monica has experienced a concerning rise in crime, sparking heated discussions...

SM.a.r.t Column: Ten New Commandments

September 15, 2024

September 15, 2024

Starting last week,  the elementary school students of Louisiana will all face mandatory postings of the biblical Ten Commandments in...

SM.a.r.t Column: Santa Monica’s Next City Council

September 8, 2024

September 8, 2024

In the next general election, this November 5th, Santa Monica residents will be asked to vote their choices among an...

SM.a.r.t Column: Part II: The Affordability Crisis: Unmasking California’s RHNA Process and Its Role in Gentrification

September 2, 2024

September 2, 2024

Affordability: An Income and Available Asset Gap Issue, Not a Supply Issue (Last week’s article revealed how state mandates became...

SM.a.r.t Column: Part 1: The Affordability Crisis: Unmasking California’s RHNA Process and Its Role in Gentrification

August 26, 2024

August 26, 2024

In the world of economic policy, good intentions often pave the way to unintended consequences. Nowhere is this more evident...

SM.a.r.t Column: They Want to Build a Wall

August 18, 2024

August 18, 2024

Every once in a while, a topic arises that we had previously written about but doesn’t seem to go away....