October 23, 2021 Breaking News, Latest News, and Videos

Council Votes Unanimously to Appeal District-Election Ruling

City of Santa Monica to appeal ruling that elections are in violation of CRVA. 

By Sam Catanzaro

On February 21, the Santa Monica City Council voted unanimously to appeal a judge’s final ruling ordering district elections in the city, in the case Pico Neighborhood Association, et al. v. City of Santa Monica, a voting rights case that contends that the at-large elections in the city dilute the Latino vote and are in violation of the California Voting Rights Act (CRVA).

“What we are trying to do with this appeal is preserve the electoral power for the voters in Santa Monica to choose the seven people they would like to represent them throughout the city,” said Santa Monica Mayor Gleam Davis in a media briefing following the vote. “In a district-based system, each council member would only be beholden to approximately one-seventh of the city. In our current system, I as mayor, and every council member is accountable to virtually every voter, resident, and constituent in the city.”

The case, filed by plaintiffs Pico Neighborhood Association, Maria Loya and Advocates for Malibu Public Schools alleges that Santa Monica’s at-large election system dilutes Latino voting power in violation of the CVRA and discriminates against Latino voters in violation of the Equal Protection Clause of the California Constitution.

In a final ruling released February 15, Los Angeles Superior Court Judge Yvette M. Palazuelos adopted the plaintiff’s judgment, ordering that all future elections for seats on the Santa Monica City Council be based on a seven-district map drawn by an expert for the plaintiffs and that the City hold a special election on July 2, 2019, for all seven seats on the Santa Monica City Council using this new district map.

The seven-district map drawn by the plaintiffs.

Theodore J. Boutrous, Jr. from Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP, one of the lawyers representing the City, told the media following the council vote, that in the appeal, the defense will argue that Judge Palazuelos’ imposition of districts will hinder the voting power of Latinos and minorities in Santa Monica elections.

“What this case is all about from the City’s perspective is defending the democratic process,” Boutrous said. “We believe the order is wrong in multiple respects, that it will hurt minorities in terms of their voting rights, that it violates the United States Constitution because it is not going to achieve the objective of empowering Latino voters or other minority groups, it is going to dilute their voting power, it is going to hurt them and it is bad for our democracy.”

According to Santa Monica City Attorney Lane Dilg, under the current at-large system, Latinos, who make up 13.6 percent of Santa Monica voters, have made up 14 percent of City Council seats since 2012. Dilg in urging the City to appeal stated that it is impossible to draw a district in Santa Monica with a voting population that is more than 30 percent Latino.

“No court-adjudicating a vote dilution claim has ever ordered the creation of districts where the citizen age population of the relevant minority group in the purported remedial district would be this low,” Dilg said. “In Santa Monica, approximately two-thirds of Latino voters live outside the proposed Pico District. In a seven-district system, most of these Latino voters would reside in districts with overwhelmingly white majorities and be prevented from organizing together across neighborhoods as they can in the current at-large system.”

Since Judge Palazuelos has ordered a special election for July 2, 2019, to choose a district-elected council, the City is requesting the appellate court to grant an automatic stay on the order, putting the special election and imposition of districts on hold. In an interview with the Santa Monica Mirror last week, Rex Parris, an attorney representing the plaintiffs was unsure if the appellate court will grant an automatic stay. Boutrous, however, seemed confident the automatic stay would be mandated.

“We believe the law absolutely mandates a stay here because the court has ordered, it mandated, that is the language that triggers an automatic stay, that an election be held,” Boutrous said. “That is the classic kind of injunction and mandate from a court that is automatically stayed.”

During the public comment period before the council’s vote, there was much discussion regarding what an appeal will cost the city.

“The grounds on appeal are narrow, prevailing on appeal I believe would be harder than it was to prevail in the lawsuit,” said Santa Monica resident and attorney Maryanne LaGuardia. “I think it is your duty to really consider your chances on appeal versus your fiduciary duty to retain and use wisely the assets of the City.”

In a December interview with the Santa Monica Mirror, Parris estimated that the City would spend at least $10,000,000 in legal fees if they decide to appeal the judge’s final decision. While the City would not speak to specific dollar amounts, citing attorney-client privilege, Boutrous said that an appeal would likely cost less than the trial because there would be less work required. According to City Attorney Dilg, an appeal would involve drafting legal briefs and a thirty-minute legal argument. Mayor Davis attributes concerns about the cost of an appeal to “misinformation.”

“There was a lot of misinformation about what the cost of an appeal would be,” Davis said. “The hard work is done in trying the case, that is where the money is spent. Now we are moving on to the appeal.”

According to Boutrous, the City will be able to draft an appeal brief within four to six months and that the judge will issue a response a few months after the appeal is submitted. It will be at least one year before attorneys can make oral arguments, Boutrous said.

Related Posts

GoodRx Completes New Santa Monica Pen Factory Headquarters

October 23, 2021

October 23, 2021

Westside Real Estate Scene October 25, 2021 By Dolores Quintana Good RX, an app based healthcare company, will be moving...

Celebrate Santa Monica’s Community Heroes

October 22, 2021

October 22, 2021

The 27th Annual New Heroes Celebration, sponsored by the Santa Monica Chamber of Commerce, is scheduled for Wednesday, October 27,...

Metro Considering Joint Development of Transit Land To Build Affordable Housing

October 22, 2021

October 22, 2021

Agency looking into goal of building 10,000 units of affordable housing By Dolores Quintana LA Metro has received a report...

Three Charged in Alleged Scheme to Steal Hundreds of Thousands of Dollars Meant for Homeless Assistance

October 22, 2021

October 22, 2021

Attorney General Bonta files charges in connection with alleged theft from Los Angeles-based homelessness assistance program By Sam Catamzaro California...

VA Secretary Announces Plans House Over 500 Homeless Veterans in Los Angeles by End of Year

October 21, 2021

October 21, 2021

Updated October 22, 2021 with added statement from the Los Angeles Homeless Service Authority. Announcement comes after Secretary Denis McDonough’s...

Homeless Man Sleeping in Santa Monica Park Set on Fire

October 21, 2021

October 21, 2021

Suspect at large in October 16 incident By Sam Catanzaro Santa Monica police are searching for a suspect wanted for...

Ocean Park’s Uplifters Kitchen Closes

October 20, 2021

October 20, 2021

Westside Dining Scene October 21, 2021 By Dolores Quintana Sadly, Uplifter’s Kitchen, a health conscious vegetarian and vegan friendly cafe...

Charges Filed Against Woman for Attacking Former “Survivor” Contestant in Santa Monica

October 20, 2021

October 20, 2021

Michelle Yi, two other unnamed victims attacked in area of 2nd and Arizona By Dolores Quintana and Sam Catanzaro Michelle...

Community Volunteer Patrol Program Brings Civilians New Insight Into Law Enforcement

October 19, 2021

October 19, 2021

The West LA Police Department has a community patrol program bridging the gap between civilians and law enforcement. Video brought...

E-Bike Company Wheels Settles Consumer Protection Lawsuit With Santa Monica

October 19, 2021

October 19, 2021

Company agrees to pay $300k for operating without a license in 2019 By Sam Catanzaro E-bike company Wheels recently settled...

Santa Monica Fire Department Put Out Two Freeway Blazes Over Weekend

October 19, 2021

October 19, 2021

No injuries reported in Sunday morning incident By Sam Catanzaro The Santa Monica Fire Department (SMFD) made quick work putting...

Vice President Kamala Harris Visits Santa Monica For The Weekend: Santa Monica Beat – October 18, 2021

October 18, 2021

October 18, 2021

Local news and culture in under 5 minutes. * Vice President Kamala Harris Visits Santa Monica For The Weekend *...

Santa Monica’s 100 Homes Initiative Moves Forward

October 16, 2021

October 16, 2021

City seeks public participation in new HUD-funded program By Dolores Quintana The City of Santa Monica is moving forward with...

Former Mesa PD Chief to Lead Santa Monica Police Department

October 15, 2021

October 15, 2021

Ramon Batista selected as Santa Monica’s first Latino police chief By Sam Catanzaro Ramon Batista, Jr., the former police chief...