May 17, 2021 Breaking News, Latest News, and Videos

Slew of Landlords Sue Santa Monica Over Short Term Rental Ban

Lawsuit claims ordinance violates U.S. Constitution and California Coastal Act

By Sam Catanzaro

Landlords are suing the City of Santa Monica, claiming a recently-adopted ban on short-term rentals violates the U.S. Constitution and the California Coastal Act, among other offenses. 

In September, Santa Monica City Council adopted a law that requires residential leases to last at least one year while also prohibiting furnished apartments. In addition, the ordinance states apartments can only be rented only to tenants intending the unit to be their primary residence. According to the City, “these new regulations are intended to preserve Santa Monica’s rental housing stock for permanent residents in response to concern regarding loss of rental housing stock to corporations and persons who do not wish to make Santa Monica their primary residence.” 

On Monda, December 14, 32 limited liability companies–including NMS and WS Communities–filed a lawsuit with Los Angeles County Superior Court alleging the decision to adopt the ordinance was “arbitrary, capricious, and lacking in evidentiary support.” These plaintiffs argue that their landlords’ properties are dependent on a business model that facilitates flexible-term leasing and furnished units. 

“Their tenants are people who want or need to live in Santa Monica, and for whom flexibility in the lease term is critical,” the lawsuit states. 

The case takes aim at Santa Monica City Council shifting course at an August 25 meeting. Going into the meeting–informed by over a dozen public hearings over the past few years–City Staff recommended that landlords be required to offer leases under a year and furnished units while also allowing tenants to decline such options. At the meeting, however, the case alleges lawmakers bowed to pressure from hotel lobbyists and political activists. 

“For purely political reasons and without the benefit of any study, the City Council elected during the middle of a meeting to change course after hotel lobbyists and other political activists protested the staff’s recommendation and demanded that anyone needing a home in Santa Monica for less than a year go to an ‘extended stay hotel,” the case reads. “Politicians simply decided on the fly that they know better than their staffers: one size would have to fit all, no matter the circumstances.” 

“Politicians simply decided on the fly that they know better than their staffers: one size would have to fit all, no matter the circumstances.” 

The case argues that the resulting law violates the California Coastal Act, which sets restrictions on local control on land within 1,000 yards of the ocean. In addition, the case alleges the law violates the U.S. Constitution’s Equal Protection Clause because it disproportionately harms renters hurt by COVID-19–such as frontline workers or families of patients–who may be looking for a temporary living space near hospitals. 

The suit also states that the short term rental ban harms landlords who are collecting less rent during the pandemic. According to a November report from Apartment List, Santa Monica rents have declined “decreased sharply” by 12.8 percent in comparison to the same time last year. Currently, median rents in Santa Monica stand at $1,870 for a one-bedroom apartment and $2,352 for a two-bedroom, the report. This decline is the steepest decline of any city in Southern California included in the report.

When reached for comment regarding the lawsuit, the City of Santa Monica provided the following statement: 

“The City of Santa Monica has a successful record adopting balanced housing policies that protect limited housing for long-term residents. In keeping with this, the City Council passed new residential leasing regulations earlier this year. The City believes these regulations are legally valid, but is reviewing the challenges raised in the complaint that was recently filed.” 

Related Posts

Vice Media Co-Founder Sells Santa Monica Canyon Estate for Record Price

May 14, 2021

May 14, 2021

Shane Smith sells Channel Road estate for nearly $50 million  By Chad Winthrop The co-founder of Vice Media has sold...

Construction Underway for Mixed-use Lincoln Boulevard Development

May 14, 2021

May 14, 2021

47 units with retail under construction  By Sam Catanzaro Construction is underway for a four-story mixed-use development spanning a whole...

Santa Monica Fire Chief Bill Walker to Leave Department for Texas

May 13, 2021

May 13, 2021

Chief moving to Texas to head up new position, be closer to family  By Sam Catanzaro Santa Monica’s fire chief...

Suspect Sought in Attack on Elderly Asian Man on Third Street Promenade

May 13, 2021

May 13, 2021

Santa Monica police looking for suspect in May 1 Third Street Promenade battery  By Sam Catanzaro Santa Monica police are...

Ben & Jerry’s Closes Santa Monica Shop

May 13, 2021

May 13, 2021

First West Coast Ben & Jerry’s closes up shop on Main Street  By Kerry Slater Ben & Jerry’s has closed...

Toby Maguire Sells Empty Brentwood Lot for $10.7M

May 13, 2021

May 13, 2021

The second most expensive land transaction this year was the sale of an undeveloped plot of land in Brentwood Park,...

SMMUSD’s Music Education Program Receives National Recognition

May 11, 2021

May 11, 2021

Santa Monica-Malibu Unified School District honored with the “Best Communities for Music Education” designation For the 19th straight year, the...

Edify TV: A Look Into the Cold War-Era as Wende Museum Reopens

May 11, 2021

May 11, 2021

With relics of the Cold War-era on display, the Wende Museum in Culver City has reopened for in-person visits. Learn...

Convicted Arsonist Making Fire Pits in Palisades Bluffs

May 10, 2021

May 10, 2021

Homeless man named Hilton making fire pits in fire-prone hillside area By Sam Catanzaro   A convicted arsonist continues to make...

Rapper Saweetie Gives Surprise Performance On The Pier: Santa Monica Beat – May, 10, 2021

May 10, 2021

May 10, 2021

Local news and culture in under 5 minutes. * Rapper Saweetie Gives Surprise Performance On The Pier * Santa Monica...

Head-on Crash on PCH in Santa Monica Results in Serious Injuries

May 10, 2021

May 10, 2021

Traffic collision occurs on Pacific Coast Highway near California Incline Monday afternoon By Sam Catanzaro Two people were extricated from...

Developers Looking to Replace Century-Old Santa Monica Houses with Mixed-Use Development

May 10, 2021

May 10, 2021

Two houses would make away for three story, 10 unit development By Toi Creel Two Santa Monica homes, both around...