August 2, 2021 Breaking News, Latest News, and Videos

Councilmember Suing City of Santa Monica Over Conflict of Interest Decision

Lawsuit filed in LA County Court by Santa Monica City Councilmember Oscar de la Torre

By Sam Catanzaro

A Councilmember is suing Santa Monica over a conflict of interest decision relating to a voting rights case brought against the City by his wife. 

On March 3, Santa Monica City Councilmember Oscar de la Torre filed a lawsuit against the City of Santa Monica in Los Angeles County Superior Court. The lawsuit seeks an injunction against the City of barring him from taking part in discussion and voting on action relating to a voting rights case brought against the City by his wife. The lawsuit also seeks to stop the City Council from meeting in closed session without de la Torre. 

The case, filed by plaintiffs Pico Neighborhood Association, Maria Loya and Advocates for Malibu Public Schools, alleges that Santa Monica’s at-large election system dilutes Latino voting power in violation of the California Voting Rights Act (CVRA) and discriminates against Latino voters in violation of the Equal Protection Clause of the California Constitution.  De la Torre’s wife is plaintiff Maria Loya and until November 2020 he served on the Pico Neighborhood Association’s board. 

In a 2019 ruling the Los Angeles Superior Court Judge ordered that all future elections for seats on the Santa Monica City Council be based on a seven-district map drawn by an expert for the plaintiffs, including a 30 percent Latino district. The City then appealed this decision.

In July 2020, the California 2nd District Court of Appeal ruled in favor of the city saying that Latinos, who account for 14 percent of Santa Monica’s electorate, lack the numbers to win an election in the 30 percent Latino district ordered by the county. 

After the Appeals Court rejected a petition for a hearing, the plaintiffs filed their case with the California Supreme Court. On October 21 the Supreme Court took up the case, depublishing the Appellate Court ruling. The court has granted the City an extension until March 22 to file its answer brief on the appeal’s merits.

On January 26, 2021, Santa Monica City Council voted 4-2 with one abstention to exclude de la Torre from participation in any closed session or confidential conversation concerning the CRVA lawsuit and voting on any decisions relating to the case. 

De la Torre’s March 3 lawsuit points out that the California Fair Political Practices Commission (FPPC) has ruled that he has no financial conflict of interest in the case. City Attorney George Cardona however, cited de la Torre’s Common Law conflict of interest when recommending Council vote to exclude him. As reported by the Santa Monica Lookout, de la Torre’s lawsuit does not address the Common Law conflict of interest. 

De la Torre did not immediately respond to a request for a copy of the lawsuit. The Lookout, however, includes quotes in their coverage. In the case, de la Torre’s attorney Wilfredo Trivino-Perez argues that the plaintiff’s stake in the outcome of the case is no different than that of any other Santa Monica resident. This is a point de la Torre brought up at the January 26 meeting, arguing that his stake in the case is just an issue he cares about.  

“I care deeply about voting rights of minorities in Santa Monica and California more generally. Just like Sue [Himmelrich], everyone knows that you care deeply about affordable housing. Just like Kevin [McKeown], everyone knows that you care about environmental issues. My wife Maria [Loya] and the entire Pico Neighborhood Association board also care deeply about minority voting rights in Santa Monica,” de la Torre said.  

Councilmember Gleam Davis, who voted to exclude de la Torre at the Jan. 26 meeting, addressed this during the debate. 

“This is not about Oscar’s opinions. This is not about Coucilmember de la Torre’s bias,” Davis said. “It has to do with the very clear fact that Mr. de la Torre was in fact part of the group, head of the group, that decided to sue the City. That he is married to the individually named plaintiff in the lawsuit, and that those facts in and of themselves create a legal, a Common Law, of legal conflict of interest.”   

According to de la Torre’s March 3 lawsuit, the City lacks the jurisdiction to bar him from these decisions without his consent or a judicial determination of a conflict of interest. Therefore, the case argues the Santa Monica residents de la Torre was elected to represent are impacted. 

“The residents of Santa Monica he was elected to represent, have suffered and will continue to suffer irreparable injury,” Trivino-Perez wrote in the case per the Lookout. 

The City released the following statement when reached for comment:

On January 26, 2021, in a 4-2 vote (Councilmember Phil Brock abstained), the Santa Monica City Council made the determination that Councilmember Oscar de la Torre has a common law conflict of interest that requires his disqualification from discussions and decisions regarding the case of Pico Neighborhood Association and Maria Loya v. City of Santa Monica. The conflict is the result of Councilmember de la Torre’s personal relationships with the two plaintiffs who brought the litigation against the City.  Councilmember de la Torre is married to plaintiff  Maria Loya and is a former co-chair, and was deposed in the litigation as the person most knowledgeable of, plaintiff Pico Neighborhood Association.  The Council made clear that Councilmember de la Torre is not precluded from participating in any Council discussions regarding the City’s election system, and that the conflict precludes him only from participating in discussions and decisions regarding the pending lawsuit.  

The City has received the lawsuit filed by Councilmember de la Torre challenging the Council’s determination.  The City believes its determination was correct and will be responding to the lawsuit in court.

Related Posts

Library Director Patty Wong to Leave Santa Monica

July 30, 2021

July 30, 2021

Santa Monica Public Library (SMPL) Director Patty Wong announced recently that she will leave Santa Monica to take on the...

City Council Prioritizes Housing for Historically Displaced Households

July 28, 2021

July 28, 2021

At its meeting on July 13, Santa Monica City Council made changes to Santa Monica’s Affordable Housing Production Program and...

Homeless Man Charged with Hate Crime in Assault of Korean Woman in Santa Monica

July 27, 2021

July 27, 2021

Melvin Taylor faces charges in connection to July 23 incident By Sam Catanzaro Hate crime charges have been filed against...

Homeless Advocate Arrested Near Shelter on Suspicion of Dealing Drugs, Claims no Wrongdoing

July 27, 2021

July 27, 2021

65-year-old Garry Featherstone accused of selling meth, PCP By Sam Catanzaro A self-described homeless outreach advocate was recently arrested near...

Off Leash Dog Park And Picnic Area Coming To Downtown Santa Monica: Santa Monica Beat – July 27, 2021

July 27, 2021

July 27, 2021

Local news and culture in under 5 minutes. * Off Leash Dog Park And Picnic Area Coming To Downtown Santa...

Two Arrested for Main Street Bike Shop Burglary

July 23, 2021

July 23, 2021

Two suspects were arrested for the burglary of a Main Street bike store after the owner witnessed the crime via...

Council Selects Berkeley Deputy City Manager to Helm Santa Monica

July 23, 2021

July 23, 2021

David White to be Santa Monica’s next City Manager starting in October  By Sam Catanzaro Santa Monica City Council has...

Ocean Park Library Set to Reopen

July 20, 2021

July 20, 2021

New self-service hours begin July 28 By Sam Catanzaro The Santa Monica Public Library’s Ocean Park Branch is set to...

Police Tase Suspect Following Santa Monica Beach Stabbing

July 19, 2021

July 19, 2021

32-year-old man arrested Sunday evening on Santa Monica Beach, suffers head injuries in arrest By Sam Catanzaro As part of...

Santa Monica Beat: Santa Monica Beat – July 19, 2021

July 19, 2021

July 19, 2021

Local news and culture in under 5 minutes. * Serial Killer Arrested by SMPD Sentenced to Death * New Grants...

Santa Monica May Ban Lobbyists From Serving on Boards and Commissions

July 19, 2021

July 19, 2021

City Council instructs staff to draft ordinance to bar paid policy advocates from serving on board, commissions, task forces   By...

Water Near Santa Monica Pier Remains Questionable as Beach Closures Lifted Following Sewage Discharge

July 15, 2021

July 15, 2021

17 million gallons of raw sewage discharged from Hyperion Water Reclamation Plant Sunday Night By Sam Catanzaro Beach closures have...