June 27, 2022 Breaking News, Latest News, and Videos

A Miracle on 11th Street

The 1947 feel-good movie Miracle on 34th Street hinges substantially on whether Santa Claus is real. Likewise the debate about the proposed 11th Street Bungalow Historic District at the last two Landmarks Commission meetings hinged on whether it is a real Historical District? This proposed District is a collection of 1904 to 1925 bungalows on the east side of 11th Street from Wilshire Boulevard to Arizona Avenue.

Initially things did not look good for this District that had started its painful birth almost 30 years ago with the 1989 battle to save from demolition an important craftsman home at 1253 11th Street. That protracted battle, which rose to City Council level but was eventually lost, interestingly figured many of the same preservationists such as Susan Suntree, Ruthanne Lehrer, Ken Breisch, Thomas Hines and Robert Winter that have reappeared three decades later in the battle for this current District designation.

In the intervening decades there was some erosion to the potential district with for example the illegal loss of the original oriental roof detailing at the home at 1218 11th Street but the real adversaries were City selected consultants that took a very negative public position. For unknown reasons the City’s 2018 Historical Resources Inventory mysteriously said this no longer qualified as a district while all previous inventories said it did and the actual historian selected by the City to review the District application said essentially there was no there there and ignored significant findings that might have justified the District.

Counterbalancing these nay sayers was the Santa Monica and Pasadena Conservancies, six of the seven Neighborhood Organizations, Santa Monica for Renters Rights, SMa.r.t, the Housing Commission and dozens of preservation luminaries such as Bea Nemlaha, Tim Vreeland, Sherrill Kushner and Mike Salazar among others. Leading this parade were the co chairs Susan Suntree and Diane Miller with Andrew Hoyer who actually filed the designation application for Mid Cities Neighbors. Over a period of about two years, they amassed an incredible collection of volunteer activists, researchers, neighborhood organizers, architects and preservationists to make the case that this district consisting of ten properties, five of which were intact contributors to the district, two were altered contributors and three non contributors (not built between 1904 and 1925), merited designation as the City’s 4th historic district.

The detractors emphasized that the five small contributing bungalows where visually overwhelmed by their adjacent two and three story neighbors and were too dispersed: only two contributors were side by side. Then there was the fact that only 50 percent of the hundred year old bungalows were contributors still substantially in their original condition. The altered contributors compromised the street scape as did the huge amount of street traffic and finally the entire block was screened by oversized fences and vegetation. The opponents argued that it did not look or “feel” like it had the integrity of a real historic District. These arguments deadlocked the first Landmark Commission meeting November 12: three for, two against one recused and one absent. This would have been a technical denial since four “yes” votes are needed for approval but the item was fortunately continued to the next meeting.

At the next meeting the Three Housequeteers (Genser, Sloan and Rosenbaum) rode to the rescue with a strong case and eloquent arguments that the proposed District should be designated because it met three specific findings of the Santa Monica’s Historical Code:

1. It manifests elements of the City’s economic, social and architectural history. These one story small bungalows with ample backyards were middle-class housing of a specific architectural style popular one hundred years ago. Today our City can no longer produce such middle-class housing.

2. It reflects a geographical pattern of settlement. This street’s homes represents the eastern growing edge of our City’s development away from the ocean at the turn of the last century. During the twenty-odd year period of historical significance (1904-1925) the City grew from a quiet village (pop. 5,299) to a bustling town (pop. 26,196). This explosive, five-fold growth rate has never been duplicated since in any two-decade period.

3. It connects to the life of famous personages or builder/architects. Waldo K. Cowan who built four of the houses, shaped Santa Monica’s founding civic culture, having served on many local boards and commissions, including, among others, the Santa Monica School Board, election boards, and the United Charities board. He was a member of the organization that became the Chamber of Commerce. He was known in Southern California to advocate for urban agriculture, bike paths and better roads. These last three initiatives are proposals we are still trying to implement today. Ken Strickfadden, a special effects genius lived at 1223 11th Street and was known for the innovative wildly arcing and sparking effects seen in such films as the 1931 “Frankenstein” movie. He was also a photographer, providing an important record of Santa Monica, now available at our Library’s Image Archives. Santa Monica has always been intimately linked to Hollywood. Finally Joseph J Rowe built two of the houses and is praised as a master builder who brought the influence of Greene and Greene to Santa Monica. His house at 929 Lincoln has already been landmarked.

These three findings carried the day along the fact that our code does not specify the amount of historic contributors in a district, the fact that the owners who opposed the designation could still freely fully develop their rear yards, the fact that it was a pedestrian-scaled district whose fences and plantings could be easily changed and finally the altered contributors could at some future date be un-stuccoed to return to be contributors.

During this process two Landmarks Commissioners changed their mind. This is to their credit and speaks to a common feeling among people who testify at City hearings: that it doesn’t matter what you say: the officials have already made up their mind. The truth is that the recipients of public testimony are influenced and are influenceable, so you should always make your case; the outcome can change up until the very last minute as it did in this case . The final vote was a victorious unanimous five yes, one recused and one absent.

Yes Virginia there is a Santa Claus. He just brought us a brand new one-hundred-year-old Historic District for the City Council’s blessing in January.

Mario Fonda-Bonardi AIA for SMa.r.t.

(San Monica Architects for a Responsible Tomorrow)

Thane Roberts AIA, Architect, Robert H. Taylor AIA, Ron Goldman FAIA, Architect, Dan Jansenson, Architect, Building and Fire-Life Safety Commission, Samuel Tolkin Architect, Mario Fonda-Bonardi, AIA, Planning Commissioner, Phil Brock, Santa Monica Arts Commission. For previous articles see www.santamonicaarch.wordpress.com/writings.

in Sports
Related Posts

Super Bowl Pre-Game Show to Be Broadcast From Santa Monica Pier

February 10, 2022

February 10, 2022

The Santa Monica Pier will be the location for the Super Bowl Pre-Game show broadcast. Learn more in this video...

Santa Monica Youth Basketball Staying and Playing Strong

October 13, 2021

October 13, 2021

By Dr. Paul Drew Hello everyone, I’m Dr. Paul Drew.  It’s been a long time since I’ve been able to...

Local Hoopers Rejoice As Venice Basketball League Returns

September 6, 2021

September 6, 2021

The Venice Basketball League is officially back on the courts after nearly 2 years of closure. Nick Ansom joins us...

Westside Olympic Swimmer Shares Her Journey To The Games

August 31, 2021

August 31, 2021

Two time Olympian, Westside Local, and Medical Student Andi Murez has returned from the Tokyo games, hear about her journey...

Local Little League All-Star Team Wins More Than Just Championships

August 10, 2021

August 10, 2021

The Venice Baseball Academy’s little league team, the Tide, recently won the SoCal State Championships but it’s more than winning...

Crossroads Wins CIF and State Regionals

June 15, 2021

June 15, 2021

The Crossroads Varsity Boys Soccer Team had a stellar championship season starting with a true underdog story with CIF Division 6 Playoff...

Samohi Vikings Frosh-Soph Defeat Culver City Centaurs in Final Seconds

April 20, 2021

April 20, 2021

2020 was a tough year for Santa Monica High School football as Covid-19 restrictions forced all high school sports to...

Pali Riptide Baseball Club Tryouts

January 7, 2021

January 7, 2021

January 9th and 10th at Pali Rec Center The Pali Riptide Baseball Club is preparing for a spring season and...

Grand Jury Indicts Former Angel Employee in Tyler Skaggs’ Fatal Overdose

October 19, 2020

October 19, 2020

Fort Wayne grand jury indicts Eric Prescott Kay on drug distribution and drug conspiracy charges By Sam Catanzaro A federal...

Column: How to Play it Safe to Prevent Deadly Heat Exhaustion

August 24, 2020

August 24, 2020

By Shawn McCann  As the Southland region broils in a summer heatwave, the coronavirus pandemic has created additional concern for...

Former Angels Employee Charged in Tyler Skagg’s Fatal Fentanyl Overdose

August 7, 2020

August 7, 2020

Former Angels Communications Director Eric Prescott Kay faces up to 20 years in prison By Sam Catanzaro An ex-employee of...

LA Marathon to Exclude Santa Monica

July 24, 2020

July 24, 2020

Race organizers, citing “bigger footprint at the finish line”, choose Century City end point By Sam Catanzaro Santa Monica has...

High School Sports Pushed Back Until Winter

July 21, 2020

July 21, 2020

All California high school sports will not begin until mid-December By Sam Catanzaro High school sports in Santa Monica and...

Video: Venice Skatepark Taken Back by Skaters

May 28, 2020

May 28, 2020

Defying officials, Venice Skate Park skaters recently took matters into their own hands after the City of Los Angeles filled...

Video: Westside MLB Brothers Give Back

May 18, 2020

May 18, 2020

Two Westside brothers, both professional baseball players, are giving back to local first responders COVID-19 pandemic. Learn more in this...