September 30, 2020 Breaking News, Latest News, and Videos

Why Consumers Won’t Get Much Of Dynergy’s Millions:

There was applause from environmentalists when Gov. Jerry Brown and the state Public Utilities Commission late last month accepted a $120 million settlement from NRG Energy, Inc., for the part it and the bankrupt former electric generator Dynegy, Inc., played in the power crisis that afflicted California 11 years ago.

To be paid over four years, that settlement will see NRG spend 80 percent of the money on a network of electric car charging stations along major highways and in the state’s biggest cities. Only 20 percent will go to consumers in the form of very small rate reductions.

Few questioned any of the deal, even though electric customers bilked during the crisis will get mere pennies back for this part of the many dollars the cheating Dynegy stole from them. (New Jersey-based NRG six years ago bought out Dynegy’s interest in two California power plants. Dynegy paid consumers $281 million in a previous settlement.)

Despite numerous attempts to get his explanation, Brown has yet to offer a rationale for spending most of the money on charging stations rather than refunding it to myriad cheated customers. The best his office has offered was this from spokesman Evan Westrup: “$100 million to expand the state’s clean energy infrastructure is good news for all Californians.”

Altogether, Dynegy caused an estimated 10 percent of the $9 billion in overcharges California electric customers paid during the crunch because of illegal market manipulations by Enron, Dynegy, Reliant Energy, Williams Energy, Mirant and other firms, most of them based in Texas. Including this settlement, it has paid back about $400 million.

So Brown endorses a deal that gets consumers little, while leaving Dynegy’s successor the owner of 200 full-service charging stations. Another 1,000 smaller charging facilities will go into commercial buildings and apartment or condominium complexes.

The best explanation of why this money will go to electric car chargers comes from Frank Lindh, the utility commission’s general counsel. In a telephone interview, he said refusing this settlement would risk eight more years of legal wrangling, with the possibility Californians could end up with nothing.

The chargers, he said, are what NRG offered, “and I think it’s the best we can do here.” For sure, the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission – which would hear any further case – has never approved a full refund of illegal gains by any electric generating company.

Meanwhile, the new chargers will likely spur more use of electric cars in California. The question is whether the PUC should have pressed its refund demands or accepted this kind of subsidy for a new sort of infrastructure. No one ever subsidized America’s gigantic network of gasoline stations. No similar largesse is yet going to anyone building hydrogen fueling stations for what many believe will be a coming generation of H2-powered cars and trucks.

It’s certainly possible to see this use of money as a form of theft. In virtually any other settlement for corporate wrongdoing, most of it would go back to those who were cheated. Residential ratepayers saw their monthly electric bills rise by an average of more than $10 per month during and after the crisis of 2000 and 2001, when then-Gov. Gray Davis was essentially blackmailed into accepting electric power supply deals at exorbitant prices rather than risk years of blackouts and brownouts. That was what the crooked generating companies threatened in their heyday, before many of their executives were later convicted for their complex cheating.

It’s also true that today’s limited number of electric car and plug-in hybrid models sell for many thousands of dollars more than comparable gasoline-powered cars. So cheated ratepayers will now subsidize the wealthy who can afford those cars.

Complained Steve Frank, the former head of the conservative California Republican Assembly and a persistent Brown critic, “(Brown) has stolen $100 million belonging to the people of California to buy a wasteful, unneeded personal toy… Brown has decided to misuse our money for his bad dream policies.”

Actually, Brown didn’t arrange the NRG/Dynegy settlement, even if he did announce it in the same press release as his executive order demanding that state officials work with private companies to get 1.5 million electric cars on the road by 2025. The PUC did that.

But Brown appointees, like Air Resources Board Chair Mary Nichols, hailed the action. “This…will clean our air, lower greenhouse gas emissions and reduce our dependence on imported oil,” she said. Added PUC Commissioner Mike Florio, a former consumer advocate, “This creative deal…propels us down the road to a clean transportation future…”

But the people who were cheated will not be repaid by this settlement. The bottom line is that no one will ever know if Lindh and the PUC are correct about this being the best that could be done.

in News
Related Posts

Santa Monica Walk to End Alzheimer’s

September 29, 2020

September 29, 2020

Alzheimer’s Association encouraging residents to walk in small groups amid COVID-19 The Alzheimer’s Association is inviting Santa Monica residents to...

Lawsuit Filed Against Plaza Development

September 28, 2020

September 28, 2020

Slow-growth group says City is violating Surplus Land Act By Sam Catanzaro A slow-growth group has filed a lawsuit to...

City Of Santa Monica Being Sued Over Proposed Plaza Project: Santa Monica Beat – September, 28, 2020

September 28, 2020

September 28, 2020

Local news and culture in under 5 minutes. * Santa Monica Being Sued Over Proposed Plaza Project. * LA Street...

Santa Monica Police Make Additional Arrests in Looting of REI

September 28, 2020

September 28, 2020

Marques Miles and Misty Jones arrested by Santa Monica Police Department Santa Monica police recently made additional arrests of two...

OpEd: The Miramar Project Will Be a New Architectural Jewel

September 27, 2020

September 27, 2020

The Miramar Hotel has been a central part of Santa Monica’s history and an integral part of the community for...

Edify TV: Trident Center Redevelopment

September 25, 2020

September 25, 2020

The Westside’s Trident Center is getting a major overhaul and new name as part of a flurry of development in...

Miramar Project to go Before City Council Tuesday

September 24, 2020

September 24, 2020

Councilmember Gleam Davis asks City Attorney whether she should rescue self from vote  By Sam Catanzaro  Santa Monica lawmakers will...

SMa.r.t. Column: Needed, A Heart Transplant

September 24, 2020

September 24, 2020

We have written about adaptive reuse in previous columns and have postulated that with proper incentives, the existing one, two...

Edify TV: Boulders Blocking Westside Encampment

September 24, 2020

September 24, 2020

City officials recently removed boulders placed on sidewalks by some Westside residents to prevent the formation of a homeless encampment....

Should Council Member Davis Recuse Herself From Voting? Santa Monica Beat – September, 24, 2020

September 24, 2020

September 24, 2020

Local news and culture in under 5 minutes. * Should Council Member Davis Recuse Herself From Voting? * Increases In...

SMC to Be Online for Winter and Spring 2021

September 24, 2020

September 24, 2020

College cites lack of available vaccine  By Sam Catanzaro Santa Monica College (SMC) has announced it will be delivering classes...

Edify TV: Al Fresco Program Ending?

September 24, 2020

September 24, 2020

During a COVID-19 pandemic many restaurants have found aid through the City of Los Angeles’ Al Fresco dining program, but...

Local Breweries Say They Have Been Unfairly Shuttered as County Passes Grant Program

September 24, 2020

September 24, 2020

$10 million grant program approved by Board of Supervisors  By Sam Catanzaro Will a $10 million grant program be enough...

Santa Monica Loses Vegan Restaurant

September 23, 2020

September 23, 2020

Space housing Santa Monica vegan restaurant Viva Vegan up for lease By Sam Catanzaro A vegan restaurant in Santa Monica...

Risks Posed by Wildfire Smoke

September 22, 2020

September 22, 2020

UCLA pulmonologist on how people can tell if the wildfires are making them sick By Toi Creel Even if you...