August 3, 2025 Breaking News, Latest News, and Videos

Voting Rights Trial Against City Wraps Up

At-large election system at stake, decision expected October 25. 

By Sam Catanzaro

A voting rights case that could change the future of elections in Santa Monica saw both sides give final arguments on Tuesday, September 11 as the trial wrapped up after six weeks in court. A decision from Judge Yvette M. Palazuelos, expected after October 25, could force the City of Santa Monica to replace their at-large election system with a district-based system.

The case, Pico Neighborhood Association et al. v. City of Santa Monica, pits voting rights advocates against the City of Santa Monica. The plaintiffs, led by resident Maria Loya, argue that the City’s at-large election system dilutes the Latino vote in City Council elections and is in violation of the 2002 California Voting Rights Act, which was passed to increase opportunities for Latinos and other minorities to elect representatives of their choice.

The case against Santa Monica was filed by Malibu-based attorney Kevin Shenkman, who has initiated similar lawsuits in dozens of cities throughout California. In 2012, the city of Palmdale was forced to change to district-based elections after losing a lawsuit to Shenkman. Other cities in the state, including South Pasadena, Lancaster, West Covina, Arcadia and Torrence have voluntarily switched to district-based systems fearing legal action from Shenkman.

At-large election systems were the norm for most of California’s history, but in the late 90s as the population became more diverse, this system of electing officials came under criticism from minority activists. These critics argue that at-large elections result in a disproportional number of white individuals dominating city councils, commissions and school boards. In the case against Santa Monica, plaintiffs argue that 13 percent of Santa Monica’s population is Latino yet the proposed Pico neighborhood district that would be 34 percent Latino. These residents, they contend, are currently under-represented in City Council.

Defense attorney Kevin Shenkman has filed similar lawsuits against cites throughout California. Photo: Courtesy.

The City counters, however, by saying that Latinos do enjoy success in City Council elections, pointing to Latino Councilmember Tony Vazquez, who is one out of seven councilmembers. Defense lawyers argue that this makes City Council 14.3 percent Latino, greater than the 13.1 percent of the City’s 89,736 residents who are Hispanic or Latino. The City also points to Mayor Pro-Tempore Gleam Davis, who testified during the trial that her adopted parents told her that her biological father is from Mexico.

“Latinos in Santa Monica have had tremendous success electing candidates of their choice to the City Council, and that any change in the City’s method of election proposed by the plaintiffs will not increase (and in fact would likely diminish) Latinos’ ability to elect candidates of their choice,” wrote Debbie Lee Chief Communications Officer for the City of Santa Monica’s City Manager’s Office in a statement.

The defense’s evidence included testimony from voting rights scholar Dr. Allan Lichtman of American University, political scientist Dr. Jeffrey Lewis of UCLA and former RAND Corporation demographer Dr. Peter Morrison. The testimony from these experts was used by lawyers for the City to argue that Santa Monica’s election system was not in violation of the California Voting Rights Act.

“The evidence presented at trial demonstrates, the City’s method of election complies fully with the California Voting Right Act and the state and federal constitutions,” said the City’s lead trial counsel, Marcellus McRae of Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP.

The plaintiffs have until Sept. 25 to file a closing brief. The defense will then get 20 days to submit a response before Judge Palazuelos issues a ruling. If all parties take the maximum amount of time allotted to submit documents, Judge Palazuelos will be able to render a decision as of October 25.

If Judge Palazuelos rules in favor of the plaintiffs, it remains unclear what impact this would have on the November election, especially if a ruling overturning at-large elections is handed down after the election.

The Santa Monica Mirror reached out to the plaintiffs for comment, but they have not responded at the time of publishing.

in News
<>Related Posts

Heidi Klum’s Tropical Erewhon Smoothie Drops Just in Time for Summer

August 2, 2025

August 2, 2025

Supermodel’s Limited-Edition Drink Blends Kiwi, Coconut, and Matcha Erewhon has debuted its newest celebrity smoothie collaboration, this time with supermodel...

California Bolsters Firefighting Fleet Amid Federal Cuts

August 2, 2025

August 2, 2025

The transition, which began in 2020, equips the fleet with advanced technology, including a 1,000-gallon water capacity—nearly triple that of...

Big Blue Bus to Restore Service on Route to Palisades

August 2, 2025

August 2, 2025

The restoration is part of a broader summer service overhaul aimed at improving coverage across the Westside The Big Blue...

Fatal Crash Claims 9-Year-Old’s Life in Los Angeles

August 1, 2025

August 1, 2025

The driver of the vehicle remained at the scene and was arrested for driving under the influence A tragic traffic...

Malibu Hires New City Manager: Ronda Perez to Lead as City Eyes Recovery and Rebuilding

August 1, 2025

August 1, 2025

Veteran Public Administrator Ronda Perez Brings Nearly 20 Years of Experience to Malibu The Malibu City Council has voted unanimously...

Santa Monica Creates Film Office to Streamline Permitting and Production Services

August 1, 2025

August 1, 2025

New Agency Will Take Over From FilmLA After More Than a Decade Beginning September 1, 2025, film permit coordination in...

Santa Monica Pier Launches “PIERfect Benefit” Fundraiser Amid Recovery Efforts

August 1, 2025

August 1, 2025

The gathering will feature food, signature cocktails, live entertainment, and a program reflecting the Pier’s history and future. Proceeds will...

THIS WEEKEND: 49th Annual Festival of the Chariots to Roll Through Santa Monica and Venice

August 1, 2025

August 1, 2025

The festival site at Ocean Front Walk Plaza will transform into a lively showcase of Indian culture, expecting around 50,000...

Film Review: The Fantastic Four: First Steps

August 1, 2025

August 1, 2025

FILM REVIEWTHE FANTASTIC FOUR: FIRST STEPSRated PG-13115 MinutesReleased July 25th  The Fantastic Four: First Steps has a different aura from...

Aging Mindfully: Zen-Inspired Senior Living Takes Shape in Simi Valley

July 31, 2025

July 31, 2025

Two Zen-inspired senior living communities are embracing the reality of aging — consciously. Ensō Village, open since 2023 in Sonoma County,...

Palisades, Malibu Among Areas Exempt from SB 9 Under Newsom’s Wildfire Safety Order

July 31, 2025

July 31, 2025

Newsom Sides with LA Leaders on SB 9 Freeze, Mayor Bass Issues Executive Order Gov. Gavin Newsom on Wednesday signed...

‘All Stars’ National Night Out Coming to Santa Monica on Tuesday

July 31, 2025

July 31, 2025

The event, themed “Santa Monica All Stars,” aims to foster police-community partnerships through a sports-inspired evening The Santa Monica Police...

City of Santa Monica Issues Statement on Surprise DTSM Board Member Replacement

July 30, 2025

July 30, 2025

Santa Monica City Government Defends Emergency Action and Process After the surprising move from the City Council, six members of...

Texas Kitchen Chain to Open Santa Monica Location at Former Fresh Corn Grill Site

July 30, 2025

July 30, 2025

The Santa Monica outpost will occupy a 3,050-square-foot space featuring a newly built kitchen and a large outdoor patio HomeState,...

Film Review: Together

July 30, 2025

July 30, 2025

By Dolores Quintana Dave Franco and Alison Brie, a married couple in real life, star in Michael Shanks’ gruesomely passionate...