May 16, 2022 Breaking News, Latest News, and Videos

U.S. Court of Appeals Upholds Santa Monica’s Home-Sharing Ordinance

Challenges by Airbnb, HomeAway rejected

By Sam Catanzaro

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit has reaffirmed its rejection of Airbnb, Inc. and Homeaway.com’s challenge to the City of Santa Monica’s Home-Sharing Ordinance, which penalizes the online platforms for unlawfully booking short-term vacation rentals of unlicensed properties in Santa Monica. 

“Santa Monica’s Home-Sharing Ordinance is a key element of the City’s work to produce, preserve, and protect housing in Santa Monica.  The regulation strikes a careful balance:  It allows residents to invite visitors into their homes for profit when a resident is present in the home and possesses a City business license; but it otherwise prohibits property owners and online platforms like Airbnb, Inc., and Homeaway.com from booking residential properties for short-term vacation rentals,” the City of Santa Monica said in a press release.  

Before the Ninth Circuit, Airbnb, Inc. and Homeaway.com argued that the City’s ordinance ran afoul of the Communications Decency Act and the First Amendment because it required the platforms to monitor the content of third-party listings on their sites and remove listings for unlicensed properties.  A panel of the Ninth Circuit rejected this argument in March.  The panel found that the Ordinance only “prohibits processing transactions for unregistered properties” and does not proscribe, mandate, or even discuss the content of the listings that the Platforms display on their websites.  It requires only that transactions involve licensed properties.” 

In response to the platforms’ arguments that upholding this local regulation would impose administrative costs and frustrate their business model, the Court declined to “expand [the Communications Decency Act’s] provisions beyond what Congress initially intended” and explained that “[w]e have consistently eschewed an expansive reading of the statute that would render unlawful conduct magically . . . lawful when [conducted] online, and therefore giv[e] online businesses an unfair advantage over their real-world counterparts.”  

In an email to the Santa Monica Mirror after the court’s march decisions, the company said that the ruling will hurt middle and working-class families who rely on home-sharing as a source of income.

“Airbnb sought to work with the City of Santa Monica on a solution that ensures working and middle-class families who want to visit the coast can find an affordable place to stay. Despite our efforts, the city insisted on an approach that was out of step with progress across the country,” Airbnb said.

The company went on to point out that in cities such as Santa Barbara, New York and Miami courts have invalidated municipalities’ home-sharing bans.

On Friday, the Ninth Circuit declined the platforms’ petition requesting that either the panel or an en banc panel drawn from the full Court rehear the case.  The City’s Home-Sharing Ordinance thus stands absent a petition by the platforms to the United States Supreme Court.    

“We are thrilled to have confirmation from the Ninth Circuit that our balanced approach to home sharing is permitted at a time when housing and affordability continue to challenge the region,” said Santa Monica Mayor Gleam Davis. “This is a big win for Santa Monica residents and our residential neighborhoods.” 

City Attorney Lane Dilg said, “Santa Monica’s Home-Sharing Ordinance is a lawful regulation and a key element in the City’s efforts to produce, preserve, and protect housing in our community.  The Court’s decision will help state and local governments across the country as they work to preserve affordability and protect housing for those who live and work in their regions.”

Santa Monica has some of the strictest home-share regulations in the United States, outlawing rentals of whole houses to tourists and travelers for under 30 days. In addition, vacation-rental hosts in Santa Monica can only rent individual rooms to guests and must be present in the residence throughout the entire stay.

The City was represented in this case by attorneys from the Santa Monica City Attorney’s Office, including Special Counsel / Chief of Staff George Cardona, who argued the case, Yibin Shen, Heidi Von Tongeln, and Michael Cobden.   

The City received amicus support from the City and County of San Francisco; the District of Columbia; the Mayor and City Council of Baltimore; Cook County, Illinois; the City of Columbus, Ohio; the City of Dayton, Ohio; the City of Gary, Indiana; the City of Oakland; the City of Sacramento; the City of Santa Cruz; the City of Seattle; the City of Somerville, Massachusetts; the Public Rights Project; UNITE HERE; the California Apartment Association; the National Multifamily Housing Council; the National Apartment Association; the Apartment Investment and Management Company; Avalonbay Communities, Inc; the Community Associations Institute; the League of California Cities; the International Municipal Lawyers Association; the California State Association of Counties; and a group of professors of business and law from across the country. 

in News
Related Posts

1221 Ocean Avenue Complex Sold For Record Price

May 16, 2022

May 16, 2022

Sold for a record price of $330 million. By Dolores Quintana The Irvine Company has sold 1221 Ocean Avenue to...

Office Construction Is Starting To Rise In Los Angeles

May 15, 2022

May 15, 2022

Property vacancies are still affecting growth.  By Dolores Quintana In March, the Los Angeles Metropolitan area had 3.2 million square...

Santa Monica City Council Selects Doug Sloan as New City Attorney

May 12, 2022

May 12, 2022

At its meeting this week, the Santa Monica City Council appointed Doug Sloan to serve as Santa Monica’s next City...

Landmark Theater Closing in Former Westside Pavillion

May 12, 2022

May 12, 2022

Theater will close at the end of month By Sam Catanzaro The Landmark Pico theater at the former Westside Pavillion...

Community Policing at the Heart of Beat Four

May 11, 2022

May 11, 2022

The Neighborhood Resource Officer (NRO) Program thrives through community involvement and collective work. Today we hear from Officer Aaron Alpert...

Santa Monica High School Among Top-900 Schools in Country

May 10, 2022

May 10, 2022

SAMOHI ranked 829 out of over 18,000 total schools By Staff Writer Santa Monica High School is among the top...

Pico Marketplace Changing Small Businesses Access to Retail Space: Santa Monica Beat – May 10th, 2022

May 10, 2022

May 10, 2022

Local news and culture in under 5 minutes.* Pico Marketplace Changing Small Businesses Access to Retail Space* Grunion Fish Seen...

Video: Westside E-Scooter Injury Rate High Than National Rate for Motorcycles

May 10, 2022

May 10, 2022

The Westside’s injury rate for e-scooters is higher than the national rate for motorcycles, a new study has found. Learn...

Douglas Sloan Set to be Santa Monica’s New City Attorney

May 9, 2022

May 9, 2022

Sloan would be first permanent person to hold post in two years By Dolores Quintana  The next Santa Monica City...

Santa Monica Releases 2022 Homeless Count Results

May 9, 2022

May 9, 2022

Number of unsheltered individuals increases 1 percent in first count since 2020 By Dolores Quintana and Sam Catanzaro The City...

Amazon Bringing 1,000 News Jobs to Santa Monica

May 6, 2022

May 6, 2022

Company signs a lease for a 200,000-square-foot space at the Water Garden  By Dolores Quintana Amazon.com intends to create 2,500...

LA Considering Emblem Program to License Cannabis Stores

May 6, 2022

May 6, 2022

Program would help Angelenos distinguish between licensed and unlicensed cannabis vendors and safe cannabis products By Dolores Quintana Members of...

Meet SMPD Beat Three Neighborhood Resource Officers

May 6, 2022

May 6, 2022

The Neighborhood Resource Officer (NRO) Program is based around the concept of community policing and collective involvement. Today we met...

McKinley Elementary School Awarded California Pivotal Practice Award

May 5, 2022

May 5, 2022

The Santa Monica-Malibu Unified School District has announced that McKinley Elementary in Santa Monica has been awarded the California Department...

UCLA Study Offers Strategy for Freeway Congestion Pricing That Reduces Burden on Low-Income Residents

May 5, 2022

May 5, 2022

Claudia Bustamante/UCLA Newsroom  Among transportation experts, congestion pricing is the gold standard policy for managing traffic on freeways and highways....