February 11, 2025 Breaking News, Latest News, and Videos

California Supreme Court Upholds Key Provisions of State’s Voting Rights Law in Santa Monica Case

Ruling Clarifies Requirements for District-Based Voting, Reaffirms Protections for Minority Voters

By Dolores Quintana

In a ruling that has significant implications for California’s voting rights law, the state’s Supreme Court delivered a decision on Thursday that serves to reaffirm certain protections in the law, but how long those protections will remain isn’t clear. 

The case in question, initiated by the Pico Neighborhood Association and others in 2016, alleged that Santa Monica’s at-large voting system for city council elections violated the California Voting Rights Act by diminishing the voting influence of the Latino community, which constituted 14% of the city’s voting-age population at the time. Rather than electing council members citywide, the plaintiffs sought a shift to district-based voting, where voters in each district would choose their representative.

A trial court issued the first decision, and the court ruled for the Pico Association. The court’s ruling ordered the city to transition to district-based voting. However, in July 2020, the decision was reversed in a state appeals court. 

On August 24, California’s Supreme Court issued a unanimous ruling, asserting that the appeals court had made an error by “misconstruing” the California Voting Rights Act. The ruling, written by Justice Kelli Evans, who wrote on behalf of the court, clarified that plaintiffs need only establish racially polarized voting in an at-large system and are not required to demonstrate that minority voters would constitute a majority or near-majority in a hypothetical district.

The Pico Neighborhood Association expressed their perspective, stating, “The at-large election system in Santa Monica has marginalized the Pico Neighborhood and its diverse residents for far too long.”

While U.S. Sen. Alex Padilla of California supported the association, the League of California Cities and the Special Districts Association, along with a coalition including the League of Women Voters of Santa Monica and the Alliance of Santa Monica Latino and Black Voters, filed briefs in support of the city. They argued that Santa Monica had made significant strides in ensuring voting power for Latino and Black voters under the at-large system.

The case has not been completely settled since the next step is for the case to go to the appeals court. Santa Monica’s statement on the ruling said briefly, “The City is reviewing the Supreme Court’s opinion and working to assess the path forward.”

The association urged city officials to “settle the case quickly” and avoid expending taxpayer resources on additional litigation, suggesting that these funds would be better directed toward addressing the city’s public safety and community service needs.

The 2001 State Voting Rights Act granted minority groups increased capacity to challenge at-large elections that might undermine their voting influence. According to the League of California Cities, at least 185 cities and nearly 400 other jurisdictions in California have shifted to district-based elections.

in News
<>Related Posts

 (Video) Beaten Dead Body Found on Santa Monica Shore

February 11, 2025

February 11, 2025

The Victim Was Pronounced Dead at the Scene The Victim Was Pronounced Dead at the Scene. pic.twitter.com/88huU3goOO — Santa Monica...

Worker Relief Fund Launched for Those Impacted by Palisades Fire

February 11, 2025

February 11, 2025

In addition to direct relief, the county is seeking donations for the fund Los Angeles County has launched the LA...

How Much Have Palisades Property Values Slipped After the Fire?

February 11, 2025

February 11, 2025

Property prices drop as sellers and buyers remain at odds in post-fire market Property values in Pacific Palisades have taken...

Retailers Impose Purchase Restrictions as Supply Chain Disruptions Cause Concern

February 10, 2025

February 10, 2025

Egg Limits Are Back – What’s Causing the Shortage? Retailers across the United States, including Costco and Trader Joe’s, have...

Community Protest and Petition Against Controversial EPA Plan For Hazardous Waste Site

February 10, 2025

February 10, 2025

CD 11 City Councilmember Park to Hold Community Town Hall on Will Rogers Site Protesters marched against the Environmental Protection...

New Bill Targets Crime in Disaster Zones – Here’s What You Need to Know

February 10, 2025

February 10, 2025

Lawmakers Push for Tougher Penalties To Protect Vulnerable Communities California lawmakers have introduced a bipartisan bill aimed at cracking down...

Mysterious Death Near Santa Monica Shoreline, Police Investigating

February 10, 2025

February 10, 2025

SMPD Seeks Information About Victim With Facial Trauma  The Santa Monica Police Department is investigating the death of a woman...

Burned Palisades Lot Sells for Nearly $1M: REPORT

February 10, 2025

February 10, 2025

Aerial images show the property was among several homes in the neighborhood destroyed by the fire A vacant lot in...

Palisades Symphony to Host Benefit Concert to Support Displaced Musicians

February 10, 2025

February 10, 2025

Several members of the Palisades Symphony lost their homes in the fires, making this concert a deeply personal effort The...

What about are you protected from future wildfires?

February 9, 2025

February 9, 2025

Our hearts go out to all those impacted by the recent wildfires and Santa Ana windstorms in Southern California. We...

Shore Hotel Remains Sustainability Leader

February 9, 2025

February 9, 2025

By Susan Payne On track to open its new coastal-inspired restaurant, Shore Hotel has excited new offerings and initiatives this...

Rescheduled 2024 Homeless Count Needs More Volunteers on the Westside

February 9, 2025

February 9, 2025

Not Enough Volunteers to Successfully Count Unhoused Angelenos This Year With the rescheduled dates for the 2025 Greater Los Angeles...

Student Protest Over Immigration Policies Leads to Walkouts Across the Westside

February 7, 2025

February 7, 2025

Walkout Turns Tense as Counter-Protester Confronts Teen in Video From Venice Students from Santa Monica High School (SAMOHI), Culver City...

10-Year-Old Palisades Girl Wins Martial Arts Medals Weeks After Losing Home to Fire

February 6, 2025

February 6, 2025

Savoian, a green belt in Yoshukai karate, trained at Gerry Blanck’s Martial Arts Center in Pacific Palisades Just weeks after...

Open Arms Art Show Runs Through Mar. 22 in Burbank

February 6, 2025

February 6, 2025

Opening Exhibition Saturday Feb. 8 from 12 to 8p.m. More than an art show, the Open Arms Exhibition is an...