September 29, 2020 Breaking News, Latest News, and Videos

Veteran Sues VA in Flag Dispute:

The continuing saga concerning the proper use of the land at the nation’s largest Veteran’s Administration campus took another turn on Tuesday, March 15, when the leader of two years of Sunday afternoon protests filed suit against VA officials, claiming that they violated his constitutional rights “based on the content of his expression and viewpoint he espouses.” 

The controversy involves not only the proper use of the VA land in West Los Angeles, but also the proper treatment of the American flag, which the protesters have been hanging upside down in front of the VA grounds.

Robert Rosebrock, a 67-year-old Army veteran, has been leading protests at the corner of Wilshire and San Vicente Boulevards every Sunday since March 9, 2008.  His group objects to the use of the VA property for non-veteran-related purposes, in particular an August 2007 Sharing Agreement between the U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) and the nonprofit Veterans Park Conservancy for the use of 16 acres of VA land adjoining that intersection as a park to “serve the needs of veterans and residents alike.”  [Santa Monica Mirror, January 1-7, 2009]

The protesters marked their 100th consecutive Sunday last month on February 21, announced a grand plan for the VA land to include housing for homeless veterans instead of a public park on the Wilshire/San Vicente corner, and promised more positive initiatives in support of their position.  At the following Sunday protest on February 28, VA police physically removed an American flag that had been hung upside down after Rosebrock refused to remove it himself.

The controversy concerning the flag had been brewing for some time.  The protesters hung a flag on the VA fence from the beginning of their protests in March 2008.  Beginning in mid-2009, the protesters began hanging the flag with the union (the blue field with stars) down as a distress call.  Rosebrock was then cited several times by the VA under a regulation which “criminalizes the distribution of materials or displaying of placards or posting materials on VA property” except as specifically authorized by the VA, according to Rosebrock’s suit filed March 16. 

The citations against Rosebrock were all dismissed in December 2009 at the request of the U.S. Attorney’s office, but the flag-hanging dispute lingered.  A VA official had written Rosebrock that hanging the flag upside down “is considered a desecration of the flag and is not allowed on VA property.”  Rosebrock had countered that it was a legally recognized distress signal, and that was his message.  So when the VA police struck the distress signal on February 28, Rosebrock took the positive initiative of filing suit.

Rosebrock’s free speech lawsuit was filed by the ACLU of Southern California against Donna Beiter, director of the VA West Los Angeles facility, and Ronald Mathis, chief of the VA police at that facility, each in their official capacity.  “The VA has shown a basic misunderstanding of the meaning of the First Amendment of the Constitution, the very document that Mr. Rosebrock and other veterans have served in the military to protect,” said ACLU managing attorney Peter Eliasberg.

Beiter’s office declined to comment on the suit and referred all inquiries to a VA official in Washington, D.C., who did not return a telephone call before press time.

Rosebrock announced the filing of his lawsuit at a March 16 press conference, on the sidewalk where the protests have taken place, in front of the locked VA gates behind which lies the land in question.  In a black U.S. Army sweatshirt with an American flag pin worn upside down below the neck, he pledged to “continue to hang the flag in distress because this property is in danger.”

Eliasberg, the ACLU lawyer, said that the VA is “really hanging the constitution upside down” by purporting to tell Rosebrock how he can express his opinion and how he cannot.

in News
Related Posts

Lawsuit Filed Against Plaza Development

September 28, 2020

September 28, 2020

Slow-growth group says City is violating Surplus Land Act By Sam Catanzaro A slow-growth group has filed a lawsuit to...

City Of Santa Monica Being Sued Over Proposed Plaza Project: Santa Monica Beat – September, 28, 2020

September 28, 2020

September 28, 2020

Local news and culture in under 5 minutes. * Santa Monica Being Sued Over Proposed Plaza Project. * LA Street...

Santa Monica Police Make Additional Arrests in Looting of REI

September 28, 2020

September 28, 2020

Marques Miles and Misty Jones arrested by Santa Monica Police Department Santa Monica police recently made additional arrests of two...

OpEd: The Miramar Project Will Be a New Architectural Jewel

September 27, 2020

September 27, 2020

The Miramar Hotel has been a central part of Santa Monica’s history and an integral part of the community for...

Edify TV: Trident Center Redevelopment

September 25, 2020

September 25, 2020

The Westside’s Trident Center is getting a major overhaul and new name as part of a flurry of development in...

Miramar Project to go Before City Council Tuesday

September 24, 2020

September 24, 2020

Councilmember Gleam Davis asks City Attorney whether she should rescue self from vote  By Sam Catanzaro  Santa Monica lawmakers will...

SMa.r.t. Column: Needed, A Heart Transplant

September 24, 2020

September 24, 2020

We have written about adaptive reuse in previous columns and have postulated that with proper incentives, the existing one, two...

Edify TV: Boulders Blocking Westside Encampment

September 24, 2020

September 24, 2020

City officials recently removed boulders placed on sidewalks by some Westside residents to prevent the formation of a homeless encampment....

Should Council Member Davis Recuse Herself From Voting? Santa Monica Beat – September, 24, 2020

September 24, 2020

September 24, 2020

Local news and culture in under 5 minutes. * Should Council Member Davis Recuse Herself From Voting? * Increases In...

SMC to Be Online for Winter and Spring 2021

September 24, 2020

September 24, 2020

College cites lack of available vaccine  By Sam Catanzaro Santa Monica College (SMC) has announced it will be delivering classes...

Edify TV: Al Fresco Program Ending?

September 24, 2020

September 24, 2020

During a COVID-19 pandemic many restaurants have found aid through the City of Los Angeles’ Al Fresco dining program, but...

Local Breweries Say They Have Been Unfairly Shuttered as County Passes Grant Program

September 24, 2020

September 24, 2020

$10 million grant program approved by Board of Supervisors  By Sam Catanzaro Will a $10 million grant program be enough...

Santa Monica Loses Vegan Restaurant

September 23, 2020

September 23, 2020

Space housing Santa Monica vegan restaurant Viva Vegan up for lease By Sam Catanzaro A vegan restaurant in Santa Monica...

Risks Posed by Wildfire Smoke

September 22, 2020

September 22, 2020

UCLA pulmonologist on how people can tell if the wildfires are making them sick By Toi Creel Even if you...

Will Los Angeles County See Another Spike in COVID-19 Cases?

September 22, 2020

September 22, 2020

County health officials keeping close eye on data this week By Sam Catanzaro Los Angeles County health officials are monitoring...