July 5, 2022 Breaking News, Latest News, and Videos

Waiving Your Rights -Pre-Employment Arbitration Abounds:

By Zach Cantor

Principal, Cantor Law

There’s something that’s spread faster than the Zika virus among most employers over these past several years. It’s called the mandatory pre-employment arbitration contract, and you probably signed one as a condition of taking a job.

Pre-employment arbitration contracts boil down to this: in any future dispute, you waive your right to take your boss to civil court and make a case before a jury. You can’t even join a class action suit against, say, hazardous working conditions or pervasive labor law violations. Instead, you’re restricted to adjudicating your dispute before an arbitrator, a single person whose decision is binding. No appeals allowed.

That sure sounds like a messed up way to start a new job. Yet the deck is stacked against you: What if you don’t sign? Can you still have the job?

It’s been an unbalanced equation. Over the past decade, the U.S. Supreme Court has favored arbitration contracts as a condition of employment. Justice Antonin Scalia was the biggest advocate of pre-employment arbitration agreements, so his death earlier this year may see the court shift its position to weigh employee’s individual rights, as well as employers, when it pertains to signing rights away.

It’s clear the U.S. Supreme Court will need to tackle the matter. Last month the 9th Circuit Court of Appeal held that workers have a substantive right to bring collective actions against their employer, therefore rendering impotent the individual arbitration contracts they signed. The National Labor Relations Board applauded the ruling, which lines up with federal labor laws. But that decision also contradicts earlier interpretations made in similar cases in three other circuit courts, saying that individual arbitration can be forced upon employees under the Federal Arbitration Act.

For years, employers have held all the cards. That might be changing.

Take the recent case of Edgar Tovar. Tovar, who is mentally handicapped, worked eight years at Ralphs/Food4Less and, until the last few months he was there, never had a black mark on his work record.

Then something went wrong. He was transferred to the deli/bakery, where he was subjected to relentless name-calling and hostility. He complained, to no avail. After his sister complained on his behalf, Tovar was fired on the pretext of eating one of the cookies he had prepared.

Tovar sued for disability discrimination, harassment and retaliation. Ralphs/Food4Less in turn filed a motion to compel arbitration, saying Tovar signed a contract when he was hired in 2006 committing himself to resolve disputes through mandatory arbitration.

The judge’s reasoning turned on the following: If Tovar was able to understand what he was signing, he’d have zero chance of taking his case to a jury. But, Tovar has a third-grade reading comprehension level. Was he capable of understanding what he signed?

Doesn’t every contract require the people signing it to be “of sound mind?” And that’s exactly the argument that persuaded a superior court judge, because the ways of measuring mental capacity have been standard for decades. On Aug. 15t, Tovar was given permission to pursue a lawsuit and have a jury decide his case.

The overall problem with most pre-employment arbitration agreements is that employers, with a lot of court backing, have had all the leverage. If a prospective employee doesn’t sign, they don’t get the job. It remains to be seen what would happen if a prospective employee wrote “signing under duress” on a pre-employment arbitration agreement.

I’m not saying companies cannot have these kinds of agreements, but they need to be considered at arm’s length, where everyone knows what’s going on, free of coercion or duress. In contracts, the “arm’s length principle” means parties in a contract stand on independent and equal footing.

Pre-employment arbitration contracts are different than similar arbitration clauses you’ve signed by downloading iTunes, opening a bank account or setting up cell phone service, which fall into the area of consumer law (and have their own problems.)

Employment is a unique context, because people’s lives are at stake. Work is not an optional thing. You can’t just choose to not work or just get another job – where you’d likely be presented with a new pre-employment arbitration contract.

Perhaps California legislators might recognize this as an issue to sink their teeth into. Who can object to putting the arm’s length principle back into pre-employment arbitration agreements?

That could happen by passing a few bills. One would explicitly allow prospective employees to opt out of signing these agreements as a condition of employment. Another would create a single, standard, state-issued arbitration form that applies to every employee and company. Make sure the form says, in reasonably large type and in bold letters, that neither side needs to consent to the agreement – and that it is not mandatory.

Until that happens, though, businesses doing the hiring will keep pushing pre-employment arbitration contracts in front of new hires.

Zachary Cantor is principal attorney of Cantor Law of Santa Monica: info@cantorlawyers.com or 213.674.0325.

in News
Related Posts

Landscaping 50 Percent Complete for George Wolfberg Park at Potrero Canyon

July 3, 2022

July 3, 2022

Officials provide update for park under construction By Dolores Quintana A recent update from the City of Los Angeles’ Department...

John McEnroe and Patty Smyth Sell Malibu Home for $29 Million

July 2, 2022

July 2, 2022

Malibu Colony home sold to unknown buyer in private sale By Dolores Quintana John McEnroe, a retired former tennis star,...

SMa.r.t. Column: A Tale of Two Cities

July 2, 2022

July 2, 2022

The City of Santa Monica is surrounded on three sides by the City of Los Angeles. Therefore, while the jurisdictions...

Santa Monica City Council Approves Ballot Measure That Would Increase Hotel Bed Tax

July 1, 2022

July 1, 2022

Santa Monica’s bed tax has been raised since 2004 By Dolores Quintana In a vote on June 28, the Santa...

PETA Attempts to Stop the Beach Club From Holding Annual Fireworks Display

July 1, 2022

July 1, 2022

Parking lot where display is held is on City of LA land, not Santa Monica, allowing Club to obtain permit...

Santa Monica-Malibu Unified School District Prepares for SMASH/Muir Campus Mold Removal

June 30, 2022

June 30, 2022

Exact costs for repairs still unknown By Dolores Quintana and Sam Catanzaro  It is unknown exactly how much the total...

Watering Restrictions for Santa Monica Residents Take Effect Soon

June 30, 2022

June 30, 2022

New restrictions will go into effect on July 5, limiting watering to twice a week By Sam Catanzaro New restrictions...

Daily Harvest Recalls Meal Kits Handed out at Venice Event Following 470 Cases of Mysterious Illness

June 30, 2022

June 30, 2022

Direct-to-consumer meal kit company under fire for handling of outbreak tied to lentil and leek meal kit By Sam Catanzaro...

Central Coast Brewery Makes Westside Acquisitions

June 29, 2022

June 29, 2022

Figueroa Mountain Brewing acquires Broxton Brewery, The Stalking Horse and more. Staff, current beer taps to remain on board at...

Mexican Restaurant Possibly Expanding Into Former Swingers Space

June 29, 2022

June 29, 2022

Bar Hermanito applies for an alcohol exemption sales permit for space at 802 Broadway in Santa Monica By Dolores Quintana...

Six Family-Fun Westside Fourth of July Events

June 29, 2022

June 29, 2022

Fireworks, parades, runs and more taking place across the Westside  By Ashley Sloan  Pacific Palisades  The Pacific Palisades will be...

California Credit Union Awards Grant to Santa Monica Teacher

June 29, 2022

June 29, 2022

Building electric circuit friendship detectors and applying engineering principles to solve real world problems are Westside school projects receiving funding...

Santa Monica’s Building Bridges Art Exchange Presents: J.J. Martin’s “Role Models”

June 28, 2022

June 28, 2022

A traveling exhibit in partnership with Indianilla Cultural Center, Mexico City and Real de Catorce Cultural Center, Real de Catorce,...

Santa Monica City Council Approves New Rules to Streamline Meetings

June 28, 2022

June 28, 2022

Pilot program will run through end of year By Dolores Quintana At the Santa Monica City Council meeting on June...

Banning Construction of New Gas Stations in Los Angeles?

June 28, 2022

June 28, 2022

Motion from LA City Councilmember Paul Koretz calls for banning the building of any new gas pumping facilities By Sam...