August 9, 2025 Breaking News, Latest News, and Videos

Pico Calls for Voting: Change Santa Monica’s At-Large Council Elections Face Competing Lawsuits

By Jennifer Eden

 

A legal battle contesting at-large elections in Santa Monica is currently underway, with an initial lawsuit from Pico Neighborhood Association (PNA) and Maria Loya this week receiving a summary judgement request from the City of Santa Monica.

The initial lawsuit calls for the abolition of at-large elections in Santa Monica, claiming that marginalized communities have not received representation on City Council and decision-making bodies.

“There has been a long history of racial injustice in Santa Monica,” lawsuit plaintiff Maria Loya told The Mirror. “Many people forget that the Pico Neighborhood was created by land-use policies, restrictive covenants and red-lining to ensure that people of color were segregated in a particular area within Santa Monica. This type of social engineering was solidified by the creation of at-large elections in 1947 which made it virtually impossible to successfully elect a person of color to the City Council.”

Plaintiffs are calling for neighborhood-based representation and voting, which would see Santa Monica divided into council districts in a similar vein to Los Angeles City.

Santa Monica City, however, claims that representation of all neighborhoods is currently fair in the at-large system; stating that from a 13 percent Latino/a voting population in Santa Monica, 28.5 percent, or two of the current seven sitting City Councilmembers, are Latino/a.

One of the sitting Latino members, Gleam Davis, agrees with the City’s stance. “In a relatively small city such as Santa Monica, I think it is a better system when all seven members of the council, not just one, are accountable to every Santa Monica voter,” Councilmember Davis told The Mirror. Davis’ birth father hails from Jalisco, Mexico, and she believes that dividing the city into districts as opposed to at-large elections, “will reduce transparency and increase horse-trading among the councilmembers, “deals will be made outside of the view of the public”.

“Never has a person of color who resides in the Pico Neighborhood been elected to serve on the City Council,” retorted Loya. “How is that fair?”

According to the City, at-large elections have been in place in Santa Monica for more than a century, “voters have twice affirmed the at-large election system – in 1975 (rejecting failed Proposition 3) and in 2002 (rejecting failed Measure HH).”

“It is impossible to create a Latino/a-majority district in Santa Monica,” the City stated, “the creation of any district designed to concentrate Latino/a voters would actually have the opposite result – isolating the majority of Latino/a voters outside of that district.”

Loya disagrees: “Residents of color from the Pico Neighborhood have run multiple times for City Council in order to challenge these policies and practices but the at large election system diluted the votes of Pico Neighborhood residents. The impact this has had on our quality of life has been harmful.”

A hearing on the motion is currently scheduled for June 14, 2018. If the court grants the City’s motion, it will end the lawsuit. If the court denies the motion, the case will proceed to trial.

Pico youth advocate fairness at a recent CRJ meeting.
Photo: Pico Youth and Family Center.
<>Related Posts

County Launches Mental Health Initiative for Veterans

August 9, 2025

August 9, 2025

The program is designed to eliminate barriers to mental health services by offering veterans direct access to free emotional support,...

Mural “The Healing Fields” Unveiled in LA as Part of Anti-Hate Campaign

August 9, 2025

August 9, 2025

The mural was created with the help of community healers and formerly incarcerated leaders, including Tobias Tubbs and Kenneth Webb,...

California Partners with Tech Giants to Boost AI Workforce

August 9, 2025

August 9, 2025

The partnerships aim to prepare students from high schools to California State Universities for careers in artificial intelligence and other...

Santa Monica Public Library Announces September Events

August 9, 2025

August 9, 2025

Among the events is Puppets in the Library, classes on how to write engaging scenes, celebrations of Hispanic Heritage Month,...

Live Like Braun Memorial Tournament Honors Athlete’s Life on His Birthday on August 9

August 8, 2025

August 8, 2025

Players and Community Members Will Gather to Celebrate Braun Levi’s Life Friends, family, and supporters of the late Braun Levi...

Los Angeles Youth Orchestra to Hold Auditions for 25-26 Season

August 8, 2025

August 8, 2025

The orchestra’s upcoming season includes Fall and Spring concerts at venues such as Pasadena’s Ambassador Auditorium and Barnum Hall in...

Pepperdine Crash Defendant Hires High-Profile Attorney, Pleads Not Guilty

August 8, 2025

August 8, 2025

Fraser Michael Bohm Now Represented by Celebrity Defense Lawyer  Facing multiple murder and manslaughter charges, Malibu resident Fraser Michael Bohm...

Boil Water Notice Issued for Parts of Malibu After Construction Disruption

August 8, 2025

August 8, 2025

 Caltrans Bridge Work Triggers Precautionary Advisory Residents in sections of Malibu are being urged to boil tap water before use...

Big Blue Bus Returns to Palisades This Weekend

August 8, 2025

August 8, 2025

The Route 9 reinstatement is part of a larger set of service changes taking effect After months of limited operations,...

Providence Relocates Palisades Clinics to Santa Monica

August 8, 2025

August 8, 2025

The relocated clinics are now accepting both existing and new patients Providence has permanently relocated its primary care and pediatric...

Film Review: The Naked Gun

August 7, 2025

August 7, 2025

FILM REVIEWTHE NAKED GUNRated PG-1385 MinutesReleased August 1st   The Naked Gun plays to high expectations due to its historic legacy,...

Children’s Hospital to Expand Pediatric Orthopedic Services in Santa Monica with $10M Gift

August 7, 2025

August 7, 2025

The funding will support expanded clinic space, new equipment, and the recruitment of additional orthopedic specialists in Santa Monica Children’s...

‘Dad Bod’ Contest Comes to Venice Restaurant This Weekend

August 7, 2025

August 7, 2025

The competition will unfold over three themed rounds: a beachwear walk, a tongue-in-cheek “talent show,” and a final flex-off judged...

City Preps for Return of SaMoHi, Pali High Students by Boosting Safety

August 7, 2025

August 7, 2025

Efforts to ensure student safety include reactivating school crossing guards, completing pedestrian safety upgrades, and promoting free public transit As...

Hot Dog on a Stick and Santa Monica Brew Works Team Up for Santa Monica’s Dog Days of Summer

August 7, 2025

August 7, 2025

Dog-Friendly Event in Santa Monica Supports Local Rescue Group  Santa Monica’s four-legged residents will get their day in the sun...