September 26, 2020 Breaking News, Latest News, and Videos

Anti-Airport Activists Footed With $31,525 Anti-SLAPP Legal Bill:

A Santa Monica-based group of anti-airport activists have been left to personally foot the legal bill of failed lawsuits against the filers of Measure D on the November 2014 election ballot and the City of Santa Monica.

Measure D was filed on March 27, 2014 as “an initiative measure amending the City charter to require voter approval in order to close all or part of the Santa Monica airport, change use of the airport land, or impose new restrictions on fuel sales or use of aviation facilities,” according to smvote.org.

A small group of anti-airport activists, known as the Santa Monica Eleven accused Measure D filers of “massive cheating” on an ensuing signature collection drive, “in clear violation of several Election Code provisions,” according to activist and attorney Jonathan Stein.

“So we filed a lawsuit, figuring we would have a fair shot at keeping this bad faith measure off the November 2014 ballot,” Stein said. “We did not anticipate that the City Attorney would side 100 percent with the Measure D proponents instead of investigating them.”

The Eleven believed that the Court would take action against what they felt were illegal practices by the signature gatherers and the unclear wording in Measure D, Santa Monica Eleven member Alan Levenson explained.

“We felt Measure D was a tricky sleight of hand sponsored by out of town money and interests claiming to be a bunch of honest Santa Monicans,” Levenson said.

The plaintiffs in the case sought to block Measure D from being placed on the November ballot after it lawfully qualified, replied attorney David Shaby II.

“That in effect is a restriction on our basic freedom of speech, expression and the electorate process and is referred to as a SLAPP, Strategic Litigation Against Public Participation, suit,” he explained.

The law states that if a SLAPP lawsuit is brought, the defendant can require the plaintiff to prove up his case in a motion to dismiss, which is known as an Anti-SLAPP motion or suit, Shaby added.

The initial lawsuit was filed the Santa Monica Eleven on May 9, 2014, against Santa Monica’s City Clerk, City Attorney, City Council, and three individual proponents of a the charter amendment, according to legal website lawzilla.com.

“Santa Monica City used four lawyers with over 80 years of public law experience to sink our little boat,” Stein said.

“I was working for free. If you were there for oral argument, as many of the Santa Monica Eleven were, you would have seen that 80 percent of the written motion papers, and 80 percent of the oral arguments, came from the City Attorney, not the proponents of Measure D,” he added.

Consisting of largely middle class homeowners and long-time renters, of limited financial means, the Santa Monica Eleven “bravely stood up to defend their neighborhood and the actions of an unanimous City Council,” Stein explained.

Failing to prove their case, the Eleven are now faced with paying the defendants’ attorneys’ fees against them.

“The City Attorney led the briefing and the oral argument on two anti-SLAPP motions and they were granted by the Court,” according to Stein. “The motion entitled the proponents’ private law firm to collect its fees, which were stated at over $74,000. I filed two motions and responses that were granted by the Court, which cut the fee bill to $31,000.”

Acting in a personal capacity, Mayor Kevin McKeown also petitioned the court in a letter dated January 23, 2015.

“If the court could find a way in which justice could be served without imposition of exceptionally punitive fees on these civic-minded citizens, your mercy would be greatly appreciated,” McKeown wrote.

Santa Monica City waived their right to collect fees from the plaintiffs.

“The taxpayers of Santa Monica should be outraged,” Shaby said. “The Santa Monica City Attorney and the City Clerk were sued by the plaintiffs in this case. Why should the hard earned tax dollars, which went to pay for Santa Monica’s defense be waived? The tax payers should be reimbursed.”

Just because people may not like what a ballot provision stands for, they should not dictate whether it should be put to the people or not, Shaby said.

“To award the plaintiffs by not collecting the attorney’s fees would just motivate them to attempt to trample on the rights of others in the future,” he added.

In a letter that he prepared to be read in front of the judge in court, Levenson said that most of the Eleven had never heard of a SLAPP suit or an Anti-SLAPP Motion.

“We believed the scales of justice would weigh in our favor. We believed we were acting as responsible adults whose efforts would have a positive effect on our families, our neighbors, and ourselves,” he said.

As of today, the Santa Monica Eleven have elected to pay the $31,525 and to bring the matter to a close.

A fundraising effort has been set up to help defray the legal costs, with the balance being footed by the plaintiffs themselves. To donate go to: http://bit.ly/11-SM-Residents

“Unfortunately, things do not always turn out as planned,” Levenson concluded.

in News
Related Posts

Edify TV: Trident Center Redevelopment

September 25, 2020

September 25, 2020

The Westside’s Trident Center is getting a major overhaul and new name as part of a flurry of development in...

Miramar Project to go Before City Council Tuesday

September 24, 2020

September 24, 2020

Councilmember Gleam Davis asks City Attorney whether she should rescue self from vote  By Sam Catanzaro  Santa Monica lawmakers will...

SMa.r.t. Column: Needed, A Heart Transplant

September 24, 2020

September 24, 2020

We have written about adaptive reuse in previous columns and have postulated that with proper incentives, the existing one, two...

Edify TV: Boulders Blocking Westside Encampment

September 24, 2020

September 24, 2020

City officials recently removed boulders placed on sidewalks by some Westside residents to prevent the formation of a homeless encampment....

Should Council Member Davis Recuse Herself From Voting? Santa Monica Beat – September, 24, 2020

September 24, 2020

September 24, 2020

Local news and culture in under 5 minutes. * Should Council Member Davis Recuse Herself From Voting? * Increases In...

SMC to Be Online for Winter and Spring 2021

September 24, 2020

September 24, 2020

College cites lack of available vaccine  By Sam Catanzaro Santa Monica College (SMC) has announced it will be delivering classes...

Edify TV: Al Fresco Program Ending?

September 24, 2020

September 24, 2020

During a COVID-19 pandemic many restaurants have found aid through the City of Los Angeles’ Al Fresco dining program, but...

Local Breweries Say They Have Been Unfairly Shuttered as County Passes Grant Program

September 24, 2020

September 24, 2020

$10 million grant program approved by Board of Supervisors  By Sam Catanzaro Will a $10 million grant program be enough...

Santa Monica Loses Vegan Restaurant

September 23, 2020

September 23, 2020

Space housing Santa Monica vegan restaurant Viva Vegan up for lease By Sam Catanzaro A vegan restaurant in Santa Monica...

Risks Posed by Wildfire Smoke

September 22, 2020

September 22, 2020

UCLA pulmonologist on how people can tell if the wildfires are making them sick By Toi Creel Even if you...

Will Los Angeles County See Another Spike in COVID-19 Cases?

September 22, 2020

September 22, 2020

County health officials keeping close eye on data this week By Sam Catanzaro Los Angeles County health officials are monitoring...

Edify TV: Santa Monica Fire Department Fighting Blazes Across State

September 21, 2020

September 21, 2020

The Santa Monica Fire Department has been busy helping combat wildfires burning throughout the state. Learn more in this video...

Lawmakers and Residents Take Steps Towards Police Reform

September 21, 2020

September 21, 2020

Santa Monica residents will soon have more control of policing after local lawmakers took significant steps to reform the Santa...

2020 Census Due September 30th: Santa Monica Beat – September, 21, 2020

September 21, 2020

September 21, 2020

Local news and culture in under 5 minutes. * 2020 Census Due September 30th * Bobcat Fire Reaches Historical Size...

UCLA Medical Center, Santa Monica Offers Free “Living With Diabetes” Zoom Patient Conference

September 21, 2020

September 21, 2020

By Staff Writer Although the novel coronavirus has dominated the health space this year, other diseases — like diabetes —...